Last week New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman wrote another of his “Wow, China is awesome!” columns. This one is about how the Chinese are on top of climate change while the Americans are so caught up in partisan bickering that they have allowed an opportunity to slip out of their hands.
So far, so good. Nothing to disagree with there, at least as far as his impression of the US is concerned.
But Friedman takes comments by Peggy Liu (of JUCCCE) that the Chinese are running various clean energy pilot projects as a signal that the Chinese are serious about cleaning up their environment.
This is where I have to part ways with Tom. As someone who has, for the past 16 years, lived in or traveled frequently to China — not just the big cities, but the countryside as well — I can only verify that things have become worse, not better. There are many things China could have been doing for the past decade or so to clean up its environment or to reduce its carbon footprint, but it hasn’t done any of them. I’m sorry, I like China, I love the people, but the place is filthy. ::continue::
Still Friedman manages to make one valid connection — that China’s clean energy efforts are all about “J-O-B-S”. He’s pretty close on that one, but while J-O-B-S are certainly a nice side-effect, it’s really more about M-O-N-E-Y. I’ve made these same assertions before on the ChinaBizGov blog:
Ultimately, Beijing sees great opportunity in the climate change movement. But contrary to outward appearances, the opportunity for China lies, not in cleaning up its environment, but in selling related technologies to foreigners.
Clean technology will be expensive, and a country facing a demographic time bomb in a decade or so cannot afford to waste a single percentage point in GDP growth to clean up its environment. China will, however, be more than happy to sell the necessary technology to those countries that are already on the bandwagon.
But don’t take my word for it. Let’s see how the Chinese government describes what it is doing. The following is a summary from China’s 2009 Auto Industry Yearbook (a government publication) summing up the purpose of China’s pursuit of “new energy vehicles”:
The hope of the new energy vehicle industry is that it will provide China with an opportunity to overtake countries with advanced auto industries … the hope is that, in the division of labor in the new energy vehicle industry, [China] can earn more profit.
While this is just part of the summary paragraph, there’s nothing in the the entire section on “new energy vehicles” about climate change or environmental protection. Though the term “energy saving” is used once or twice.
The point here is not to pile on China and accuse it of being duplicitous. China is actually being very clear about what it wants. The problem is when the Tom Friedmans of the world fly into Beijing, stay in five-star hotels and then proceed to interpret Chinese actions through their own worldview.
I think it’s great that China is undertaking all of these pilot projects. This work desperately needs to be done, and much more could be done in the US if our political leaders were more focused on the good of the country than they are on their careers (and if voters would punish them for it).
But it is way too early to draw the conclusion that China is concerned about climate change. This is a country that is concerned more about growth than anything else. If things continue on their current course, China will get what it wants: M-O-N-E-Y.
And they’ll continue to get it from the US.