Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

Solar Training: Choosing a Program that Works

By Jerry Sena, Strategic Word
November 10, 2009   |   14 Comments

Do you like this news?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 
There is no foolproof method for rooting out less than qualified training programs, Spies said. There are, however, a number of precautions you can take to ensure that the school you choose is a reputable one.
14 Reader Comments
No image available
Comment
1 of 14
Anonymous
November 10, 2009
With micro-inverters, AC modules are now available that don't have any dangerous high voltage DC, don't have any inverter or string sizing requirements, don't have any temperature coefficient calculations, and don't have any rack structure design or installation work.

Why go through all this complicated training if new technology makes that training irrelevant?

How many people remember how to use a timing light and dwell tach? That's the way high voltage DC PV systems are going.
No image available
Comment
2 of 14
Anonymous
November 10, 2009
Even with micro inverters you need to be properly trained with roofing and electrical skills.

In 2007 Roofing was the 6th most fatal profession followed by #7 Electric Power Line workers.

Since installing micro-inverters employs the skills of the 6th and 7th most dangerous professions, it is wise to learn the proper design and installation techniques if you plan to earn your livelyhood in the profession.

Micro-inverter design and installation is easier than string inverters, but it is still not easy. Those that skip the fundamental PV Design and Installation training have a much larger failure rate than those that take the advised training. Those that skip the training can learn by doing, but the cost to learn by doing is much more expensive.
Comment
3 of 14
November 10, 2009
You also might look into what organization qualified the instructor, who qualified the training materials and if they require 8 hours of building a real solar array.

Most NABCEP classes do not require a hands-on class nor do they actually approve the actual training materials nor do they check the instructors credentials.

Solar training classes offering the ETA International certification (httwww.eta-i.org) will be taking classes that are taught by certified instructors whose credentials/background have been checked, use certified training materials, and require a mandatory 8-hour hands-on class that requires students to build a a real solar array.

There are industry comparison charts that can be found by doing a Google search on ETA vs. NABCEP.

The other problem with NABCEP is the limit the number of testing locations which requires students to fly out of state to take the test, might require them to wait up to 6 months to take a test in their area, and might find extremely long lines or sold out classes.

ETA is in the process of adding more than 100 certified administrators to administer their test by schools that have been in the certification business for many years.

While NABCEP is run by volunteers, ETA has been in the certification business for 31 years and has a full-time paid staff that develops stringent certification processes for instructors, class materials and the hands-on portion of the classes. Last year they issued more than 10,000 certifications and train across a wide portfolio of industries, not just solar. Check ETA's list of industries served:
http://eta-i.org/industries.html

Even more important is what type of companies hire them after they pass their test & receive their certification. ETA's list is impressive: http://www.eta-i.org/ETA%20Companies%20Who.pdf

So if your looking for a job with the federal government, the U.S. Armed Forces or Fortune 500 companies, you'll find that ETA is a better certification.
Comment
4 of 14
November 10, 2009
And while NABCEP claims they are accredited and certified by the Interstate Renewable Energy Council's Institute for Sustainable Power Quality (IREC ISPQ) and that their programs are certified programs that have met the council's stringent guidelines for appropriate curriculum and experienced trainers.

The real question is who approved IREC to issue education accreditations.

You might ask them to what educational accreditation programs IREC, its member schools or its actual entry level solar certifications have been approved by as an ACCREDITED CERTIFICATION.
Comment
5 of 14
November 11, 2009
Thank you veterans.
Visit www.helmetstohardhats.org for a gateway to a career in the skilled trades. Most renewable energy system capacity in the US is installed by industrial contractors using skilled trades people on utility scale projects.
Good luck and welcome home.
Comment
6 of 14
November 11, 2009
rhoskins:

Sowing seeds of doubt about the competition is rather self-serving, don't you think?

Though I'm no apologist for NABCEP (nor am I NABCEP-certified), I've worked with members of their board, have worked as a PV & thermal installer, have been an "uncertified" trainer, and I find their course standards top-notch. The NABCEP Task Analysis is industry-standard, and where I was an instructor, we used it to develop our course materials.

Of course there's no substitute for professional qualification and experience, no doubt about it. And most NABCEP-certified people have got it (do examine their requirements to obtain certification--- it's not just "take a course, get a cert"; a mix of training and experience are required).

And there's a reason NABCEP does not certify training materials: conflict of interest. If they were approving courses, they could not maintain the appearance (and fact) of integrity. So they set high standards, and leave course accreditation & certification to IREC ISPQ.

I continue to have great faith in NABCEP.
Comment
7 of 14
November 11, 2009
Interesting to read that Jeff Spies doesn't believe in making money off the solar industry when he works for one of the largest solar distributors in America.

What a hypocrite!

And it looks like the training courses they offer require people to become an AEE Solar Dealer. Kind of self-serving to only train people that have to buy products from your company SO THAT YOU CAN MAKE MORE MONEY.

And how much money is he making off these solar training classes? $1,000 - $3,000 per student. 1,000 students would equal $3 million dollars. Sounds like a profitable business to me.

If Jeff Spies, AEE Solar, SEI and NABCEP really care about growing the solar industry, why not provide solar training for FREE??

One simple reason, because they are in this industry is here to make a PROFIT.

It kind of looks like this article is written to promote only AEE Solar's NABCEP solar training courses and that every one else in the solar training business is bad.

Spreading these kind of negative rumors to hurt the competition is a very bad business practice and hurts the entire solar industry.
No image available
Comment
8 of 14
Anonymous
November 11, 2009
Who offers free training in any profession? Why in the world is it hypocritical to charge people for training who are being trained in preparation for getting a job and making money?

And why would someone be in an industry if they weren't in it to make a profit? Isn't that the point of industry?

You missed the point of the article - there are too many people offering training that is sub-par - Jeff and others including NABCEP and IREC are trying to make sure that PV (and solar thermal and small wind) installers know what they're doing.

If you don't think the system is perfect - why don't you jump in and volunteer to help make it better - after all - making money for your efforts would be hypocritical!
Comment
9 of 14
November 11, 2009
I also find it rather suspicious when a trainer is considered an objective source about training in the industry ... that said he didn't trash anyone but rather certain kind of trainers - which is a good thing.

Training is VERY important, whether OTJ or in the classroom. AC based systems, which someone mentioned, make up a small portion of solar PV, and by no means will be the dominant installation and even so you should be trained on the the dangers of rooftop installations. Safety isn't the only issue either ... there's system efficiency - I've seen some attrociously designed systems, where strings were designed so that they all went out as soon as shade started creeping accross the array.

We started out giving training a year ago ... all pro-bono, before we decided that market was getting too crowded too fast. Now we recommend a number of different training organizations, including some online training (which incidentally is quite hard - you still have to pass tests and they are hard, and the material is mostly all reading).

Nothing, I might add too, can compensate for experience. Some distributors are starting to offer this ... where they will come out for your first install or two. Definitely worth considering when you're shopping for equipment. I spoke with AEE at the Expo about this.

They don't do it, at least not yet, and the fellow I spoke with seemed pretty geared toward steering their trainees to use their recommended equipment, software, etc. instead of taking a more rounded approach.
Comment
10 of 14
November 11, 2009
the first comment from annonymous shows the lack of knowledge. AC voltage requires less than an amp to kill you. Both AC and DC can be dangerous. ALWAYS keep safety in mind. Always assume all wire are live and can hurt you.

quote below-
Anonymous November 10, 2009
With micro-inverters, AC modules are now available that don't have any dangerous high voltage DC......
Comment
11 of 14
November 12, 2009
Editor's note: To read more about Solar Training, check out last week's feature article: "Solar Education, Outreach and Training: Moving the Industry Forward." In the article, you'll find links to video interviews with Boots on the Roof, IREC, SEI and other industry professionals on the topic of training in the solar industry.
Comment
12 of 14
November 15, 2009
Mr Spies article is noteworthy. The comments about quality are very important. NABCEP, AEE and SEI are all very good companies for what they do. I am sure that there are many more. It is always good to set the bar higher then the norm, but with respect to those that have been here before NABCEP and other certifying entities, that have contributed enormously to this industry. Many are beyound the need for certifications. You can see many of them that have written for Home Power over the years and know what I am talking about. Real oldtimers in this fast growing industry providing free knowledge and experience for any one willing to read. No to mention the fact that there are a lot of Community Colleges out there offering quality instruction both to the beginner and the advanced solar installer and designer. More entities out there offering some form of certification is a good thing not a detrimental one. Some of us remember that not long ago there were none and it seemed that everyone had a friend or a brother-in-law that could install solar. No one and no one providing certification is perfect but this industry benefits from those that try.
Comment
13 of 14
November 18, 2009
Plumbers and electricians have to go to school for several years and lately, have to go to school each year to keep up their license. They also have to go through several years of on the job training to qualify. I cannot understand how a brief course on installing solar qualifies anyone. Solar used to be installed by those who educated themselves or worked in the trades. Lately, solar certification companies have come and gone telling their students that they are "certified installers" just because they completed a weekend course. Even some of the major certifiers that have been around and built up their business such as the NEBCEP have only been around for a short time. A lot shorter than the time necessary to be a qualified. All you have to do is look at photos of installations and the people installing. You see all kinds of dangerous situations. Just look at the photos in this article alone. Panels are being installed on racking systems and roofs that provide no working space. Panels are being installed that are exposed to sunlight. Why aren't they covered? Every electrician knows to turn off the power before working on a circuit. Why are systems mostly installed on roofs? As mentioned in the article, it is one of the most dangerous places to work. The ground seems to be a much better loctation. This also helps with actual grounding of the systems. It also provides better lightning protection, makes wire runs shorter, decreases installation time, makes repair and service much easier, makes cleaning and maintaining easier etc. So overall, it makes the installation safer for those who are not properly trained and can reduce accidents both now and in the future. Unfortunately, we let even less qualified people, the gov. along with the power companies, make policies that tell us the panels have to go on a roof in order to get any payback, especially in the residential market. So a note to certifiers, get some training yourself before you start training others.
Comment
14 of 14
November 19, 2009
As noted above, there can be a big difference between being trained and certified, and being skilled. You know it when you see it in the installation. Ask your local electrical inspector.

Equipment and Installation costs are going up.
The 2011 NEC will probably require arc-fault detection at the string or module level in addition to the system ground-fault protection already required for roof-top systems. The code-making panel may be accepting and reviewing comments from stakeholders at this time. Anyone can submit comments, at no cost. All of the necessary information needed to submit a comment is in your 2008 NEC codebook.
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

Talesun Solar Stoel Rives LLP Quick Mount PV Rotork plc American Electric Technologies, Inc. (AETI) Mannvit BEES - BioEnergy Events & Services
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters