Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

Biogas Flows Through Germany's Grid Big Time

By Jane Burgermeister
July 17, 2008   |   21 Comments

Do you like this news?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 
Germany's four big energy providers have recognized the value of biogas and we think there will be a bright future for large-scale biogas plants that feed gas into the national grid."

-- Andrea Horbelt, German Biogas Association
21 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 21
July 17, 2008
Anything that is compostable can be used as a feedstock for biogas. Therefore, the obvious answer to the feedstock problem is to use organic material diverted from our waste stream. This kills three birds with one stone: a). Less material going to landfill; b). Less methane production in landfills; c). free energy source for biogas production. Interestingly enough, manure is not an ideal feedstock (too much nitrogen); the ideal feedstock has a carbon to nitrogen ratio of 30:1. If you want to see how different material combinations will affect methane outputs, check out the Anaerobic Digestor Calculator located here: http://biorealis.com/wwwroot/digester_revised.html .

So where could one find a bunch of carbon-heavy, organic feedstock? Hmmm...how about suburban American? With our sprawling lawns and fastidious homeowners...we produce a heck of a lot of organic material (grass clippings, etc) that just goes to waste. My hometown of Madison, WI, for example, has to pay to truck this waste to 3 big composting sites outside of town...why not just use this as an energy source right in town?

I've written a complete business plan for a green restaurant chain that powers its stoves and heats its premise with biogas produced from kitchen waste and lawn waste from the surrounding neighborhood. The scrubbed C02 goes back into an onsite greenhouse, to boost fruits/vegetable growth, which is then used in the restaurant. If you'd like to see the business plan or get involved, just drop me an email: paulschechter@yahoo.com
Comment
2 of 21
July 17, 2008
I think that this is a great thing. There are so many alternatives to oil and I hope this continues. I think however that non food bio mass needs to be used. I do agree with Mr. Hunt that Algae biomas is a great idea. I am also behind the increased use of Wind, Wave, Geothermal and nuke plants. Go Germany. Lets get this monkey off our backs!!!!!
Comment
3 of 21
July 17, 2008
I have read where some communities are sequestering the CO2 from biogas by growing algae to scrub CO2 out of the mixture, then are using the algae to make biofuels such as biodiesel. Insofar as crops, I think only non-food portions of these crops, e.g. wheat chaff or corn stover should be used. Cow manure and hog operations would be a good source of biogas. I understand that Europe and Asia have invested in methane-powered vehicles a lot more than the US. I don't agree with T. Boone Pickens on lots of things, but he may have a point about natural gas powered vehicles. I think biogas and algae may offer the best hope for using biomass energy. I am unsure about ethanol and have even bigger doubts about methanol.
Comment
4 of 21
July 17, 2008
Hi Robert and Charles,

Andrea Horbelt said there is a big push in Germany right now to find alternatives to food crops for biogas plants, including grass, straw, manure...

She believd there are plenty of other options to using food crops in the long-term. The new government tariffs are also steering biogas away from food crops.

Jane
Comment
5 of 21
July 17, 2008
I wonder what the possibilities are for sequestering the CO2 that is filtered out of the biogas. Usually the collection step is the hard part in CO2 sequestration but here that is already solved. If they can find a place to stick the stuff this would turn the technology from carbon neutral to carbon negative....
Comment
6 of 21
July 17, 2008
In agreement with Robert's comment. Although I agree with biogass from agricultural residues, only following an original intention to produce food, I don't agree with intensive growth of crops specifically for biogass, or biofuel production for that matter. When considering population growing as it is, some nations may be better fixed trying to produce more food internally rather than importing, which has a heavy reliance on fuel.
Comment
7 of 21
July 18, 2008
Biogas IS the better biofuel. Biogas can be made from organic waste, cow manure, human manure, yard cuttings, kitchen waste, fire suppression cuttings. The bi-product after the methane is captured is non petroleum base fertilizer that can be utilized in agriculture. You do not need fresh food crops, when you can use virtually any organic waste source, Use the corn stock not the corn. Since Americans are the most wasteful people on the planet, that shouldn't be a problem. If we ever do run out of waste, there is a special non edible maize developed by the French that is very effective as another feed source.

Capturing biogas will reduce the GHG, (methane) from entering the atmosphere as it does now from landfill. There is a cattle rancher who had a 2000 ton pile of manure that caught fire and burned for two years. That pile could have been turned into methane and fertilizer and the rancher could have made a profit selling methane to the local gas company and selling the fertilizer to local farmers.

Processing organic waste for biogas will reduce the landfill problem by 50%. Sewage plants can produce Biogas like they do in Sweden, which runs a train on biogas.

Running our vehicles on biomethane is sustainable. Anaerobic digestion of all our organic waste is the way to go. keep natural gas as backup.

Forget biodiesel (Cold weather problems, only works with diesel vehicles), Forget ethanol (potential conflict with food crops) Biomethane burns cleaner. Being a gas it will never spill into the ocean or any where else to contaminate the environment. The natural gas grid already exists and can be easily expanded. No more fuel trucks running the road, Wherever the grid runs a fueling station can be installed. And you can fuel up at home with an fueling appliance call PHILL

I'm considering trading in my Prius for a cleaner, greener, Honda GX running on CNG.
Comment
8 of 21
July 18, 2008
A great thing about this process is that the residue has everything in it that it had originally except for some H and C. The residue is a great fertilizer and can be put right back on the fields it came from, reducing the need for fertilizer produced with fossil fuel energy. Even better, the proportion of the elements in the residue is pretty close to what is required by many plants. The plant-animal cycle has already seen to that.
Out of curiosity, does anyone know what process is actually being used to scrub out the CO2.
Incidentally, some ancient work has shown that if water hyacinths which have been used to scrub out a range of elements from the outflow of certain factories are used to produce biogass, for some reason, the proportion of methane in the biogas is much higher.
Comment
9 of 21
July 18, 2008
Great Work,
What will be the scale of the Digester and is there only one digester or several>?
I do feel that instead of going for one big scale digester, we should OPT for some small scale digesters too so that according to me in BIOLOGICAL DIGESTIONS - LARGER THE SCALE BIGGER THE RISKS INVOLVED so why to take risk at this stage where Biogas plants have come a reall long way frm Gobar gas plants.
But then too taking risks is again a great job, unless some one tries nobody will come to know the right scale so all the best and will be looking forward for the plant efficiency and economics.
If anyone can post me then i would be thanfull to them.
srinivaskasulla@gmail.com
Comment
10 of 21
July 18, 2008
Not to worry about the carbon dioxide from biogas - just use it as food for algae in a bioreactor. Then take the algae resdue and feed it back into the biomass process to make more methane. It's a low loss system.
Comment
11 of 21
July 18, 2008
What is the time unit for the rated capacity? If that is on a yearly basis, then I believe there are other facilities that have a greater output.
Comment
12 of 21
July 18, 2008
I read a report today about a fermentation process for turning wood-based syngas into ethanol. It does look really cost-effective and would be great for keeping our existing cars on the road. However...
New Zealand had an enviable programme for converting cars to dual-fuel and still have all the pipelines in place - although government policy changes meant we stopped the incentives too early and all the natural gas compressors and dual-fuelled cars are now gone. Anyway, this article made me think that we might be better piping gas around the North Island of NZ, than building a huge plant to convert this gas into a liquid fuel. I'm sure the investors will want the option to export, so liquid fuels are the only way to go.

Also, for the record - I reckon a mag like REW should know that the unit "kW/h" makes no sense at all and that the "k" in kW should always be small case. Small thing? Maybe.
Comment
13 of 21
All renewable organic materials (ROM) contain bioenergy/biofuel and elements (plant nutrients and other elements) and can be used as a feedstock for biogas.
We need novel systems and methods for production of biogas and biofertilisers. High solids anaerobic digestion (HSAD) should be improved. Dry and carbon-rich ROM have to be processed together with wet and nitrogen-rich ROM. Future HSAD should be seen as feed processing equipment used to create the best conditions for methanogenic microorganisms that produce methane by the fermentation. Today we do not have first-class recipes neither advanced technology adjusted to biotransformation of ROM by microorganisms.
Closed local facilities with modern design, logistic, robotics, automation and IT are necessery for management of ROM from household and industrial waste, human and animal excreta, residues from forestry, agriculture, horticulture, all green areas as well as from floods, lakes and seas.
My research was focused on plant nutrients recycling and improvement of soil fertility. Unfortunately, it is impossible to efficiently recycle plant nutrients without drawing attention to bioenergy. We need to realise that bioenergy and element in ROM are both key subjects for our survival. We use ROM for food, feed, fibre and fuel (as methane in biogas). Biogas is generally considered to be carbon neutral.
We have to phase out unsustainable technologies as incineration of ROM and sewage systems. Emissions from these technologies are expensive and polluting losses of energy and elements.
Albert Einstein: "We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them."
Comment
14 of 21
July 18, 2008
Food waste from households and food processing and catering industries can provide substantial inputs to biogas plants. With increasing cost of waste disposal, this is the way to go.
Comment
15 of 21
July 18, 2008
Brandon,

I finally saw the calculations on what it would take for algaculture to produce biofuel and I don't think you'll be seeing anything other than demonstration projects in that field ever. The CO2 from this process can go back into the wild since that's where it all came from.

There isn't any way to sequester this CO2, since that costs a significant amount of energy and the process of AD is already at a disadvantage compared to fossil fuels.
Comment
16 of 21
July 18, 2008
Biogas production is far more flexible than simply energy crops. Biogas can be upgraded from mixed municipal waste feedstocks, food wastes, sewage sludge and landfill gas. In the UK were are also getting a increasing focus on the potential biogas can have to be fed in to the National Grid. There are a number of technical and logistical issues to be resolved first, and also to create a level playing field in so far as green energy tarrifs for upgraded biogas are concerned.
Comment
17 of 21
July 20, 2008
Excellent news and hopefully we soon adopt these technologies in Ecuador that is a rich country in biomass production and has huge advantages for its weather and average temperatures.
Fermentation processes in tropical countries are more robust not only for its weather, but also for complex microflora consorces involved in.
We would like to contact experienced personnel and/or companies interested in investments in Ecuador to produce biogas from agricultural waste materials.
If someone is looking forward investments, please write to ejcarvajal@puce.edu.ec.
Thanks,
Javier Carvajal
Comment
18 of 21
July 20, 2008
All thing said and done I find that the user is not educated enough to make use of these technologies. Is bio digestor as easiliy available as a diesel engine?
Is it is as easily operable?
Then again how he is supposed to know that his machines are operating effectively?Are there instruments to check for it available on site?
Technologies and methodologies which can be translated in an easy manner to the user, needs to be evolved . The technology must come out of the labs irrespective of furthur development on the way. Energy crisis is for the real.
Even if it is little improvement , it can be used and development can continue
Comment
19 of 21
July 20, 2008
Biogas for Clean Environment
Now a days, city garbage with decomposable and non-decomposable materials is a big problem. Similarly, production of methane gas from the agricultural fields is also another problem to all environment concerning people. Agricultural processing plants are producing by-products which is polluting not only fields but also running water (rivers, lakes etc). I am very much interested to know about the utilization of olive by-products after olive extraction on production of methane gas and supply to those who need fuels to cook food. I hope your suggestions for my future industry in Nepal.
Thank you.
Regards,
Comment
20 of 21
July 21, 2008
Hello all.. No No DON'T USE NEW FOOD! It is a much more efficient system to COLLECT AND USE POST CONSUMER FOOD SCRAPS!!!!!! There is so much waste that will produce great methane, plus great compost to go back to the farms and improve food security.

In the San Francisco Bay Area all our haulers collect food scraps & food contaminated papers from restaurants and commercial kitchens (about 75% of their discards), giving them a discount from their refuse fees. Also, residents can put the same food scraps in their green carts for weekly collection of their garden trimmings. Our participation is high.

This is fabulous material to anaerobically digest to capture methane. The solid residue is excellent COMPOST that goes to FARMERS, where it replaces lost carbon, sequesters carbon in soil, improves water retention, reduce need for ghg producing fossil-fuel derived fertilizer

If instead this material goes into landfill, it generates methane into the air - usually before the capture equipment is installed.

This system reduces greenhouse gas emissions at every point, while producing energy, product (compost), and food security.

Using urban source-separated feedstock, you can locate the anaerobic digester in the urban area, and produce the gas for urban use (also to fuel city cng vehicles.)

In California we're working on siting anaerobic digesters for this material0. Currently most of us haul the organics to rural areas for aerobic composting. (also good, but no energy capture). The straight garden trimmings, and possibly the residue from anaerobic, will continue to go there.

Isn't germany already doing wet/dry refuse collection? What's happening to the wet stream now?

For more information on food scrap collection, go to www.stopwaste.org.
Tania Levy
Recycling program manager
City of Berkeley
Comment
21 of 21
June 16, 2010
Viaspace.com has the answer with its GKC (Giant King Grass) They Just partnered up with a Biogas producer in Germany and it slowly spreading around the world Go check it out.
VIASPACE SIGNS AGREEMENT WITH GERMAN BIOGAS PRODUCER RUBA ENERGIE GMBH
06/14/2010

Giant King grass growing in Europe for the first time
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

Blue Sky Energy, Inc. ESI Inc. of Tennessee Puralytics Apricus, Inc. Mitsubishi Electric & Electronics USA, Inc. Cantsink Manufacturing Geothermal Energy Association
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters