Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

Abandoned Farmlands Are Key to Sustainable Bioenergy

July 3, 2008   |   18 Comments

Do you like this news?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 
"Our study shows that there is clearly a potential for developing sustainable bioenergy, and we've been able to identify areas where biomass can be grown for energy, without endangering food security or making climate change worse."

Chris Field, Director, Department of Global Ecology, Carnegie Institution
18 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 18
July 4, 2008
Has anyone noticed I submitted Davis Blume's solution to the energy problem uses waste water that is chocked full of nutrients?

Satisfied Water, Fertilizer, and land use needs using marginal, or even empty gravel pits making all the excuses why we can't leave our keyboards and git r done a very lame excuse indeed!

Get Blume's Opus and get with it. http://tinyurl.com/56rrda

We are talking about North America, not some imaginary Sim City where tens of thousands stand at attention, ready to build Your paradise to your specifications with unlimited money and resources.

Instead the proposal is quite modest: It requires NO waiting on technology advances, or permission from State or Federal Government entities. It solves part of river and stream pollution problems, negates coal, petroleum or natural gas for fertilizer, and does not tie up a single acre of prime cropland.

What's not to like, except for it might not be Your sacred idea?

Sir Richard Branson, We stand ready to solve Your fuel problems and do so at rates under current contract kerosene rates. Other Airline execs. reading this are also welcome to contact us via the FARMY. http://tinyurl.com/5nftmm
Comment
2 of 18
July 4, 2008
I join those who have mentioned, "where will the water come from?" We already have widespread drought throughout the world, and all bioenergy feedstocks require water - some of them require a lot of it! California is committed to a large biofuel industry, when we already have a "water emergency," as declared by the Governor. Somebody needs to start talking to somebody!
Comment
3 of 18
July 4, 2008
Most biomass (with the exception of Algae, if and when it materializes) to fuel is a loosing proposition: A) its Energy ROI is negative, at best poor. B) It would be impossible to stop the conversion to energy crops from food crops, C) Marginal lands should produce crops for our starving world. D) All crops are susceptible to weather conditions, and diseases, particularly mono-culture species. and E) The cost to develop sustainable renewable energy farms such as wind, solar thermal, ocean wave, is a fraction of that of agriculture. Advantages are many: a) They're robust mechanical not fragile biological producers, b) fractional maintenance, many crops are not perennial, thusly expensive replanting, harvesting, and energy conversion every year. Renewable energy, wind, solar etc., is perennial! And renewable energy goes more directly into energy/ power/ heat/ cooling, without pesky factories, and complex land, marine based haulage logistics. Often, for example, the fields are not where the fuel plants are, where the market is. Ethanol can not be pipe lined. Given that were not a problem, try renting a rail car for distribution, the bigs have eaten them all! Physical distribution/ logistics is a major problem, also more pervious to weather. Renewable energy should be localized/ regionalized. A final point is renewable plants can desalinate / reprocess water, to grow plants, sustain people and industry. My company Sannerprojects, Inc JRIAM1945@aol.com is intent to commercialize $.05/kWh renewable energy Wind Power, and concentrated solar thermal. The Joke used to be, a kid asked his dad, how he became so rich buying rags for $2 and selling them for $1? To which the Dad, quickly answered "volume!"
Comment
4 of 18
July 4, 2008
Contact:
James E. Miller (Stanford alumnus)
AlgaeOilDiesel, LLP
530 NW 13th St., Corvallis, OR 97330, USA
immmiller5417 -at- yahoo.com
541-757-9797
Comment
5 of 18
July 4, 2008
CONTINUED FROM ABOVE

establishment of a community-wide mesh wireless network. The Internet feed would be by satilite.

The requirements are:

Flat (relative) land inland of the sea.
Sea water as cold as we can find (or a large, inland lake)
Preferably, a harbor which supports fishing and has a deep enough port for ocean cargo ships.
Local, state and national governments which support the project with speedy permits and no corruption.
Safety for persons and property.
Once established and profitable (2-3 years), the operation will be self-sustaining and can grow from internal profits. Profits in excess of these needs would be available for debt service, if needed.
Construction, development and start-up capital.

The outcomes are:

Provide biodiesel to the local, state and national economy with any surplus exported for cash. Local demand must first be met before any exports. Biodiesel can be used in transportation, heating and electrical generation.
Provide safe, potable water to the village or town. A domestic water system and a waste water system compliment each other. The sea water is the source of the water, which when distilled, is very pure water. The waste water is treated using the Eco Machine and the treated water used to irrigate the groves of trees. Wash water (containing potassium) from refining the biodiesel will be used for crop irrigation.
The food production is a source of affordable, healthy fresh fruits and vegetables.
The form of ownership of the plants will be a cooperative, membership in which is formed from the native, working-class, population. On-the-job training will be provided. An earnings differential cap of 4:1 will be observed.
Part of the net profits will be used for education, health care and child development and nutrition for all of the local residents.
Part of the net profits will be used for micro-loans in support of local, small business. See: http://www.kiva.org/
Contact:
James E. Miller (Sta
Comment
6 of 18
July 4, 2008
CONTINUED FROM ABOVE

By combining existing technologies, we can create a crop plant operation along the sea shores of most countries, which factory operation will also produce biodiesel, animal feed, fresh fruits and vegetables and potable water, all at a very low operational cost. In summary, the technologies are:

Sea Water Greenhouse which houses algae ponds, evaporators, condensers, aeroponic gardening and production of fresh water fish, crustacians and worms. http://www.seawatergreenhouse.com/
A domestic, potable water system in for the village/town and a waste water collection system. A greenhouse which houses a Eco Machine to remediate waste water and return it for agroforestry crops. http://www.ecosherpa.com/waste-management/eco-machines/
An algal oil extraction plant and a biodiesel plant. See http://montanasynergy.wetpaint.com/page/BUSINESS+PLAN+FOR+SPIRULINA+CULTURE+AND+PRODUCTION
Assuming we could co-locate with a harbor which supports a fishing industry, we could expand the operation to include processing of the catch, then using the fish parts for algae nutrient (fish tea) and the solid parts for composing and/or animal feed. http://www.the-organic-gardener.com/fish-emulsion.html
Establishment of groves of Paradise Trees for production of nut oil for both human consumption, livestock feed and production of biodiesel. http://www.svlele.com/simarouba.htm
Establishment of groves of agroforestry for food production, including hazelnuts, citrus, tropical fruits, tropical nuts, and small grains and fiber producing plants (hemp, flax). The fish meal cum compost is excellent feed for the soil foodweb.
Marginal crop lands can be remediated through the use of holistic land management practices. http://www.holisticmanagement.org/
A requirement for outreach for schooling, health and welfare, citizen participation will include the introduction of the ruggized laptop, equiped with wireless and the establishment of a community-wide mesh wirel
Comment
7 of 18
July 4, 2008
In the article, Growing energy on unused agricultural land, the reporter states:
"The researchers calculated land area by using historical databases and estimated potential bioenergy crop yields based on natural plant growth on those lands today. Past studies have found that agricultural yields are about 65% of those from natural plant growth on the same land, Campbell notes, though improved methods can increase agricultural productivity. One important caveat, he adds, is that conventional biofuel crops such as corn may exacerbate nutrient runoff and soil erosion. Planting diverse perennial plants, such as those being developed as feedstocks for cellulosic ethanol, would be environmentally preferable, he says."
http://pubs.acs.org/cgi-bin/sample.cgi/esthag/asap/html/es801609k.html
The researchers and/or reporters 1 have yet to state that much is at stake as to the low yield crop lands. Consider these factoids:
Rain forests are removed by burning, crops are good for a year or two, then the land is abandoned and great erosion occurs.
Lands which are marginal to begin with, are farmed and when the soil is exhausted, abandoned.
Poor farming practices can destroy farm land which was good to begin with but is exhausted or so heavily eroded, it cannot be used.
Drought causes crop lands to be abandoned.
Use of toxic rescue chemicals (the 'cides) kill the soil food web and thus kill the "stomach" of the plants.
Loss of the aquifer will terminate cropping. The Mid-west is facing what is already happening in the Central Valley of California.
The marginal lands can be productive of energy, but not by growing oil seed crops or plants for cellulosic ethanol production. The solution is to grow algae. Here's the plan:
Here is a food and fuel security solution which will work throughout most of coastal Africa or the tropical Americas and possibly in an inland area with a large body of water:

By combining existing technologies, we can create a crop plant operation
Comment
8 of 18
July 4, 2008
How many of those acres were abandoned due to drought? If so, will biomass be able to grow at an adequate rate to meet those projections?Does anyone know?
Comment
9 of 18
July 4, 2008
Why think of only abondoned farm lands/. There are million of hecters in India where nothing is grown any way.These lands also exist in Africa.In fact all over the world!.Jatropha is a crop which can be easily grown on such sites
Research aimed at increasing the oil content of this seed is the need of the hour also its yield from the plant.Why use Corn to produce bio fuel?
Jatropha oil has been used in India since last four thousand years or more - long before electricity was thought of as resourse for lighting on the Diwali Festival - when entire India even village huts are covered by lighting .
Infact companies which have large tracts of land withem should grow this seed .
I believe Jatropha cultivation and its processing technology should be promoted like rearing a cow.Every family in India would know how to rear a cow or a goat!Milk is part and parcel of our diet since the begining of civilization and part of our culture!
This will solve energy problem in Agriculture to a very large extent besides providing employment to thousands - especially poor rural folk in the developing world!
Comment
10 of 18
July 4, 2008
Abandoned farmland is very important bird habitat. With a severely declining songbird population in the United States, using more marginal lands for biofuels will probably further reduce the population of songbirds. This conflict in resource use is the result of overpopulation, an issue that no one addresses, but is a problem we must do something about soon.
Comment
11 of 18
July 4, 2008
Gregory,

We have a very suitable crop for this environment. Please let me know your contact details.

John
Comment
12 of 18
July 4, 2008
I don't understand an article that claims we can only make 8% of our energy off of abandoned farmlands without giving us at least a rough idea how many acres this amounts to, what the conversion rates are, etc.

I do know that if one feeds primary treated sewage to cattails on man made marshes using empty gravel pits, run down land, etc., one can have a minimum of 7500 gallons per acre, GGE, as Ethanol and Methane. We only need about 20,000,000 acres out of some 1.3 billion acres to replace all gasoline used in the lower 48. It's detailed in David Blume's book. http://tinyurl.com/56rrda
Comment
13 of 18
In France the artichoke has been used for wine and beer production for many years. Ethanol and butanol, two fuel grade alcohols, can be produced from Jerusalem artichokes. The cost of producing ethanol from Jerusalem artichokes are alot cheaper than corn, and therefore the success of Jerusalem artichokes ethanol plants should be known.
Comment
14 of 18
Thank you Gregory,
Romania has 4 distinct seasons much like that of North America. The winters can are cold reaching temperatures between 0°C and -5°C. There is lots of snow fall in the mountains creating a perfect destination for skiers and snowboarders with its affordable ski resorts. Spring is pleasant with cool mornings and nights and warm days. In the summer hot sunny days can be experienced along the Black Sea coast and Transylvania where temperatures reach about 30°C. Autumn is dry and cool with colourful foliage from the trees and mountains.
Average Seasonal Temperatures
Summer Winter Average
Black Sea Coast 20.0 °C 2.4 °C 11.2 °C
Bucharest 21.8 °C 0.6 °C 11.2 °C
Transylvania 18.2 °C -2.6 °C 7.8 °C
Carpathians 14.5 °C -4.5 °C 5.0 °C
Danube Delta 20.8 °C 2.3 °C 11.5 °C
Timisoara 21.2 °C 0.0 °C 10.6 °C
I don't think elephant grass can tolerate the tempeture but thier other plants that can.
Comment
15 of 18
July 4, 2008
Hey you Americans!First of all, congratulations for celebrating 4th of July!
Second, come to Romania to see around 3 millions of hectares, some 6 million acres, not cultivated, only this year!
All of them can be used as energy cultivating, and I'm thinking on miscanthus, Elephant grass, to seed on them.
It will be easy to cultivate and harvest, and from this to produce second generation biofuels, without competing with edible crops...
If you want, contact me.

Gregory
Comment
16 of 18
July 5, 2008
I hate to point out that any crop that can be grown profitably on abandon farm land can be grown at a higher profit on current farm land. Note, those lands were abandoned because they couldn't compete for some reason (water/pollution)

So our current farm land will be converted over to growing biofuels thereby causing massive starvation, death and disease in the 3rd world.

The current generation of Biofuels are evil. To support it, is to support death by slow starvation and disease for millions. Look at the color of the people who will die and then look at the color of the people who will use the fuel. Its black and white. Its genocide.

I reserve judgment on the algae based systems since they claims to use non-potable water and less land.
Comment
17 of 18
July 8, 2008
James Miller:
I have had remarkably similar thoughts on the problem and similar solutions. The algae idea, if successful, would be a great addition.
The seawater greenhouse (and any other desalination process) produces a saline effluent, which instead of disposal at sea could be used as feedstock for other commercial processes such as the production of salt, magnesium, lithium, etc.
It may prove more economic in the end to use an ocean energy device such as the ceto device (ceto.com) to not only supply the required input seawater, but ready for desalination without the requirement for seawater greenhouses.
Your other ideas would not conflict with this new method, and would allow for the production of electricity when required
Comment
18 of 18
July 8, 2008
Thanks for the article and the above comments including one from India on experience of non edible source of biofuel Jatropha. In India isolated local community get electricity from generators using jatropha oil from household plantations as it is not economically and physically possible to get electricity from conventional grid system. Though there is a severe controversy going on between available food for the people and energy need for sustainable development but still I think each country should consider some liquid fuel from bio energy in case of emergency like war or delay in import of fossil fuel for a developing country like us which very depend on diesel oil to operate farming machinery such as power tiller, thresher and diesel engine for irrigation and tranporting foods.

Shamim Bangladesh
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

UnThink Solar Schneider Electric Solar Power International 2011 Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Quick Mount PV Helios Solar Works AllEarth Renewables
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters