The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News & Information
Sign In or Register
Renewable Energy World Logo
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
  • Sections
    • Home
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Solar
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Wind
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Geothermal
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Bio
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Hydro
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Careers
    • Companies
      • Company Directory
      • Press Releases
      • Products
      • Events Calendar
      • White Papers
    • Webcasts
      • Upcoming Webcasts
      • Featured Webcasts
      • Archived Webcasts
      • Events Calendar
    • White Papers
    • Magazines
      • Renewable Energy World
      • Wind Technology
      • Large Scale Solar
      • Hydro Review
      • HRW - Hydro Review Worldwide
      • Renewable Energy World (North America Edition)
      • Photovoltaics World
    • Awards
  • Account
    • Sign In
    • Register
  • Search
Don't Miss The Great Solar Debate: Where Does the Global Solar Industry Stand? Click Here to Register! ×

In Germany and Elsewhere, Energy Storage is Key to Unlocking Renewable Energy

Stefan Nicola, Bloomberg
August 27, 2012  |  20 Comments

For Michael Specht, the solution to Germany's future energy needs lies in a rectangular framework of steel pipes and valves the size of a VW campervan parked on the outskirts of Stuttgart.

“We’ll need this technology if we want to make Germany’s energy switch a success,” Specht, a head of department at the ZSW Center for Solar Energy and Hydrogen Research, said last month on a tour of the facility where the energy-storing device is based. “The question isn’t if it’ll be deployed, but when.”

Specht is one of an army of researchers working to overcome the technological challenges posed by Chancellor Angela Merkel’s decision to abandon nuclear power and shift to renewables in the biggest energy-infrastructure overhaul since World War II. Their task is to fill the energy gap when atomic plants that accounted for about 20 percent of Germany’s power early last year go offline within a decade.

As executives from EON AG to Siemens AG join government officials to discuss the implications of the energy switch at a conference in Berlin today, the challenge for Merkel is to keep the lights burning and energy affordable. The risk is her energy policy fuels a second crisis as she grapples with financial turmoil from Greece that’s raging across the euro region.

“The energy overhaul is an epic project that will span many decades,” said Claudia Kemfert, chief energy expert at the Berlin-based DIW economic institute. She estimates at least 200 billion euros ($250 billion) of public and private investment will be needed over 10 years to compensate for nuclear. If Merkel manages it smartly, it’ll bring “economic advantages, raise competiveness and create jobs,” Kemfert said.

Election Year

The alternative is disruption to Europe’s biggest economy and higher power prices. With plans to fast-track construction of unpopular power lines and consumers being warned to expect steeper bills to pay for renewables in 2013, an election year, energy policy looks set to join the euro crisis as a campaign theme standing between Merkel and a third term.

The opposition Social Democrats and Green Party, which drew up the nuclear phase-out in 2002 when in coalition together, accuse her government of a lack of commitment to the project after its sudden conversion to renewables following the tsunami and nuclear disaster at Fukushima in Japan. They say Merkel isn’t going far or fast enough, and that by giving her blessing to some new coal-fired plants, she favors utilities’ interests over those of consumers and the renewables industry.

‘Major Consequences’

Peter Altmaier, the minister in charge of the overhaul, is candid about the high stakes of getting it right. Failure to deliver “would have major consequences for prosperity, economic growth and employment,” he said in an Aug. 16 statement.

Almost 18 months after Merkel announced she was shuttering Germany’s atomic plants by 2022, turning her energy policy on its head, the government is funding a research boom to ensure that Indian-style blackouts don’t happen in Germany. EON and RWE AG, Germany’s two biggest utilities, are among the companies on board after a combined 26.8 billion euros was wiped off their combined share value last year as they were forced to overhaul their operations to curb losses from closing reactors early.

Research is focusing on a major downside of renewables: unlike nuclear energy, solar panels and wind turbines leave consumers without power when the wind doesn’t blow or the sun doesn’t shine. That makes storing energy key to their use.

Sixty energy-storage projects have been singled out for a total of 200 million euros in research grants through 2014. The government is also mobilizing the state-owned bank, KfW Group, to provide low-interest loans to storage projects.

‘No Way Round’

“Electricity storage really is the holy grail for the German energy transformation,” Dieter Manz, the chief executive officer of Manz AG, a German engineering company interested in battery equipment technology, said in an interview. “There’s no way around it if we want to make things work.”

That’s where Specht’s box in Stuttgart comes in. It uses electricity and carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas blamed for global warming, to turn water into methane that can be stored in underground caverns for days or weeks, then burned in gas plants when needed.

Volkswagen AG’s luxury-car division Audi is building a 6 megawatt industrial-sized plant based on the technology that’s due to start operating next year. EON has invested at least 5 million euros in the power-to-gas concept and started construction of a pilot plant on Aug. 21.

Other government-funded research projects include a trial system using computer technology to connect renewable generators with storage facilities and consumers on the North Sea island of Pellworm, and research into chemical batteries that are larger and have a longer lifespan than lithium-ion batteries.

Bendable Panels

Scientists at the Fraunhofer Institute in Freiburg are working on longer-term projects, from bendable solar panels to high-speed charging stations for electric cars that might one day act as a battery for the national grid.

The overhaul is growing markets for domestic manufacturers including Solarworld AG, as well as for their foreign peers such as Vestas Wind Systems A/S., the world’s biggest maker of wind turbines.

It all amounts to “a major innovation wave within the German economy that can strengthen our position on the global markets for the next 20, 30 years,” Altmaier said last month.

Altmaier, 54, a chancellery confidante and former parliamentary whip for Merkel’s party, was appointed environment minister in May after Merkel sacked his predecessor, Norbert Roettgen, amid reports that he wasn’t listening to industry concerns and opposition claims that targets were slipping.

Green Objections

The Greens and Social Democrats, whose original plan forged under Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder to abandon nuclear power was overturned by Merkel in 2010, then reinstated six months later after Fukushima, accuse her of mismanaging the task. Juergen Trittin, co-leader of the Greens, has called on the chancellor to push more ambitious renewables targets instead of cutting subsidies, saying the whole project is “in danger.”

The average German household may have to pay 175 euros a year next year to subsidize renewables, a rise of 40 percent, according to Stephan Kohler, head of the Dena energy agency, a researcher part-owned by the government. That will prompt “a heck of a power-price debate,” Kohler told reporters Aug. 22.

Germany aims to raise its share of power production from renewables to at least 35 percent by the end of this decade from 25 percent now. The U.K. is targeting about 30 percent by 2020, while Sweden, Austria and Spain, each of which have richer hydro-electric resources, have pledged to better Germany’s share. The U.S. has no federal mandate for renewables.

Merkel, whose electoral district on the Baltic Sea coast looks out to a EnBW Energie Baden-Wuerttemberg AG offshore wind farm comprising 21 Siemens turbines, says the energy transition is “a Herculean task.”

Yet it “can be an example to other nations by showing them that you can succeed,” she said June 25 in a speech. “It’s possible to take the path to a sustainable energy supply.”

Copyright 2012 Bloomberg.

Lead image: Keyhole via Shutterstock


20 Comments

Register To Comment
Andrew Kazantsev
Andrew Kazantsev
August 29, 2012
BTW, by using Air Hydropower (http://airhes.com) we can get a minimal cost for 1 kWh storage ~ $36-40 (2 km head, hydrogen price $2/kg) - 18 t water is ~100 kWh (3 day household) - compare with other ways here http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/09/got-storage-how-hard-can-it-be/
Ann Vole
Ann Vole
August 28, 2012
@ Bob_Wallace: yeah, they do a lot of mentioning the safety aspects of their system. Argon is a gas above -185.85 °C so works great for this range of temperature (and is safe and relatively cheap... extracted from air). Gravel is easy for lots of surface area achieving maximum heat transfer. On the other hand, the ammonia will be liquid and solid (not gas) and likely held inside thin metal containers in a bath of argon so the chance of a leak is nil when in operation. When it evaporates if warmed up to room temperature, the pressure would need a place to go (or strong containers). I will look for an alternative material that remains liquid at room temperature.
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 28, 2012
I'm just guessing here, but it seems to me that the problem would be getting that heat/cold into "air" form. They are using gravel as the storage medium because it holds shape and they can pass air around it to capture the heat. Lots of surface area for heat exchange.

They are (IIRC) using argon as the transport medium.

And gravel is both danged cheap and very safe (unlike an ammonia leak).
Ann Vole
Ann Vole
August 28, 2012
regarding Isentropic's Pumped Heat Electricity Storage: looks like they are storing 500 degrees C and -160 degrees C. Looking at the heat of fusion of various common materials, the three that stood out as highest were water, aluminum and ammonia. Water freezes at 0 degrees C but aluminum and ammonia at 660.32 °C and -77.73 °C respectively. With adjustments to their working fluid or pressures, they might be able to hit those temperatures for the storage and store aluminum and ammonia in partial solid and liquid states. Magnesium is also a good choice at 650 degrees C (and only slightly lower heat of fusion)
Ann Vole
Ann Vole
August 28, 2012
@ Bob_Wallace: Thanks for the heads-up on PHES. Spain has been adding thermal storage to it's thermal solar installations for years now and there are projects around the world doing this. The lower cost of PV (then PV's cost earlier) has taken away some of the financial advantage of solar thermal but when thermal storage is included and power delivered when needed most (and output can be fluctuated within seconds), thermal storage can continue to be more cost effective then PV. I plan to build a wind-powered high temperature kiln that does not use electricity but rather high temperature storage and heat created by fluid friction in pipes. The windmill would be pumping air to move liquid iron in chrome pipes to create the high temperatures underground. A simpler related concept would be to use wind power to pump hydraulic oil and use friction in pipes underground to make steam-producing temperatures to make steam on demand and thus steady electricity production no matter when the wind blows or how strong the wind is. Steam turbines are not as efficient as direct electric generation though so the advantage is only the storage side of things.
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 28, 2012
Ann - you might want to read about Isentropic's Pumped Heat Electricity Storage (PHES). Their approach is to store heat in insulated containers of gravel and use a specially designed heat pump to turn electricity into heat and heat into electricity.

It's something that conceptually works and the company is currently building a prototype. It's interesting and if it works it's fairly cheap storage.

And there are already thermal solar plants which are storing heat to be used to spin turbines after the Sun is down. The Europeans have one or more in operation and a very large system in the US is now about half constructed.
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 28, 2012
"Bob maybe you didn't understand the article, its syn-natural gas, who cares if you take carbon dioxide from the air around to create natural gas from hydrogen?"

Did you see something in the article about using atmospheric CO2 in the process? I missed that.

Every time I've read up on projects to turn CO2 into fuel I've found that they eventually admit that they need concentrated CO2, the stuff found in coal and natural gas waste streams and don't operate on low concentration "air".

If someone can make liquid fuel from atmospheric CO2 and do it efficiently with renewable energy input, then they are on to something. We need clean liquid fuel for flight. But read carefully, most of the schemes require sucking a smokestack and that means there would be pressure to keep coal and gas plants operating longer.
Ann Vole
Ann Vole
August 28, 2012
I was disappointed that the article did not concentrate on solutions. I see some solutions mentioned in the comments. One solution that seems to be overlooked is thermal storage. This is best implemented in thermal solar installations where the energy is already in the form of heat and only needs to be stored for a few hours to keep the plant producing peak power 24 hours of the day (and most just needs storage from solar peak of early afternoon to use peak in the early evening). Most big uses of energy (including natural gas) are creating heat or cool with that energy. You can store that heat or cool and with smart metering, can use the cheapest electricity (which would be based on what renewables are available and the capacity of the distribution). Actual stand-alone heat-based storage may compete with batteries in cost when done at a significant scale and incorporated with other thermal energy sources such as fuels. On the consumer level, Germany has embraced the PassivHaus standard of high efficiency buildings. With smart metering and incentives, houses can be heated and refrigerators cooled during cheaper power (which would match available renewables of course).
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 28, 2012
"But how long will they keep the energy? 90% over 1-2 Weeks
How much can bee stored for maybe 10weeks if over a long period
no wind power ore solar power is possible. In Germany we have gas storage capacity for more than a half year. So who matters if the Start of the Storeprocess has just 60% efficiency, but after that it can be stored for months. In Germany we have not enough cable capacitie to get the windpower from the north sea down to the big users."

Self-discharge. I believe the MIT liquid battery (company name Ambri) does not have a self-discharge problem. Same for Aquion's sodium-ion grid storage battery.

There are not weeks for which the wind does not blow nor the Sun shine. If you link wide geographical regions supply variability is greatly reduced. This is something that Europe is actively doing already.

It might make sense to use existing gas storage and gas plants for very deep backup. In the US we have gas peaker turbines that run only a few hours a year. Mothballing existing capacity should be a good and affordable solution for the extraordinary.

If you're talking very rarely used storage then 60% efficiency might be acceptable. If you're considering "normal" storage, moving night time wind to early day and midday solar to afternoon or covering 3-4 days of low renewble input, then efficiency is important. Loosing energy in the storage process makes electricity more expensive.

Europe is build a lot of transmission. It's looking like there will be one big grid that stretches from Iceland (geothermal and hydro) all the way to North Africa and the Middle East (massive solar). Read up on Desertec - that will give you an idea about what seems to be happening.

And don't get hung up on generation getting ahead of transmission or transmission getting ahead of generation once in a while. Projects don't always follow schedule.
Wind Farm Analytics
Wind Farm Analytics
August 28, 2012
Its great to see the importance of energy storage is finally being recognised. I agree that tried and tested 75-80% efficient pumped hydro needs to be more widely deployed and it can be co-located with wind farms to eliminate variability and lack of predictability. This will offer wind farm (or solar park) owners new revenue streams by capturing curtailment energy, allowing energy trading of wind power so it is delivered when it is more needed (and when the market offers higher prices) and also avoiding the risk that future grid huge wind farm capacity would have to take low prices due to glut of wind power when it gets windy. The last point is quite a risk for the wind industry meaning that wind farms could be less profitable when most productive but this risk can be eliminated by energy storage. But I am in favour of other energy storage methods too and I think it is important to install tried and tested but also to try out newer and innovative methods. Smaller scale fast-acting batteries can work alongside city (GW) scale long duration (many hours or days) storage offered by pumped hydro. I think electrolysis of water using renewable energy to produce green hydrogen is also a critical energy storage method which can offer wind farm owners yet another revenue stream via export of green hydrogen to zero emission transportation networks. All forms of energy storage should contribute to a smart grid and allow for more renewable energy integration. Again, electrolysis is well-established tried and tested technology so we should be deploying it massively for energy security and sustainability of pollution free transportation whilst continuing to trial newer ideas.
matthias ludwig
matthias ludwig
August 28, 2012
Another good source of CO2 for the methane synthesis would be the cement industry. These facilities run around the clock and produce huge amounts of CO2.

Grid scale bulk energy storage is still to expensive even with low cost batteries like the Aquion or Liquid Metal Battery (which has by the way been renamed to AMBRI http://www.ambri.com/)

The most promising technology for really large scale energy storage is the storage module from Gravity Power (http://www.gravitypower.net/index.aspx) or for even lower cost down to 1 €/kWh is the Lageenergiespeicher by Prof. Heindl (http://lageenergiespeicher.de/en/hhs-storage.html)

But this technology take some years to develop and until then the discussed storage options might be a bridging technology.
Andrew Kazantsev
Andrew Kazantsev
August 28, 2012
@kgrossman Yes, and Hydropower accumulation can ideally match a new idea of Air Hydropower - http://airhes.com - real alternative of Solar & Wind. Any nearby hills can be Niagara by using the idea.
ANONYMOUS
August 28, 2012
@Bob

"It uses electricity and carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas blamed for global warming, to turn water into methane that can be stored in underground caverns for days or weeks, then burned in gas plants when needed."

"We have to do better than that. This is a system of double using fossil fuels. Put these systems in place and it will likely increase the amount of time it takes to get fossil fuels out of our energy mix.
"

Bob maybe you didn't understand the article, its syn-natural gas, who cares if you take carbon dioxide from the air around to create natural gas from hydrogen?

Audi is producing hydrogen by using renewable energy!! After that they take your carbon dioxide from the normal air to put it to the hydrogen and you have syn-natural gas.
Where do you have a problem in it?
ANONYMOUS
August 28, 2012
@Bob_Wallace

dear Bob nice to know that batteries are getting better.
But how long will they keep the energy? 90% over 1-2 Weeks
How much can bee stored for maybe 10weeks if over a long period
no wind power ore solar power is possible. In Germany we have gas storage capacity for more than a half year. So who matters if the Start of the Storeprocess has just 60% efficiency, but after that it can be stored for months. In Germany we have not enough cable capacitie to get the windpower from the north sea down to the big users. But we have more then enough capacitie in the gas-net. We would be stupid not to use it.
The energy is directly stored in the hugh gas net and when energy is needed in south Germany it can bee generated on demand easily with gas plants.

Please tell me your idea how to transport and store the energy.
The efficiency of batteries maybe better, but the process power to gas and on demand gas to power works stabil and we also have a big stored capacity for natural gas in Germany.
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 27, 2012
This just showed up in my Inbox...

"A promising battery startup backed by Bill Gates, Liquid Metal Battery, has changed its name to. . . Ambri. The company, which is the brainchild of MIT Professor Don Sadoway, says the new name is a nod to Cambridge, which is where the company was founded. Ambri CEO Phil Giudice tells me that the new name is shorter, easier to say, less literal, and less confusing.

Ambri is developing a battery for the power grid using molten salt sandwiched between two layers of liquid metal. The battery is still about two years from commercialization, and the team has built a 16-inch prototype, though they might scale that up to 36 inches."

http://gigaom.com/cleantech/bill-gates-backed-liquid-metal-battery-is-now-ambri/
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 27, 2012
Don't loose sight of what is happening with utility scale battery storage.

The MIT liquid metal battery is very promising. Dirt cheap materials. Prototypes have apparently undergone over 7,000 charge/discharge cycles with no apparent loss in capacity.

If this battery pans out the game is over for fossil fuels. Cheap, extremely easy to site, close to zero response time - exactly what we need for a storage solution.

And the Aquion sodium-ion battery is also looking pretty good. Cheap, tested at over 5,000 cycles, heading into manufacturing this year. If the MIT liquid battery works out the Aquion sodium-ion battery could be the smaller scale backup battery we need and the battery for off the grid applications. If MIT's battery doesn't pan, the Aquion could solve our grid storage needs, just at a slightly higher cost.
Kurt Grossman
Kurt Grossman
August 27, 2012
Hydropower is the solution that is a 'cold' energy generation system. Thermodynamics and heat engines are inefficient. Here's a little reminder in case you have fogotten 1st semester physics... http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/hframe.html
ANONYMOUS
August 27, 2012
The author writes: "Germany aims to raise its share of power production from renewables to at least 35 percent by the end of this decade from 25 percent now."

It is worth noting that the 2011 renewable generation data had Germany at just barely past 20% of demand and this was aided by unusually high wind and hydro generation and a warmer than expected winter. Germany may have hit 25% renewables for some partial-year statistics that didn't include the summer months, but it is extremely unlikely that the full year 2012 data will reach 25% generation.
Steven
ANONYMOUS
August 27, 2012
Regarding Bob's remarks in comment #1:
Germany has a fair amount of biomass in its renewable energy mix and could provide CO2 for the methane generation from those sources. Of course, a combined cycle natural gas generator is only about 60% efficient and the generation itself isn't perfectly efficient, so energy storage in the form of methane comes at considerable cost in efficiency. Bob's worries about long-term coal use are reasonable though. With many new coal-fired generators being brought on line to replace their large nuclear generation coal is almost certain to increase its share of total generation and no one is going to want to close down a new plant until its rated lifetime of 40-60 years. The rational choice would be to phase the nuclear power out slowly as needed renewable capacity is brought online, but German energy policy is anything but rational.
Steven
Bob Wallace
Bob Wallace
August 27, 2012
"It uses electricity and carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas blamed for global warming, to turn water into methane that can be stored in underground caverns for days or weeks, then burned in gas plants when needed."

We have to do better than that. This is a system of double using fossil fuels. Put these systems in place and it will likely increase the amount of time it takes to get fossil fuels out of our energy mix.

"Well, we can't turn off that coal plant. It's providing CO2 for energy storage, for Pete's sake....{

Pump-up hydro, CAES, utility scale batteries, even ammonia - there are storage systems which do not give us an excuse to keep burning coal, oil and natural gas.

Add Your Comments

To add your comments you must sign-in or create a free account.

  • Create a Free Account!
  • Sign-In
Stay Connected
         
To register for our free e-Newsletters, create your free account here:

Editors' Picks

  • America's Real Problem with Solar Energy
  • EU Debate Over Climate Change Policy Could Dampen Renewable Energy Growth
  • Massachusetts Resets Its Solar Energy Bar, Four Years Early

Most Commented

  • 12
    Breakdown: Penetration of Renewable Energy in Selected Markets
  • 12
    Fracking and Solar: Friends, Foes or the Bridge to Clean Energy Adoption?
  • 7
    San Antonio Solar Fans Delay Introduction of SunCredit Program
  • 5
    Renewable Energy Research Initiative Launched in UK

Total Access Partners

Growing Your Business? Learn More about Total Access
  • EU PVSEC (European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition)
  • OnGrid Solar
  • Leybold Optics
  • Solar FlexRack
  • AltE
  • Panasonic Eco Solutions North America
  • North American Board of Certified Energy Practitioners
  • DNV KEMA Energy & Sustainability
News
  • Renewable Energy
  • Solar Energy
  • Wind Energy
  • Bioenergy
  • Geothermal Energy
  • Hyrdo Power
  • Blogs
  • Video
  • Finance
Resources
  • Companies
  • Products
  • Careers
  • Events
  • Webcasts
  • White Papers
  • Magazines
  • Press Releases
  • e-Newsletters
Company
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising & Services
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Site Map
Network Partners - Magazines
  • Hydro Review Magazine
  • Hydro Review Worldwide Magazine
  • Renewable Energy World Magazine
Network Partners - Events
  • Power-Gen International
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India
  • HydroVision International
  • HydroVision Brazil
  • HydroVision India
  • HydroVision Russia
© Copyright 1999-2013 RenewableEnergyWorld.com - All rights reserved.
RenewableEnergyWorld.com - World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for news & Information