Photo Credit: HSWAC
article tools
Increase Text Size Increase Text Size Decreate Text Size Decrease Text Size
Share Email This Story Share Share This Story Reader comments Reader Comments (12) View image gallery Image Gallery (1) Add to favorites Add to Bookmarks Printer friendly version Printer Friendly Version
Article Tool Sponsor:

Advertise with us

More Jobs
0 ratings - Sign-in to rate this article
July 9, 2008

Investors Fund US $10.75 M for Honolulu Seawater Air Conditioning

by Peter Myers
Hawaii, United States [RenewableEnergyWorld.com]

Private investors have completed the US $10.75 million equity financing for Honolulu Seawater Air Conditioning, the innovative renewable energy project for downtown Honolulu. The company anticipates a construction start date of January 5, 2009.

"We are excited to have the private equity in place, enabling us to proceed with the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), detail engineering plans and project development," announced William (Bill) Mahlum, President and CEO of Honolulu Seawater Air Conditioning, LLC (HSWAC). "This will be a very busy year as we prepare for construction and complete our marketing efforts."

The equity financing for the US $152 million project has been provided by private investors in the U.S. and Sweden, with more than half of the cash coming from Honolulu investors.

"The significant commitment from local investors demonstrates their excitement and confidence in this new community asset," said Mahlum. "Seawater air conditioning will protect businesses from the skyrocketing electric rates caused by oil price increases and everybody will benefit from a cleaner environment," he said. Mahlum added that most of the remaining project costs would be covered by approximately US $140 million in construction financing.

"As Hawaii grapples with the dual threats of US $100-a-barrel oil and global climate change, the time is absolutely right for the development of this zero-emissions air conditioning system," said Mahlum. "Reducing our use of fossil fuels and preserving the environment will be a wonderful legacy that we all leave to future generations of Hawaii residents."

Conventional air conditioning is a heavy consumer of energy in Honolulu, which relies on imported oil and other fossil fuels for a staggering 90% of its electricity. HSWAC will reduce Hawaii's dependence on imported oil used to generate electricity. It will dramatically reduce operating costs for downtown building owners, with the savings increasing as oil prices climb. With oil at US $80-a-barrel, the savings in overall operating costs are projected to be 16.1%, but those savings climb to 21.7% with US $100-a-barrel oil prices. In addition, HSWAC customers will no longer need to worry about periodic capital expenditures to repair or replace expensive on-site cooling equipment.

Downtown building owners have, of course, responded enthusiastically to the prospect of lower operating costs and stable rates for 25 years. The HSWAC system already has made commitments to future customers totaling more than 50% of the system's 25,000-ton capacity. Among those signing letters of intent are the Prince Kuhio Federal Building and Hawaiian Electric Company (HECO), which sent letters to its customers encouraging them "to carefully consider utilizing deep-water cooling for your building's air conditioning requirements." The utility pledged to sign up for the new service at its headquarters and to turn off its own electric-powered cooling system.

How It Works

Seawater will be drawn from a depth of approximately 1,600 feet at a temperature of about 45 DF. It will be pumped to a cooling station onshore, where heat exchangers enable it to cool fresh water that circulates in a closed loop to customer buildings. After passing through the heat exchangers, the warmed seawater will be returned to the ocean at a shallower depth, using a diffuser that ensures proper mixing and dilution.

Deep water cooling is a proven technology in Canada and the U.S. In Ithaca, N.Y., Cornell University uses water from Cayuga Lake to cool its campus. Toronto's system uses deep water from Lake Ontario to cool its downtown buildings. The technology has tremendous potential for other urban areas located adjacent to large bodies of cold water.

Honolulu Seawater Air Conditioning will be managed under a long-term management contract by Renewable Energy Innovations, LLC, an affiliate of America's most widely-recognized district heating and cooling system located in Saint Paul, Minnesota. That company's President, Anders Rydaker, and HSWAC Vice President of Engineering, Ingvar Larsson, pioneered seawater air conditioning in their native Sweden and are now bringing this technology to Honolulu.

The Honolulu Seawater Air Conditioning project has received encouragement from the Governor's Office, the Hawaii State Legislature, Hawaii's Congressional delegation and numerous business, environmental, labor and civic organizations.

Peter Myers is an independent media consultant and video producer based in Minneapolis/St. Paul.

Image Gallery (1)
 
Reader Comments (12)
 
No image available
July 9, 2008
The Honolulu project site claims that it saves about 80% of the energy compared to a standard chiller with air-side heat rejection system. Perhaps reality is less than that, but still the savings are impressive. If the economics work (you're sitting next to deep cold water, you can afford a huge up-front investment, etc) it's worth doing. However, it's not completely isolated from power rate increases; it's just more energy efficient.

The other problem is that the straight-through heat exchanger probably puts out a chilled water supply temperature to the building of about 48F. That's pretty marginal (a typical standard is 42F) for cooling, unless you have nice gentle summers, such as Hawaii, Ithaca, or Stockholm. This might be practical in the San Francisco Bay Area, less so in LA.
Comment 1 of 12
No image available
July 9, 2008
I wonder what the energy requirements of pumping the water are compared to that of conventional air conditioning and compared to conventional geothermal heat pumps. Anybody know?
Comment 2 of 12
No image available
July 10, 2008
Ok energy check, what about the ocean itself with all the living organisms and ecosystems. I fear construction in any form, especially around coast lines. Runoff is inevitable and has been going on in Hawaii for years, in addition to the slow decay of coral. But whatever, I don't have millions; therefore, I can't talk, only on the bottom of comment pages........live on.
Comment 3 of 12
No image available
The 48F is the Hawaiin deep water temperature. The temp in LA may be colder making it a viable option there as well.
Comment 4 of 12
No image available
July 10, 2008
I believe that they are going to use a double loop heat exchange system so that fresh water and not cold salt water would be used in the pipes going to the buildings. This system should prevent corrosion of the pipes.

Since such a high percent of all electricity in Hawaii is presently generated by burning fossil fuels (mostly sour or high sulfur oil from Indonesia), good savings should result.

adrianakau2aol.com
Comment 5 of 12
No image available
July 11, 2008
Since you are pumping large amounts of water from the deep why not combine this project with an OTEC 'spar'? If not for grid power then perhaps generate only enough to do the air conditioning pumping. One problem with OTEC is the proximity of the differential temp. water to population needing electricity; in this case you need the power right where you are pumping cold water to begin with.
Comment 6 of 12
No image available
July 11, 2008
Cold water from the deep ocean is very clean in terms of pollution and the larvae of pipe fouling organisms and is usually nutrient rich. This raises the possibility of letting the water out into shallow ponds or even an impounded bay, sometimes with a little silicate added to encourage diatoms, and then passing the water through 3D oyster beds. The Pacific oyster can be brought to a large commercial size in 8 or 9 months. Why waste this water by diffusing it back into the ocean. Get another product out of it.

Another wrinkle if this system catches on world wide. Such a system, would start to lower the level of the thermocline. If you don't think it is possible, look at other effects man has had on his environment. Who would have thought we could destroy the Amazon rain forest or cut away large mountains for their minerals. As the thermocline lowers, clatrates will start to release their methane. Could be interesting.
Comment 7 of 12
No image available
July 11, 2008
The article notes a January '09 start-up date and that they will now begin the environmental impact statement (EIS). The EIS process takes at the very minimum one year, assuming no significant controversy. This technology appears to have tremendous potential, but I often wonder about the credibility of press releases. Does anyone know who will be the federal lead agency for the EIS- DOI/MMS or FERC? FERC has asserted jurisdiction over wave energy projects, thereby conveying EIS lead status and regulatory authority. Hawaii's Coastal Zone Management Act (HCZMA) will have to be followed as well. I am confident environmental impacts can be minimized if project construction is approached sensibly and with the sensitivity to protect Hawaii's valuable coastal and marine resources. Hawaii has tremendous potential with renewables, many of which the Hawaii Renewable Energy Lab has studied. We now have rapidly advancing technologies spurred by rising oil prices, which are opening up a world of opportunities. Seems like lots of expertise out there judging from above comments.
Comment 8 of 12
No image available
July 11, 2008
This project sounds very familiar to the experimental Ocean Thermal Energy Technology (OTEC) projects of the early 1980's. The enemy of OTEC is marine fouling and salt water corrosion. I helped build an experimental 50 kW OTEC plant on top of a 60 x 160 ft. barge. It produced 50 kW total, but needed 40 kW to run the pumps, therefore netting only 10 kW. I saw this barge sitting next to the pier years later, and it was totally corroded in ~only two years of operation.
Comment 9 of 12
No image available
July 11, 2008
I agree with Muir Matteson. The buildings ARE going to be cooled, so they might as well use a local resource, rather than tankers bringing oil across that same ocean.
Comment 10 of 12
No image available
July 11, 2008
Pumping the seawater around shouldn't take a great deal of energy. It may be coming from 1600 feet down, but it doesn't have to be LIFTED 1600 feet, as water might have to be lifted from the depths of a well in the desert. The seawater enters the pipe with all the pressure of the water above it, so the pumps have to do no more work than if the pipe were horizontal and on the surface. This is a very small pumping job. The heat exchanger, with a large number of narrow openings, presents a bit of friction. Even so, it probably still requires only a tenth the electricity of a conventional air conditioning setup.

Regarding the underwater environmental impact, it's really not huge. Look at the overall picture. The project has some impact, yes. But look at the impact it prevents. It keeps a lot of fossil fuels from being burned on Oahu. So, there will be less ships crossing the ocean, less chance of oil spills, less air pollution, less runoff. On the whole, a big positive.
Comment 11 of 12
No image available
July 12, 2008
It sounds like a good idea. I'm surprised it took this long. They could line the saline section of piping with a glass if corrosion is a problem, but I'm sure they have thought of an obvious thing like salt water corrosion before spending all this money.
Comment 12 of 12
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In
Featured Total Access Partners
Click company logos to learn more
Third Sun Solar and Wind Power, Ltd. OutBack Power Systems Krannich Solar Inc. KYOCERA Solar, Inc. National Hydropower Association The Wall Street Green Trading Summit IX
WORLD'S #1 RENEWABLE ENERGY NETWORK
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network Logo