Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

Wind Energy Demand Booming

By Lester R. Brown
March 27, 2006   |   13 Comments
Cost Dropping Below Conventional Sources Marks Key Milestone in U.S. Shift to Renewable Energy

Do you like this opinion & commentary?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 
"A decade from now, there may be thousands of ranchers who will be earning more selling electricity than they do selling cattle."

- Lester R. Brown

The information and views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of RenewableEnergyWorld.com or the companies that advertise on its Web site and other publications.

13 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 13
March 27, 2006
What statewide initiatives have been broached to ensure the continued livelihood of another natural commodity, bats? Because turbines in certain studies supported by the Bats and Wind Cooperative have proven deadly to thousands of area bats. These same bats are critical to organic practices so important in green living nationwide. Central Texans alone enjoy the Bracken bats which have been estimated to devour 200 tons of crop pests a night during bat season. Are we taking appropriate measures to ensure the balance in nature is being maintained before we simply add more and more turbines?
Comment
2 of 13
March 27, 2006
Great article Mr. Brown. Just as the "mainframe" computers were displaced by distributed computation (the PC), would love to hear your thoughts on Distributed Generation (DG) using small wind turbines. "Wind Farms" are usually remote centralized facilities. Using the DG model will there be an emerging "Wind Forest" of many distributed generators?
Comment
3 of 13
March 27, 2006
Thank God for Lester L. Brown and the critical insight and analysis he and those working with him have provided to such a wide audience for so many years.
Once again as in so many other areas his insight has been instrumental in guiding us forward toward a world where PHEVs,large and smaller
scale wind generated electricity, and solar technologies can begin to lift us out of our fossil fuel stupor.l
For me, living in north Texas, changing over to wind generated electricity was as simple as changing energy providers. Yes, it's costing me one and a half cent more per kilowatt hour. And yes, I have become more decerning in my energy usage. High efficiency lighting and appliances plus insulation, shading, ventilation, and energy waste all factor into my thinking a little more now. And yes I will add photovoltaic panels in the next few years to help in recharging the PHEV I plan to buy as soon as the car manufacturers figure it out and start rolling them off the assembly lines.
Comment
4 of 13
March 28, 2006
Many thanks to Lester Brown for his alerting us to the crossing of the cost lines. As I have written in the past, once the sweet smell of profit becomes evident and risk factors have declined, it is only a matter of time before savy businessmen, some of whom are farmers, rise to the occasion. I believe we are presently witnessing the entry of wind generated power into the mainstream of commerce here in the US.

adrianakau@aol.com
Comment
5 of 13
March 29, 2006
I do find it ironic, that what we jump on Exxon for doing, price jumping during 'limited supply' we're okay with, if its wind? I don't think so. We paid a premium for wind, because it's 'green' fine. Why punish us when it's more mainstream? I don't see any plans to 'rebate' that previous support, once prices fall, and that's fine, but blaming supply for wind price gouging? c'mon... Apparently, we have an OPEC for wind. We won't produce enough turbines, so, there's a demand, so we can charge what we want. I'd laugh my ass off, if we nationalized it, and tossed a few thousand mills on BLM land, where the deer and the antelope all play :P Yes, I understand the business credo here. But greed doesn't impress me.
Comment
6 of 13
March 29, 2006
The problem I have with wind turbines is that they kill bats and birds. Wind energy might be climate friendly but it's not kind to our flying friends. We don't need this at a time when biodiversity is being destroyed. There have been extensive studies; turbines have had a devastating effect on seabirds, in particular.

Sorry for the brief rant. Solar power has no moving parts and therein lies in beauty.
Comment
7 of 13
March 29, 2006
I would be interested to know what Mr. Brown is quotingwhen he says the cost of generating wind electricity has fallen from 38? to 4? to 6? means I would assume cents per kilowatt hour? and If so where can I get some more information on the specific components of these costs?
Comment
8 of 13
March 29, 2006
This is certainly encouraging and I'm pleased to see the progress. I still have concerns with the "unpredictablility" of wind, especilly during the periods of low output and high demand, particularily in the hot summer months.

As far as the bats are concerned, I might speculate that the demise of bats that can't evade a 16rpm turbine may only improve the gene pool?
Comment
9 of 13
March 29, 2006
I believe we are presently withnessing the boom of solar PV power plants in Texas.
This year the global solar power market is estimated to be worth between 9 billion and 12 billion U.S. dollars a year.
Giulio Negrini
www.gnpimb.com
Comment
10 of 13
March 30, 2006
There's a lot of mis-information on costs here. Here are some facts, based on actual contracts filed in utility cases in my state:

Purchase power agreements (PPAs) for wind energy from large wind farms (50 MW +): 2.5 to 3.0 cents a kwh, with the producer keeping the PTC. Contracts that start at the low end often include annual inflators of 3%-5%.The PTC is worth 1.8 cents/kwh, levellized, so the unsubsized cost of large scale wind right now is around 4.5 cents/kwh.

Smaller scale wind projects (less than 1 MW) cost about twice this.
Comment
11 of 13
March 30, 2006
Wind energy prices have not crossed below coal/natural gas electricity. Wind costs about 15 - 20 cents per kwh to produce. The wind companies get about 1/2 of that from the price they charge for the electricity, the other half coming from tax breaks on their profits. Wind energy, being intermittent and unpredictable, would, on a real open market, have a price well BELOW baseline power. Baseline power is usually about 5 cents or less. So wind is worth about 3 cents. Austin Energy found that over the past few years, that the price for peak demand natural gas electricity was above wind. They are comparing two different types of electricity production. I think wind can work. Just get the government out of it.
Comment
12 of 13
March 30, 2006
By the way, non-moving structures such as buildings and solar panels are much more dangerous to birds. The huge reduction of acid rain and mercury pollution resulting from wind electricity save birds from regional extinctions. Small fast turning wind turbines killed a few birds - but modern huge and slow turning turbines are safe for birds. Sorry for destroying one of the absurd antiwind myths.
Comment
13 of 13
March 30, 2006
Some people seem to long for small windmills, which now are as expensive as solar, or 1000% more expensive than big windmills. The reason wind turbines are a real threat to coal and nuclear, is their low cost resulting from their big scale.

Wind electricity is proportional to the square of blade diameter. 80% of power comes from the 15% tip of the blade (due to lever effect). Taller towers capture faster winds. The difference between 165' and 230' can be 20% faster wind. Wind electricity is proportional to the cube of the wind speed. At 65 extra feet, the same turbine will produce 80% more electricity, money, and health savings.

I am impressed with the fact that today the only way to shut down coal and nuclear plants, is with large windmills. We need to increase funds for solar research.
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

Fairtrade-Messe Konica Minolta Sensing Americas, Inc POWER-GEN Africa EnPower Systems Inc. Planet Solar Inc Krannich Solar Inc. Stoel Rives LLP
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters