Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

The Quest for Alternative Fuel in the Aviation Industry Takes Off

By James DiGeorgia, The Gold and Energy Advisor
November 24, 2008   |   14 Comments

Do you like this opinion & commentary?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 

The information and views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of RenewableEnergyWorld.com or the companies that advertise on its Web site and other publications.

14 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 14
November 24, 2008
At the price of being cynical, in this instance I have no issue with aviation continuing to rely on petroleum fuels for the foreseeable future. It represents a small percentage of total petroleum consumption and by far the benefits it brings the world outweigh it's environmental costs.

After all, Diesel and jet fuel are basically refined from the same hydrocarbon range. Therefore, alternatives to ground based diesel fuel would have an equal impact on net petroleum consumption while at the same time not have to meet the same technical standards are a JET-A equivalent.

So using electrified rail, biomethane for trucks, PHEVs, biodiesel, et al would have the same net impact on petroleum consumption vs. developing JET-A biofuels. The former sounds easier to me.
Comment
2 of 14
November 26, 2008
I think new airline fuel will encompass a new type of airliner. One of the most powerful pressures is using steam, that can be produced via microwave electric pulse into thermos tanks that already have a hot temp. thereby using small amounts of electricity to reach the steam levels...which would circulate.

Another great option is using the pollution in the atmosphere as a fuel resource. Tapping that resource is a very real component to gases being used that are refined while in the atmosphere.
Comment
3 of 14
November 26, 2008
I was disappointed to see that this article only focused on hydrocarbon-based fuels with no mention of developing hydrogen-powered aircraft - water vapor is, of course, already present in the atmosphere.

Earlier this year Boeing conducted a test flight of a hydrogen-powered plane (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7330311.stm). However, even though the tests were successful, Boeing claimed that they didn't think "fuel cells could be the primary power source for large passenger aircraft." I'm sure Boeing's R&D budget has experienced drastic cuts over the last couple years, which might explain their lack of will in taking the risk to develop this technology, but fuel cells represent a genuinely clean alternative that is capable of meeting the power demands of large aircraft.
Comment
4 of 14
November 26, 2008
Air New Zealand biofuel test flight all set. The world's first commercial aviation test flight powered by a sustainable second-generation biofuel is ready to go next Wednesday 3 December 2008

The jatropha fuel has now been blended 50:50 with standard Jet A1 fuel by Air New Zealand at its Auckland Engineering Base. The biofuel blend, named J50, has now been transferred into an RNZAF fuel tanker ready to fuel the Air New Zealand Boeing 747-400 early next week.

The two-hour test flight is scheduled to take off from Auckland airport on Wednesday morning 3 December, with the jatropha biofuel blend powering one of the Air New Zealand Boeing 747-400's Rolls-Royce RB211 engines.

keep New Zealand green
Comment
5 of 14
November 26, 2008
According to National Renewable Energy Laboratory, algae produce biodiesel from 5.000 to 20,000 gal/acre. It also reported that algae which contain 50 % of oil can be grown at 50 g/m2/day.
I have no idea how much jet-fuel is needed to satisfy world-wide demand, the cultivation of algae for the demand would require a huge cultivation farms.
I believe that we have to concentrate extensively to develop technology to produce them in a large amount in a short life cycle.
what i think is that we should divide transportation in two, one is high speed trains for less than 1,000 miles at 200 mph or faster and two is airplanes for beyond the distance.
High speed trains can be run renewable energy. Other ground transportation systems including trains slower than 100 mph and buses should fill outside space of high speed trains and airplanes service areas. All ground systems can run on renewable energy.
The fuel for airplanes is pet-oil until bio-jet fuel technology becomes mature and supply all jet fuel.
Trains can be environmentally clean using renewables. They are very energy efficient, They need only from 1/5 to 1/12 of energy per passenger base of cars and 1/8 of energy of airplanes.
Comment
6 of 14
November 26, 2008
Mr. DiGorgia: I am surprised you did not mention hydrogen as a fuel. In 1957, NASA tested a B-57 bomber using hydrogen in place of the jet fuel. It was successful. With the new light-weight carbon fiber tanks that can hold hydrogen at 10,000 psi, it has the highest energy density of any fuel and is lighter in weight. With Boeing's new carbon fiber lighter weight jet liner, the hydrogen propulsion would be an ideal combination.
Comment
7 of 14
November 26, 2008
Sir: Correction, DiGeorgia. sorry about the mis-spelled name.
Comment
8 of 14
November 26, 2008
I am no Big Three sycophant, but it is patently false to claim that "Over the last 30 years, U.S. car manufacturers haven't cut motor vehicle emissions at all". For example, a 2007 Ford Fiesta MK6 (UK car) produces over 98% less NOx, CO and HC than did a 1976 Ford Fiesta MK1. In the U.S., the fuel consumption of the average car decreased between 1975 and 2008 by some 35% (GHG emissions are directly related to fuel consumption). More cuts to both criteria air contaminants (CACs) and GHGs could certainly have been made, and I hold strong hopes that we will see a real change in powertrain technology; however, it is important that advocates for green energy not overstate their cases and present falsehoods that allow the naysayers an opening to dismiss our arguments.
Comment
9 of 14
November 26, 2008
Warren Reynolds: there is a difference between "energy density" and "specific energy" that I think you have missed. Energy density has units of Wh/L while specific energy has units of Wh/kg. Therefore, your statement that hydrogen "has the highest energy density of any fuel" is not true--but will be if you change it to specific energy.
Comment
10 of 14
November 28, 2008
Maybe we better focus investment on high capacity communication technologies (wireless or broadband with audio-visual support and enhance teleconferences), strive to reduce frequent and long distance travel and enjoy feeling comfortable not only with gained personal time but also with growing credit points on our saving accounts for avoided GHG emissions. Reducing our ecological footprint and improving resource efficiency balance will be more decisive for our sustainable future than temporary solutions with fuel from algae, jatropha and other fuel commodities which finally all have difficulties to compete with GHG-reduction achieved through a new paradigm focussed on lower transportation needs.
Comment
11 of 14
November 29, 2008
If only it were that simple:

"Making Biofuel out of Small Farmers"

http://gristmill.grist.org/story/2008/11/24/203023/24

"...A final interesting point is that planting a non food crop like castor or Jatropha (both contain toxins and are inedible) benefits the biodiesel refiner as it means that there is no market competition for the farmer's production. For the farmer it limits their options, but more importantly, the crops can't be eaten if the refiner doesn't deliver as is the case in the above story..."
Comment
12 of 14
November 30, 2008
I feel bad for criticising someone who is contibuting to what I see as a worthy cause, but I think the standard of this article is low.

For example, seed oil derivatives are not normally considered a second generation biofuel. Second generation biofuels are those which aim to offer a step change in energy harvest density by using the 'whole plant' - to harness a larger fraction of the plant's energy reserves than just the seed oil or carbohydrates.

While seed oil derivatives can provide a much higher "well-to-wing" energy yield compared to ethanol, mainly due to the lower energy consumption in it's manufacture, true second generation fuels such as cellulosics or waste derived products need all the publicity they can get - I'm shocked by the lack of attention they get in this article.
Comment
13 of 14
November 30, 2008
--------"Even these oils can't supply all of aviation's needs, though. Most industry experts agree that the best long-term solution is likely to come from algae. The benefit to algae is it can produce an oil yield up to 15 times that of other biofuel plants. In theory, every airplane in the world could be supplied by a total cultivated area the size of West Virginia. The other advantage is that some algae actually consume greenhouse gases during their cultivation, rather than producing it (as corn ethanol production does)."------

This statement from the article is untrue. All biofuels are produced from plant sources that must remove CO2 from the atmosphere. If they do not remove the CO2 from the atmosphere, the plants can not carry out photosynthesis---hence, no crop. No crop, no biofuel.

Also, sorry folks, this is NOT new and untried technology. Germany developed and deployed rockets and jet aircraft powered by synthetic and biofuels including methanol and ethanol in World War 2, including the world's first operational jet aircraft the Me-262 Swallow, the manned rocket aircraft, the Komet, and the unmanned V-1 and V-2 ballistic missles.

These fuels were produced using coal and wood sources using the Fsischer-Tropsch process, which can be adapted to produce alcohols, and also long chain hydrocarbons.

This was all being done almost 70 years ago.

Fischer-Tropsch can produce ethanol and/or longer carbon chain molecule output by adjusting temperature and catalyst parameters, and uses any type of plant cellulose feedstock.

Fischer-Tropsch process is the process that will be used in a plant being constructed right now in Soperton, GA, that will produce 100 million gallons per year of ethanol from logging and millwork waste wood.
Comment
14 of 14
January 4, 2009
----"Air New Zealand has become the first airline to test a 50/50 blend of the green fuel in a Boeing 747-400 passenger jet:"--------
-------"The flight lasted two hours and ran one of the plane's Rolls-Royce engines on the jatropha biodiesel blend. Air New Zealand has previously stated that they want to become the world's most sustainable airline and hopes that by 2013, 10% of its flights will be powered by biofuel blends such as the jatropha biodiesel blend used in this test flight.

Air New Zealand said the the jatropha used to make the fuel came from South Eastern Africa (Malawi, Mozambique and Tanzania) and India. They also claim that the oil was produced from Jatropha seeds grown on "environmentally sustainable farms."

As a second generation biofuel, jatropha is grown on land that doesn't compete with food. Jatropha requires almost no care and very little water. Another major benefit of jatropha is that, due to its ability to take hold in harsh wastelands, it can be used to help stop erosion in these areas and reclaim them for agricultural production."-------

From the article: Kiwis Make First Jatropha Biodiesel Flight

link: http://domesticfuel.com/2008/12/30/kiwis-make-first-jatropha-biodiesel-flight/
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

WindPole Ventures, LLC Endurance Wind Power IntertechPira RBI Solar Inc. National Solar Trainers Richardson RFPD, Inc. Motech Industries, Inc.
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters