The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News & Information
Sign In or Register
Renewable Energy World Logo
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
  • Sections
    • Home
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Solar
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Wind
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Geothermal
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Bio
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Hydro
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Careers
    • Companies
      • Company Directory
      • Press Releases
      • Products
      • Events Calendar
      • White Papers
    • Webcasts
      • Upcoming Webcasts
      • Featured Webcasts
      • Archived Webcasts
      • Events Calendar
    • White Papers
    • Magazines
      • Renewable Energy World
      • Wind Technology
      • Large Scale Solar
      • Hydro Review
      • HRW - Hydro Review Worldwide
      • Renewable Energy World (North America Edition)
      • Photovoltaics World
    • Awards
  • Account
    • Sign In
    • Register
  • Search
Don't Miss The Great Solar Debate: Where Does the Global Solar Industry Stand? Click Here to Register! ×

German Compromise Limits Power-Price Increases, Ensures Election-Year Battle

Tino Andresen and Brian Parkin, Bloomberg
February 15, 2013  |  11 Comments

Germany's environment and economy ministers, coalition partners from different parties who have clashed over the country's shift from nuclear power, forged a joint plan to slow power-price increases caused by subsidies for renewable energy.

The agreement by Environment Minister Peter Altmaier and Economy Minister Philipp Roesler includes reduced compensation for both existing and new renewable sites and fewer exceptions for energy-intensive companies, Altmaier's ministry said in a statement. The proposals limit the surcharge consumers pay for funding renewables to 5.28 euro cents (7.04 cents) a kilowatt-hour next year and an annual increase to 2.5 percent in future.

The deal, which would save consumers an estimated 1.86 billion euros in 2014, sets up an election-year conflict between Chancellor Angela Merkel's government and opposition-controlled states, which can block the changes in the upper house. Both ministers are holding talks with regional officials today.

"The states have to look very carefully at whether they want to back or reject this brake on power prices," Roesler said today on ARD television. "Whoever refuses the model will be politically responsible for any further price increase."

Law This Year

The cost of Merkel's decision made following the Fukushima disaster to shutter atomic plants in favor of renewables such as solar and wind power is becoming a campaign theme before the Sept. 22 elections. Roesler said the "way is now open" for legislation before the election.

The planned subsidy cuts may "throttle" renewables expansion by curbing investment, the Berlin-based BEE renewable energy federation said in a statement after the proposals were announced. Merkel should instead cut energy tax that comprises about 25 percent of power prices, the BEE said.

Germany wants to more than triple the share of renewables in the energy mix by 2050 as it phases out nuclear generation. The scale of the energy transformation, the most dramatic overhaul since World War II, and the risks it carries to Europe's biggest economy has moved the soaring cost of electricity to the center of the political and economic agenda.

Germany's four electricity grid operators said in October that consumers would shoulder an average increase in subsidies for renewables of 47 percent per kilowatt-hour this year.

Solar Panels

While it was a coalition government of Social Democrats and the Green Party that first legislated to shutter all Germany's nuclear plants, they oppose aspects of Merkel's energy overhaul. Now in opposition, the SPD and Greens used their majority in the upper house, the Bundesrat, to block a law last year lowering subsidies to the solar industry, saying that the reduced tariffs put panel makers at risk. The legislation was passed after going to a mediation committee. The SPD says that the latest government moves will slow the expansion of renewables.

The planned savings, if agreed by the opposition-controlled states, may lower the estimated 20.36 billion euros that Germans are set to pay this year for electricity from renewable sources. Electricity companies are compelled to pay for power from solar plants and wind parks that is tapped into the national grid, the costs of which are then passed on to consumers and industry.

Altmaier proposed a shift in clean-energy expansion costs last month to producers from consumers to stem the price surge. Roesler, who leads the pro-business Free Democratic Party, Merkel's junior coalition partner, had resisted the change.

Consumers could face a 10 percent increase in the renewables surcharge next fall without any action, Altmaier said in an interview with Phoenix television. The government proposes limiting any rise to 2.5 percent per year. "A lot of citizens are prepared to pay that for the energy overhaul," he said.

Lead image: Negotiation highway sign, via Shutterstock

11 Comments

Register To Comment
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
February 16, 2013
Germany's high electricity prices started well before renewables and closing down reactors came into the game.

From a 2009 Economist article about the high price of electricity:

"The main reason Germany's electricity market is not working as it should is the lack of competition."

"A second problem is that Germany's biggest electricity generators also own the networks that distribute electricity. Critics argue that this gives them a huge advantage over independent producers..."

"... over the longer run, ambitious plans to increase the share of electricity from renewable sources may erode the dominance of the country's four biggest electricity generators. Germany hopes to get as much as 30% of its electricity from renewable sources by 2020, and although few in the industry think the target will be met, there is nevertheless likely to be a huge investment in new generating capacity over the coming decades."

http://www.economist.com/node/13527440

And then more recent info...

"Renewable Energy generated almost 26% of the total electricity demand in Germany during the first half of 2012. ... That's a massive increase compared to 20.56%, the percentage during the same period in 2011"

http://cleantechnica.com/2012/07/26/germany-26-of-electricity-from-renewable-energy-in-1st-half-of-2012/

Looks like a bunch of volks in the industry are going to be dining on crow.
Tim Dolan
Tim Dolan
February 16, 2013
I note that Germans are paying about 35 cents (.25983 Euro) per kWh, so 7 cents is the equivalent of 2.2 cents per kWh for average electricity in the US.

Not quite as bad when you consider their overall price for electricity, especially knowing that in the long-term it will keep it from growing any more and may actually eventually lower the price.

If I knew that if I paid even 3 cents more on what I pay to day, that my price will never go up for at least 40 years and I would get significant secondary benefits like better energy security, air quality and better storm survivability, I would be good with that.

Of course I already have solar on my roof, so i already did the up front cost thing.
ANONYMOUS
February 16, 2013
Best fossil fuel subsidy in the US is master limited partnerships. No corporate taxes. Fantastic hussle.
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
February 16, 2013
"No business model that requires a subsidy to exist is a sustainable energy."

We've been subsidizing the fossil fuel industry for 100 years.

We've been subsidizing the nuclear industry for more than 60 years.

--

BTW, both solar and wind will likely not be subsidized in the US after 2017/2018. Neither will need subsidies. They are on track to be very competitive against subsidized fossil and nuclear electricity.
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
February 16, 2013
Solar is causing the wholesale price of electricity to plummet on sunny days. The price of electricity which would otherwise be the most expensive is becoming the cheapest.

http://cleantechnica.com/2012/03/23/german-solar-bringing-down-price-of-afternoon-electricity-big-time-more-charts-facts/

"(A) recent study by Germany's Institute for Future Energy Systems (IZES), conducted on behalf of of the German Solar Industry Association (BSW-Solar), has found that, on average, solar power has reduced the price of electricity 10% in Germany (on the EPEX exchange). It reduces prices up to 40% in the early afternoon, when electricity demand is peaking and electricity typically costs the most. There's a visual of that (in German) here:"

http://s.tt/15C72

That means that Germans are already getting a great return on the extra small amount of money they are currently paying for electricity. A 10% price drop almost covers the subsidy paid. And prices will fall more as more panels are installed.

All those panels they have helped install will continue to provide them with cheap electricity for decades.

--

Those cheap wholesale prices are not currently being passed on to customers, but that's not a problem solar (or wind) has caused. It's a problem with the German utility industry which is for all practical purposes a monopoly.

That's where German voters need to focus. They need to kick the fossil fuel industry people out of their government and put in people who will treat them fairly.
Peter Turrell
Peter Turrell
February 16, 2013
If you think I am the only one you obviously do not live here and you obviously do not understand the importance of liabilities and that the bank and insurance perspectives trump philosophy. Some countries may have no other assets but Ontario is rich in hydro resources. Perhaps this forum should publish the German insurance companies view.
John Alexander
John Alexander
February 16, 2013
Yes, better them than us as I see it. Will be interesting to watch how it evolves and how it affects their economy and whether special interests can change the debate. The German public does seem to have a very high tolerance for taxation as long as it is not used to support neighboring economies. They seem to have reached the end of their rope on that one.

All modern economies may some day conclude that decentralization of the electric grid is all too real to ignore and the sooner they work toward that goal the more efficient their economies will become in the long run.

In the short term each society has to make the choice between lower cost dangerous technologies and less efficient safe but more costly alternative energy. German people have spoken that they don't want a Fukishima in the Vaterland but will special interests and the citizens pocketbook change the debate? The average German citizen has far more political clout than the average Japanese citizen and its doubtful there would be one operating German nuke plant if Germany were a volcanic island.
ANONYMOUS
February 16, 2013
Maybe your are the only one who thinks its a bad direction?

"I am shocked how few in the industry comment on this bad direction"
ANONYMOUS
February 16, 2013
Most typically wouldn't run a cost benefit analysis for a year period but it does make for good drama. I suspect the free fuel benefit in Europe for then next 30 years has an upside.
Peter Turrell
Peter Turrell
February 16, 2013
Ontario Canada will go bankrupt over wind energy as banks and insurance companies are now waking up to the reality that landowners now hold toxic assets. I anticipate mass lawsuits in the future. The wind model could not exist here without fascist rules that crush property rights and the democratic process in rural communities. No business model that requires a subsidy to exist is a sustainable energy. I consider that the renewable energy lobby support for this behaviour will harm the entire industry and I am shocked how few in the industry comment on this bad direction. The next election here may crush the renewable energy industry as a backlash to the poor implimentation and this will not attract intelligent investors. The cheap wind model has severly undermined solar investment and is now being seen by the public as way to fleece public money into private hands.
Cliff Claven
Cliff Claven
February 16, 2013
7 cent/kWh to fund renewables. Wow. The ultimate economic anti-stimulus package. Thanks for being the canary in the coal mine, Germany. Renewable portfolios have already crushed Spain and Italy and Greece and are squashing the Netherlands. We are all watching to see how far this madness will go before it brings down the strongest economy in Europe as well.

Add Your Comments

To add your comments you must sign-in or create a free account.

  • Create a Free Account!
  • Sign-In
Stay Connected
         
To register for our free e-Newsletters, create your free account here:

Editors' Picks

  • America's Real Problem with Solar Energy
  • US, Australian Companies Taking Giant Steps for Global EGS Geothermal
  • EU Debate Over Climate Change Policy Could Dampen Renewable Energy Growth
  • Wind Power — Even without the Wind
  • Massachusetts Resets Its Solar Energy Bar, Four Years Early

Most Commented

  • 13
    Fracking and Solar: Friends, Foes or the Bridge to Clean Energy Adoption?
  • 12
    Breakdown: Penetration of Renewable Energy in Selected Markets
  • 7
    San Antonio Solar Fans Delay Introduction of SunCredit Program
  • 6
    Renewable Energy Research Initiative Launched in UK

Total Access Partners

Growing Your Business? Learn More about Total Access
  • Green Power Conferences
  • SolarReviews
  • Festo
  • SolarEdge Technologies
  • Valentin Software, Inc - providing Solar Design Software
  • Fairtrade-Messe
  • Leybold Optics
  • RevoluSun
News
  • Renewable Energy
  • Solar Energy
  • Wind Energy
  • Bioenergy
  • Geothermal Energy
  • Hyrdo Power
  • Blogs
  • Video
  • Finance
Resources
  • Companies
  • Products
  • Careers
  • Events
  • Webcasts
  • White Papers
  • Magazines
  • Press Releases
  • e-Newsletters
Company
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising & Services
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Site Map
Network Partners - Magazines
  • Hydro Review Magazine
  • Hydro Review Worldwide Magazine
  • Renewable Energy World Magazine
Network Partners - Events
  • Power-Gen International
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India
  • HydroVision International
  • HydroVision Brazil
  • HydroVision India
  • HydroVision Russia
© Copyright 1999-2013 RenewableEnergyWorld.com - All rights reserved.
RenewableEnergyWorld.com - World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for news & Information