Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

Where's The Outrage?

By Tom Currie, VP Sales, Solar Sentry
October 2, 2008   |   13 Comments

Do you like this opinion & commentary?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 

The information and views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of RenewableEnergyWorld.com or the companies that advertise on its Web site and other publications.

13 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 13
October 2, 2008
I fully agree, and appreciate the author's reality-acknowledgement that coal will be with us for a while. I think the Republicans generally don't care about renewable energy, and the Dems take RE industry support for granted. As a Dem, I believe the House leadership should have been more supportive of the ITC over the past year and bears some responsibility for using it as an expendable bargaining chip. This drama did not have to happen.

The author is correct, it isn't "just wind." Turns out that wind and solar complement each other well. Solar is at its best during the hot summer afternoons when the utilities are screaming for power and wind is typically down to 7% of rated capacity or something like that. Meanwhile, wind is typically stronger at night. We need to get started on those thermal solar plants in CA.
Comment
2 of 13
October 2, 2008
McCain blew it twice earlier this year...two times the Senate had 59 yes votes and he abstained. And he's from Arizona! He could have declared, "I'm the Green Candidate." and won some of the young voters that are lopsided against him.
His advisors aren't very good.....it was an uncontested slam dunk from the top of the key...I'm thinking...Dr. J....red, white and blue ABA ball...windmilling!

George@RRREC.net
www.RRREC.net
Comment
3 of 13
October 3, 2008
This is a position I was hoping we were not going to be forced into. I know for fact, many 1000's of calls, emails and letters were sent to Capital Hill asking for support of HR 6049. I guess they just figured if American's really wanted it, why not force them to ask our D.C. crew of Senators and Reps to vote "Yea" for the bail out package.

Hopefully when this passes the house it will still contain the section for the ITC and PTC credit so we can all move forward in this RE industry.

DC Miller
Comment
4 of 13
October 3, 2008
My outrage is nearly exhausted. Five, maybe six votes ago, I realized that Senator Wayne Allard, a Republican scum bag representing Colorado, was never going to vote for extending the ITC in any real situation. The man is, as are many other Senate Republicans, completely deluded to believe they might find some perfect situation wherein they could vote for RE without any pain to the budget or to oil. So I am giving dollars to Mark Udall, while the US Chamber of Commerce and many other "problem forces" are pouring huge amounts with vicious attacks into the race supporting Schaeffer, who in quote says "There is not a thing Allard did, I would change. " It is a waste of time to call Sen. Allard's office again. As for McCain, he has missed every vote to extend the ITC, all 8 of them. He is no friend of RE.
Comment
5 of 13
October 3, 2008
Now the ITC credit package has been added to the $700 billion "Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008" - the Wall Street bailout package. There is sufficient public support for RE that the package has now been used as a sweetener for the bailout. Talk about a Faustian bargain! Faust sold his soul to the devil for vast riches.

As a solar professional, I yesterday received an email alert from national ASES telling me "if you only make one call this year, this is the one", as well as similar admonition from SEIA to call my congressman. I just can't do it. I respected my Democratic congressman for rejecting the bailout on the first vote on Tuesday, and I won't ask him to sell out now in order for my industry to gain the (substantial and essential) spoils of the bailout. I'm not willing to benefit from the egregious abuses by the Wall Street investment houses. That's a stain my soul can't wipe away.

My faith is that the RE incentives are popular enough that they will come up again and pass; likely by a new administration. Times will be tight, but they will be anyway - the bailout is at best a wild guess as to whether it will succeed.

I don't expect many to agree with me, but I hope to engender some lively dialogue here.
Comment
6 of 13
October 3, 2008
It may well be time to realize that outrage will get you nothing but an upset and disturbed self. The peaceful mind prevails. The egos that believe they are in the right will seem to prevail for a time. The trust in truth will prevail if support is merely withdrawn from illusion.
The reason renewables do not get support in Washington DC is there are no, or few, major PAC funders for it. Politicians have enormous need/greed for money. Only a few career politicians nearing or having passed retirement will admit to this. But it is fairly obvious to one who sits back and sees what is happening. Our government is a business (for far too many). It was intended to be representative of the general population, but the founders did not perhaps realize the clout of the megga corporations that have developed today.
Solar thermal for small private and business installations will save more energy dollars than all other venues, but it has little or no PAC funders other than the individuals.
Comment
7 of 13
October 3, 2008
I think the title of the article would have been more honestly worded. "Where's the money?".

Isn't that what everyone wants - some one else's money?

"Congress has an important role to play." Indeed, giving away my money to the point of fiscal recklessness.

Some people want free health insurance for children. Others want money to buy land to 'protect' it. Everyone wants money and this author is no different.

Wake me up if you find a leader in the RE industry who believes their company can stand on it's own merits (geo thermal, maybe).

Each state should evaluate the resources available to them and quit looking for a magic solution for the whole country.
Comment
8 of 13
October 4, 2008
Who was it that said, "The love of money, is the root of all evil."?
Comment
9 of 13
October 4, 2008
Allan & Rt:

I agree with both of your posts. I also can't bring myself to applaud the RE extensions when bundled with the sickening bailout of festering greed.

Renewable energy CAN stand on its own--it just needs a level playing field!

So many subsidies and incentives are paved for oil, nuclear, coal, etc. that renewables have an uphill battle from the gate.

Rt: It is a fact that wind, solar thermal, and soon to be other technologies like geothermal and ocean energy (including OTEC) stand on their own. I spoke with an executive recently from a major national power producer who said they will continue to develop wind projects even without an extension of the PTC.

Renewables' best friend would be true capitalism--the kind this country was built on and seemingly has long forgotten.
Comment
10 of 13
October 4, 2008
By the time you read this, it passed, so no worry there. But I wanted to let you know the history and why there is such difficulty. It is not as simple as you thought.

The PTC was attempted 9 times, failed each time in the Senate, because there are only 4 Senate Republicans who routinely vote with the 51 Democrats to grow renewable energy. The Senate requires 60 votes to vote on a bill, so we were always short. On the 9th time, the Senate attached some ornaments (Ike disaster relief), and it had some fossil funding as well as clean energy funding) and so got Republican votes.

Returned to the House and they stripped off the ornaments passing each part separately as a clean bill. They passed a much better solar bill, fully funded. They have a bigger Democratic majority, so its easier.

But that killed it back in the Senate, because now the Republicans didn't have to vote for renewables, since there were no goodies now attached. Ike relief was separate.

But then the bailout failed in the house!

The Senate Democrats saw how they could have a new must-pass bill to attach it to, when trying again: the bailout/AMT.

The House Democrats wanted to pass renewable energy/AMT. The Senate Republicans were on board with the bailout/AMT.

The two were married, and both got what they wanted. Even Bush signed the clean energy bill he had vowed to veto - because it was stuck to the bailout

.For full history
Comment
11 of 13
October 4, 2008
Oh, I guess I cannot insert links:
full history



http://dotcommodity.blogspot.com/2008/09/on-ninth-attempt-democrats-pass-clean.html
http://dotcommodity.blogspot.com/2008/09/house-fully-funds-renewable-energy-act.html
http://dotcommodity.blogspot.com/2008/09/energy-funding-endangered-as-congress.html
http://dotcommodity.blogspot.com/2008/09/bailout-failure-improves-energy-bill.html
Comment
12 of 13
October 6, 2008
Thats Good.
Comment
13 of 13
October 6, 2008
Just Goes to Show Yah! Everything is a lesson. Didgeyah learn?
Everyone knows someone who did not like the bankster boyz bailout and yet voted Bush(wack) and will vote McCain/Palin. Sorry to be so political here, but all this seems so very connected.
I have an investor buddy that just digs in and waits to strike when he feels threatened by new ideas, like RE. Oddly, he is often rewarded.
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

Leybold Optics Blue Sky Energy, Inc. Advanced Energy Industries, Inc. GoGreenSolar.com Texas Renewable Energy Industries Association FRONIUS USA LLC  Solar Electronics Division Konica Minolta Sensing Americas, Inc
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters