Trump’s Tax Reform Proposal ‘Leaves Door Open’ to Repeal ITC/PTC

The tax reform package released at the end of September by White House and Republican leadership “left the door open” to repeal critical existing renewable energy tax credits prior to their scheduled either expiration or phase down, Gregory Jenner, partner at Stoel Rives, told Renewable Energy World.

“They are going to be looking everywhere for revenue, and the renewable energy industry would be very wise to not take for granted the good will of the tax writing committees,” Jenner said, adding that industry leadership should get tax writers on record as saying they will not touch the investment tax credit (ITC) and production tax credit (PTC).

Jenner worked as a technical staffer in the Senate to help write the Tax Reform Act of 1986 — the last major tax reform package passed in the U.S. He also served as both Acting Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Treasury for Tax Policy in 2004 and Deputy Assistant Secretary for Tax Policy  from 2002 to 2004.  

An ‘Ugly’ Process

He said that he is not optimistic that a reform package will be agreed upon before the end of the year.

“Depending on what the process looks like, and depending on how they try to raise revenue, this could be a pretty ugly process,” he said. “People have no idea what they are facing.”

According to Jenner, Trump’s reform package presents other less obvious issues for the renewable energy industry than the potential loss of the ITC/PTC.

“Even if they don’t get rid of the ITC/PTC or phase it down earlier, there’s a chilling effect in the marketplace just because of the possibility that they could,” he said.

Uncertainty about the future availability of tax credits could hinder investment deals for renewable energy projects.

Jenner said that forcing tax writers to commit to leaving tax credits alone in the reform process will give investors the confidence they need to move forward.

“Another hidden twist — and there’s not much you can do about — is the effect of the lowering of the corporate tax rate,” he said.

The reform package released in September proposes lowering the top corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 20 percent.

“The renewable energy industry depends on outside investment — tax equity investment — and a lot of that tax equity investment is priced according to the corporate tax rate that’s in effect — particularly for depreciation,” Jenner said.

A dollar of depreciation deduction at a 35 percent rate is worth a lot more than a dollar of depreciation at a 20 percent rate, he added.

“Investors are not going to be caught short — assuming 35 percent and then having it drop to 20 percent,” Jenner said. “They are going to assume 20,” and then figure out how to reverse it if it becomes 25 or 30 percent.

While the Trump Administration and Congressional Republicans are pushing to pass a new tax plan this year, there is a long road ahead, including turning the original reform proposal into full legislation from both the Senate and the House, and then reconciling both pieces of legislation.

Lead image credit:

Previous articleAre Hurricanes Correcting Global Warming?
Next articleSecretary of Energy Moves to Save Coal: The Art of the Squeal
Jennifer Delony, analyst for TransmissionHub, started her career as a B2B news editor in the local and long-distance telecommunications industries in the '90s. Jennifer began covering renewable energy issues at the local level in 2005 and covered U.S. and Canadian utility-scale wind energy as editor of North American Windpower magazine from 2006-2009. She also provides analysis for the oil and natural gas sectors as editor of Oilman Magazine.

No posts to display