The Worlds #1 Renewable Energy Network for News & Information
Sign In or Register
Renewable Energy World Logo
Sunday, May 19, 2013
  • Sections
    • Home
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Solar
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Wind
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Geothermal
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Bio
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Hydro
      • News
      • Opinion & Commentary
      • Featured Blogs
      • Research & Reports
      • Video
      • Press Releases
      • All Blogs
      • Events
      • Products
      • Finance
    • Careers
    • Companies
      • Company Directory
      • Press Releases
      • Products
      • Events Calendar
      • White Papers
    • Webcasts
      • All Webcasts
      • Featured Webcasts
      • Upcoming Webcasts
      • Archived Webcasts
      • Events Calendar
    • White Papers
    • Magazines
      • Renewable Energy World
      • Wind Technology
      • Large Scale Solar
      • Hydro Review
      • HRW - Hydro Review Worldwide
      • Renewable Energy World (North America Edition)
      • Photovoltaics World
    • Awards
  • Account
    • Sign In
    • Register
  • Search

Would Wind Farm 'Desecrate' Site of D-Day Invasion?

Steve Leone
August 16, 2011  |  23 Comments

There’s an interesting battle brewing at the site of perhaps the most famous military landing in modern history.

According to several published reports, the famed beaches at Normandy on the coast of France where Allied troops launched a historic offensive against Nazi Germany on June 6, 1944, are now being flooded by complaints from veterans — mostly from the U.S. and Great Britain — who oppose French President Nicolas Sarkozy’s plan to put 100 wind turbines seven miles offshore. Some go as far to say the turbines would "desecrate" the site.

These are hallowed grounds, they say. To ostensibly line the path of history with 100 turbines is, as British writer Robert Hardman wrote in an op-ed in the Daily Mail, an attack on the past. “If modish environmental dogma takes priority over our most important heritage sites, then a precedent has been set.”

Sure, but who owns the past? For nearly 70 years, that site has all but belonged to Allied veterans, who saw it as a reflection of their democratic ideals. Do wind turbines — barely a thumbnail tall on the horizon seven miles away — change those ideals? And who owns that history? The French certainly own the rights.

The French government is surely keen to the sensitivity of the site. But they also know they are falling behind the renewable energy curve as they contemplate their future energy policy. The country remains deeply invested in nuclear power, with little to show in terms of solar and offshore wind development.

It’ll be interesting to see how they navigate this issue that seems to be more contentious abroad than it is at home.

The information and views expressed in this blog post are solely those of the author and not necessarily those of RenewableEnergyWorld.com or the companies that advertise on this Web site and other publications. This blog was posted directly by the author and was not reviewed for accuracy, spelling or grammar.

23 Comments

Register To Comment
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
September 8, 2011
Anonymous again! "Wind spill"? Well, given it takes many, many barrels of oil and many, many tons of coal, and many, many tons of iron ore to make each windmill, there'll be various spills and mining deaths incorporated into each wind 'farm". That's not counting the Minke whale beachings now occurring due to offshore windmill vibrations coupled into the water. But who cares about whales, eh?

Wonder is Anonymous is like a Rumsfeldian "known unknown", or more mysterious "unknown unknown"?
;]
ANONYMOUS
September 8, 2011
I have been to Normandy and as I recall the French honored our soldiers by creating the site and moving the bodies. I was there for Taps at Noon and it was very moving. As a non-war veteran if I were lying in one of those graves I would be proud to see energy being created in a manor that helps the earth.
The curvature of the earth is at 7 miles so truly these turbines would be very small blips on the radar. And I've never heard of a "Wind Spill"!
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
August 26, 2011
Very well said, Gator -- I hope you were looking in the mirror when you wrote that. Your shame is appropriate.
Allen Gerhardt
Allen Gerhardt
August 26, 2011
When someone lies about the value of wind power, misrepresents himself as an environmentalist, insults British and German people, acts in arrogance and ignorance, I feel ashamed to be an American. Veterans of all wars have sacrificed-none are greater than others. I'm done.
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
August 26, 2011
It's ok John. Now we know what part of the barnyard Gator wallows in.
;]
John Giannasca
John Giannasca
August 26, 2011
aligatorhardt...unnecessary mate! That's not way we should interact here. Emotion is good. Emotion with the edge you have displayed in this forum...not good.
Allen Gerhardt
Allen Gerhardt
August 26, 2011
Well, Dr liar not only swallowed the bait but the line and the boat. I knew by the previous Glen Beck inspired nonsense that the doctor could not give a crap about whales, or any other organism that does not make deposits into his bank account.

Doctor,drag your knuckles back to AOL or whatever other rag you came from, as intelligent people here are actually solving the world's energy problems.

I have had more than I can stomach with the "world's greatest generation" crap. Many of my relatives can speak German and none of them are Nazis. The British and the Russians and other Europeans fought the Nazis for years and lost millions of brave soldiers and countrymen. Then when the Nazis were beat down, the US came in and made one contribution at the shores of Normandy, with some losses, and tried to take credit for the whole effort.
What arrogant steaming piles that is! Yes the "greatest generation" gave us racism, global warming , nuclear contamination, and a foreign policy based on piracy and murder.
Excuse me if I don't stand up to vomit.
John Giannasca
John Giannasca
August 25, 2011
Doc can't let you get away with that. Do you have a color television cos you seem to see the world in black and white!!

subsidized...All renewable energy forms are subsidised

resource-intensive...Remember our previous discussions...wind pays its total energy back in less than a year, PV...well...It doesnt make it bad , I just dont like the argument!

environmentally-invasive...
Wind turbines, like virtually all tall man-made structures, present a collision risk to birds and bats. The risks however are far lower than many imagine – especially when compared to risks of collision with other structures such as communication towers, tall buildings and transmission towers. The impact of wind turbines on birds and bats is insignificant compared to the impact of domestic cats and the loss of habitat through development.
Wind Turbines take up less than 1% of a wind-farm area leaving plenty of room for crop and livestock
Wind turbines need to be placed in locations exposed to strong winds. They are large machines and a wind farm will feature in the landscape. In contrast, fossil power (pants and mines) are predominantly out of the public eye. Large scale coal-fired power stations – the source of 84% of Australia's electricity – are by and large "out-of-sight and out-of-mind".

high-maintenance...Not sure of your point here...this is taken into account in the project economics when assessing the price of wind power, which is the cheapest form at the moment and getting cheaper.

low power density...same comment as above (with exception of the cheaper bit)

intermittent...correct. Wind and PV are intermittent but as our friends in Europe have found, its not a showstopper. Rooftop PV does give transmission benefits, but large scale wind delivers the big reductions.

yadda, yadda... Lets save this for another day!!
Have a good one!!
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
August 25, 2011
So, as a longer-time member of NRDC, Sierra Club, WWF, Ocean Concervancy... than you M. Gator, my opposition to foolish wind power might not be limited to only it, wouldn't you think?

Foolish things are foolish no matter who pushed them.
Allen Gerhardt
Allen Gerhardt
August 25, 2011
Let me provide links for protection of whales and dolphins. http://cetaceanconservation.com.au/cetaceanrights/

Here is the link for www.nrdc.org
Thank you for your concern for sea life and the most intelligent and peaceful residents of the ocean.
Allen Gerhardt
Allen Gerhardt
August 25, 2011
If the good doctor wants to protect whales he should protest off shore oil drilling that is poisoning sea life and oil exploration sound waves that shatter their ears and sonar from ships that damage their senses; these are the most likely causes of whale beachings.
I hope he will add his name to the Cetacean Rights petitions as well and lobby Japan and Iceland to stop killing whales for meat.
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
August 21, 2011
+-27...", might want to delete one of your anonymous msgs, to save server energy.

As for the pomposity of your remark -- subsidized, resource-intensive, environmentally-invasive, high-maintenance, low power density, intermittent, yadda, yadda systems "pray homage" (your typo)? Really?

There are far better ways to serve our iPads & EVs, and still honor folks who did something few here would.

August 21, 2011
I believe that to do such is to actually pray homage to the dead, a modern day illustration of Frances commitment to a form of peaceful energy production.

I for one, applaud their courage and vision, and I ask that all those who disagree, take a moment and ask yourselves this question. Do you want to a future where more young men die for oil? When all the while, wind power is there for our peaceful use. I think we all know the answer to that question.

August 21, 2011
I believe that to do such is to actually pray homage to the dead, a modern day illustration of Frances commitment to a form of peaceful energy production.

I for one, applaud their courage and vision, and I ask that all those who disagree, take a moment and ask yourselves this question. Do you want to a future where more young men die for oil? When all the while, wind power is there for our peaceful use. I think we all know the answer to that question.
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
August 20, 2011
"American fries" for all! Their food proves Brits have no sensibilities.
;]
John Giannasca
John Giannasca
August 20, 2011
I wonder how Americans or Brits would feel if they had to respond to to the sensibilities of our French brothers.
Dr. A. Cannara
Dr. A. Cannara
August 19, 2011
"frivolous complaints from WW2 veterans from foreign countries should be dismissed completely" -- Und vizout zem, ve vood be sprechen ze Deutch, eh, mine oberfurher?

Only 7 miles? That should be expensive, as John knows, in permanent 24/7 power loss and huge upfront fossil-fuel consumption & emissions, eh? Not to mention the whale beachings already occurring near some offshore 'farms'.

Talk about wasting resources & MW! Oh, and subsidies too.
;]
Gregor Giebel
Gregor Giebel
August 19, 2011
Why not combine both things? The turbines could be put where the old temporary harbour is slowly rotting away, to mark the spot. The veterans didn't complain when the USS Arizona in Pearl Harbour got some white structure on top of it, marking it and making it more accessible. It's along the lines of thought of some Dutch designers, quite a few years back - I think Ecofys did the studies back then, and their thinking was, you cannot really make the turbines disappear, so why not mark prominent structures (motorways, canals, dykes) with them? This was in the context of putting up wind turbines in one of the most densely populated countries on earth.
David Scapin
David Scapin
August 19, 2011
This is a France issue and only a French Issue if the locals are okay with putting them 7 miles out of shore where the Locals will barely see these I say go for it. I am sure some Vetrans who fought in that terrible Battle would not have a problem with that.
Thomas M
Thomas M
August 18, 2011
Battles have been fought over nearly every inch of this planet. Why are some battlegrounds more sacred than others. Perhaps if we stopped the battles we wouldn't be having this discussion.
Dave Wilson
Dave Wilson
August 18, 2011
France has gone out of her way to acknowledge and honor the fallen foreign soldiers of D-Day. While I, too, acknowledge an eternal debt to those of the Greatest Generation, I feel that France can certainly move on with its plans now 65 years later. Seven miles is seven miles.
John Giannasca
John Giannasca
August 17, 2011
aligatorhardt...I agree and well put.
Allen Gerhardt
Allen Gerhardt
August 17, 2011
These frivolous complaints from WW2 veterans from foreign countries should be dismissed completely. They do not even live in the country of France, and to object to turbines 7 miles away on a visual basis is absurd. The turbines would appear one half inch high from the shore, if visible at all. This project is the business of the French alone.

Add Your Comments

To add your comments you must sign-in or create a free account.

  • Create a Free Account!
  • Sign-In
Steve Leone

Steve Leone

Steve Leone has been a journalist for more than 15 years and has worked for news organizations in Rhode Island, Maine, New Hampshire, Virginia and California.
  • About
  • Articles
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • FOLLOW
  • CONTACT
Stay Connected
         
To register for our free e-Newsletters, create your free account here:

Create a free account and start adding your blogs.

Create an Account

Most Commented

  • 17
    The Economic Case for Divesting from Fossil Fuels
  • 9
    Breakdown: Penetration of Renewable Energy in Selected Markets
  • 5
    Ireland Keen to Hit 2030 Renewable Targets, Says EU Ambassador
  • 3
    No Easy Fix for Broken Wind Turbine at US High School

Total Access Partners

Growing Your Business? Learn More about Total Access
  • Active Communications International
  • Admirals Bank
  • EnergyDreams LLC
  • Arena Solutions
  • The Stella Group, Ltd.
  • AEG Power Solutions
  • Fairtrade-Messe
  • ExxonMobil Lubricants & Specialties Europe
News
  • Renewable Energy
  • Solar Energy
  • Wind Energy
  • Bioenergy
  • Geothermal Energy
  • Hyrdo Power
  • Blogs
  • Video
  • Finance
Resources
  • Companies
  • Products
  • Careers
  • Events
  • Webcasts
  • White Papers
  • Magazines
  • Press Releases
  • e-Newsletters
Company
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising & Services
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Site Map
  • News
  • Conference & Expo
Network Partners - Magazines
  • Hydro Review Magazine
  • Hydro Review Worldwide Magazine
  • Renewable Energy World Magazine
Network Partners - Events
  • Power-Gen International
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
  • Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India
  • HydroVision International
  • HydroVision Brazil
  • HydroVision India
  • HydroVision Russia
© Copyright 1999-2013 RenewableEnergyWorld.com - All rights reserved.
RenewableEnergyWorld.com - World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for news & Information