Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

Switchgrass Burn Test Proves Hopeful

June 19, 2006   |   9 Comments

Do you like this news?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 
Environmental Resource Trust's EcoPower program certifies the amount of power generated during the test burn that resulted from a renewable energy source, and allows the project team to market the RECs to companies, government organizations, and/or residential consumers who are willing to pay a small premium to ensure that a portion of their energy purchases go to a renewable power generator.
9 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 9
June 19, 2006
It is the marginal increases in greenhouse gases that count, not the background level of greenhouse gases, regardless of the source. If you are five feet tall and the water is rising, it's the last few inches that count, even though the bulk of the water brought up the level to just below your nose.

If you are appalled at the so called ignorance of this blog, go over to realclimate.org; I'm sure that you will feel more comfortable peddling your theories amongst experts.

The article failed to address the carbon and energy inputs necessary for this process. Yes, most of us know that the feestock itself is supposedly neutral, but without knowledge of all the inputs necessary for this process, it is not possible to evaluate the energy return or the net carbon impact.
Comment
2 of 9
June 19, 2006
The author seems to say "primary" as in "the greenhouse gas that is a primary concern to the current global warming mitigation models." not "most potent on a scienfic scale"
Comment
3 of 9
June 19, 2006
" Reduced emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), the primary greenhouse gas,"
Ignorance of greenhouse gases seems to be rampant on this blog. Carbon dioxide is nowhere near the most potent greenhouse gas. That distinction belongs to water vapor, which accounts for fully 95% of greenhouse gases and is far more potent than CO2. The remaining 5% is divied up amongst methane , CO2 and others.
Methane is produced in large quantities by trees, especially in the rain forests, and is a more potent greenhouse gas than CO2.
Comment
4 of 9
June 21, 2006
Grasses and weeds are best as an ethanol source. Unlike corn, they need no fertilizer.

Isn't Methane the worst greenhouse gas? The melting tundra and its peat, especially in Siberia, is a huge source of Methane.
Comment
5 of 9
June 21, 2006
Strange to see comments about water and methane wrt this story.There are many things we need to fix if our children are to have a halfway decent world to live in, this experiment is trying one.
I would have liked to see a full EROEI analysis of teh switchgrass process, and obviously not mixing teh ash with the coal ash would have meant it was usable as fertiliser for the switchgrass fields, but lets not dump on people actually trying to do something thats potentially in a right direction.
Comment
6 of 9
June 22, 2006
And how do we resolve the emission problems in the production process? Don't just write it off. Switchgrass is native, it is perennial, it is drought and insect resistant and it needs little or no fertilizer. There are varieties that grow to 6-12 ft tall and it is therefore at the highest end of per acre production.

I am appalled at how the huge agricorps have run off with the ethanol idea to put millions of acres into habitat destroying mono cropped corn that must be harvested, reseeded, fertilized, tilled and sprayed each year. If we can just get the Switchgrass-crop / lumber waste source secured in a far more environmentally safe production process, the infrastructure issue is much smaller for E 85 and E 95 fuels than other alternatives. We are talking about only a special pump per station and flex fuel vehicles. That's do-able. Let's make it work.

If coal is the main issue of the processing cycle, can we replace it with some other source of energy?
Comment
7 of 9
June 23, 2006
As a mechanical engineer at a pulverised coal fired plant I find some key info in this story lacking. Was the boiler used a pc unit or a fluidized bed? What was the BTU/pound content of the switchgrass? What was the injection method into the boiler? What methods are required, if any, to dry out the cultivated fuel prior to combustion? Since I am not familar with the D-stringer machine, was the fuel chopped into little bits or fed as cut, in long strands? Just as important as the BTU question, how much acreage is required to grow this crop and under what conditions? It is an interesting idea and the boiler at my plant has burned a variety of fuels in the past but more info need to be publicly published to attract increase usage of this potential fuel. -
Comment
8 of 9
June 30, 2006
"Grasses and weeds are best as an ethanol source. Unlike corn, they need no fertilizer."

This is simply not true. EVERYTHING requires fertile soil. Any farmer knows that whenever you grow the same thing over and over, without constantly adding nutrients, it eventually wears out the soil.

To be truly sustainable, this fuel source needs to be created in a closed-cycle, which means organic fertilizer (manure or green manure).

Crops of switchgrass probably need to be rotated with legumes to fix nitrogen -- possibly soybeans for biodiesel.

:::: Jan Steinman, Communication Steward, EcoReality http://www.EcoReality.org ::::
Comment
9 of 9
July 13, 2011
I have been doing research on Swtichgrass as a biofuel in recent weeks and I believe there are a few misconceptions about switchgrass that have been demonstrated in comments by some users on this article.
Switchgrass is a native perennial C4 warmgrass that provides habitat for nearly 500 species of birds. The ratio of energy input vs energy output of switchgrass during its complete life cycle is between 1:4 and 1:13 depending on the use, so every unit of energy you put into switchgrass production will yield 4-13 equal units of energy. It also has the capacity to sequester roughly 5 tonnes of CO2/acre/year as well as sequester and prevent excess nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment from getting into ground water and river systems. It is a carbon negative fuel source over its lifecycle if processed correctly. Switchgrass can be grown on marginal, erosion prone, or unproductive lands. Once a stand is established it can continue to be harvested for as many as ten years or longer without annual fertilization. Also switchgrass is fairly immune to stand productivity reduction so a stand will continue to produce a relatively consistent amount of biomass during its lifecycle.

check these sites out

http://ecolearnit.ifas.ufl.edu/viewer.asp?rlo_id=443



http://www.extension.org/pages/26635/switchgrass-for-biofuel-production#Current_Potential_for_Use_as_a_Biofuel

If subsidies for corn and soy bean ethanol were redirected towards switchgrass; as well as, provide a tax credit for carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus sequestration, switchgrass production could flourish helping us decrease our dependence of fossil fuels and protect the environment.

I dont think it is a sure fix. i do not necessarily believe that any new energy technology is a surefire fix on its own, but with current energy infrastructure (set up for fossil fuels), they must be used in unison to be as economical as fossil fuels. People must also be willing to change how they view energy consumption and generation
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

Asia Solar Expo The Stella Group, Ltd. HUBER+SUHNER AG Kipp & Zonen Latin American Wind Energy Association (LAWEA) The Interstate Renewable Energy Council Trojan Battery Company
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters