Photo Credit: Gerhard Koller/MAK
article tools
Increase Text Size Increase Text Size Decreate Text Size Decrease Text Size
Share Email This Story Share Share This Story Reader comments Reader Comments (44) View image gallery Image Gallery (1) Add to favorites Add to Bookmarks Printer friendly version Printer Friendly Version
Article Tool Sponsor:

Advertise with us

More Jobs
0 ratings - Sign-in to rate this article
December 21, 2007

Introducing the Solar Tree

by Jane Burgermeister

The streets of Europe could soon be lit by solar energy due to the fact that a solar tree prototype recently passed a key test phase.

The solar trees went on display for four weeks in October on a busy street — the Ringstrasse — in Vienna, Austria.  They were able to provide enough light during the night-time even when the sun did not show for as much as four days in a row.

"The solar cells on the tree were able to store enough electricity in spite of receiving no direct solar light for days at a time because of the clouds. They showed that solar trees really are a practical form of street lighting," Christina Werner from Cultural Project Management (Kulturelles Projektmanagement, Vienna) told RenewableEnergyAccess.com.

She said that the City of Vienna was now in the process of deciding whether to install more solar trees.

"We hope that not only the city of Vienna but other cities will see the merits of using renewable energy for street lighting to cut emissions," Christina Werner said. "Someday soon solar trees could well be the main form of street lighting in Europe."

Putting solar powered LED light systems on trees would cut down on the carbon emissions and also slash the bills of local authorities, she said.

Street lighting consumed 10 percent of all the electricity used in Europe in 2006 or 2,000 billion KWh, and resulted in carbon emissions of 2,900 million ton.

The use of more energy-efficient lighting in the Austrian city of Graz, with a population of almost 300,000 saved the city 524,000 KWh of electricity and 67,200 euros [US $96,800] in 2005.

 

 Close up of branches on a solar tree in Vienna.  (Credit: Gerhard Koller/MAK)

"Not just trees but other objects could be decorated with solar cells and so keep streets well lit at night time," she said.

The branches of the solar tree were decorated with 10 solar lamps, each one comprising 36 solar cells; they also had rechargeable batteries and electronic systems.

A sensor was used to measure the amount of light in the atmosphere and trigger the solar lamps to go on automatically at sunset and off at sunrise.

The tree's lights went on for the first time in Vienna on October 8, 2007 at 11:00 pm. They are now on display outside the La Scala opera house in Milan.

The tree was designed by Ross Lovegrove, a British designer, who said that they are not only efficient but also attractive and bring "nature into a gray city environment".

An Italian company specializing in designer lighting systems, Artemide, as well as the world's largest producer of photovoltaic (PV) cells, the German company Sharp Solar, joined forces to turn the design into reality.

The idea came from Peter Noever, the Director of the Austrian Museum for Applied Arts in Vienna (Österreichisches Museum fuer angewandte Kunst). 

 

 Solar Tree, prototype, November 2007, designed by Ross Lovegrove and produced and developed by Artemide polycrystalline solar cells by Sharp. On display at the Piazza della Scala, Milan, Italy.  (Photo by David Zanardi)

Ross Lovegrove and Sharp are now working on the design study for a car that is powered by solar energy.

Sharp solar had a production volume of 434 megawatts in 2006 and a world market share of 17 percent. It produces PV cells in a factory in Katsuragi, Japan.

Most of Sharp's modules are used for solar energy systems on roofs, but the company believes that solar cells could soon be used in all areas of everyday life from clothes to satellites - including Christmas trees.

Jane Burgermeiser is a writer based in Austria.

Image Gallery (1)
 
Reader Comments (44)
 
No image available
December 21, 2007
The great thing about this idea is that I'm sure the light levels will be lower than presently. Most cities have so much light pollution that seeing the stars or the moon is almost impossible. Streetlights tend to separate us from nature. Many people have never seen the milky way!
Comment 1 of 44
No image available
December 21, 2007
Germany has a feed-in tariff correct? Does the U.S. have a similar program. Ok, I understand net metering, isn't that the same thing as feed-in tariff? Or is a feed-in tariff a "federal program"? In which case, the US certainly doesn't have.
Comment 2 of 44
No image available
December 21, 2007
This is an idea whose time came, I would think, years ago, but it's still compelling. The article mentions the streets of Europe; why not the whole world? This article and others like it would be more useful if the basic economics (capital required, break-even, payback, etc.)were explained. Also, on the business end of things, who are the players downstream? Sharp? Others?
Comment 3 of 44
No image available
December 22, 2007
Jane,

How much do the solar trees cost and how much light do they produce?

Thanks

Ian
Comment 4 of 44
No image available
December 23, 2007
The use of artistic talent with solar can only help acceptability. There can be truly futuristic art, when we use our imagination. There are many clever ways to have multiple use of the solar structures and create electric at the same time. As to U.S. tax credits, its clear the 13 Billion oil welfare program we have is working well for them. They use our money to fight their battles to stop renewables, and anything else that will defuse profits. look how the oil lobbyists and their paid political pupits killed the tax credit extentsion stopped the intended 1% tax increase for the oil magots. While their profits soar to astronomical heights. I'm sure its a joyous x-mas for them with todays carpet baggers, snake oil peddlers, yes, our illustrious leaders who could have done the right thing, but enjoy to many benefits from their oil butt hole benefactors, earmmarks and pork, they so wisely deserve, while we foot the bill. We won't forget and we won't forgive.
Comment 5 of 44
No image available
December 23, 2007
An outstanding example of a successful FEEDIN TARIFF is that of Spain -- the generator of solar or wind energy gets paid 5x the base rate of fossil-generated electricity,for up to 25 years, after which the rate drops by 20% for the life of the system. At present this is around 43 euro cents/kwhr., if I recall correctly. With a system size cap at 2MW, this encourages rather large, utility-scale systems. The result has been a fulminating boom in solar energy installation in Spain.

The US does not need tax credits for renewables -- but a FEEDIN TARIFF which could be easily supported with some of the $13Billion welfare we throw to the oil companies, and we would realize the kind of distributed infrastructure that is developping now on the Iberian Peninsula.
Comment 6 of 44
No image available
December 23, 2007
J.D. -- Net metering and feedin tariff are not the same.

Net metering simply means returning your unused home-generated electricity to the grid for CREDIT equal to either a)the retail cost of electricity, or b) the avoided cost of electricity, in your area. 39 US states make net metering mandatory.

A FEEDIN TARIFF (much better!)involves GETTING PAID A PREMIUM for the home-generated electricity returned to the grid. Spain, Germany, Japan, Korea, Italy, France, Portugal have feedin tariffs -- and very generous ones.
Comment 7 of 44
No image available
December 26, 2007
Trees

Trees that shine while we decline and pour our funds to oil,
Not to address but to suppress all those who work and toil,
Our leaders fall at money call of corporate interest lure,
With bated breath arrange the death and vote clean power poor.

adrianakau2aol.com
Comment 8 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
PS To all those who posted a message here or gave an opinion of how it should work; GET REAL!! Solar power is here to stay, read and learn about it, stop asking stupid questions and remember the engineers who design things like this solar tree have put alot of effort into the product, they sell and design. Batteries and a charge controller as well as sizing all worked out long before the device went into production. and the guy who commented on a motion detector!! geezzz.(read and learn about SOLAR power and how it works) do the world a favor.
Comment 9 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
Where do I sign?...I want them here in the USA I can sell a million units in my state alone; SOME ONE CONTACT ME!! tvesely@neaenergy.com I love Sharp products I have their solar panels on my home, and I have local towns looking for a way to lower property taxes...CALL ME! tvesely@neaenergy.com
Comment 10 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
I think this solar tree is beautiful, as an art form. As noted above costs would be nice to hear about? I would like to know where I could buy one tomorrow for my garden.
Comment 11 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
This article sounds electrifying even for the City of Seattle with its cloudy days.
But can the cloud cover of 30 or 60 or 90 days be overcome. If yes, then this could be something which the City Council should look at.
If an artistic piece of equipment can save 10% of our electricity consumption then this could be the alusive alterntive energy source which is needed.
Comment 12 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
Interesting idea that would cut our need for baseload power substantially if widely deployed. I'm not crazy about this particular design (imitating organic forms is not necessarily the most beautiful artificial design) but other designs are possible. To those who question why lighting at night is useful: in urban and suburban areas these lights are key for night-time safety...they might be fitted with motion sensors to turn them on and off though this might defeat the purpose in some areas.
Comment 13 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
how much area it will illuminate ? Will it be sufficient for street lights around 3 meters or 6 meters height ? What about the replacement of rechargeble batteries ? What will be the price
Comment 14 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
It is becoming more apparent all the time that integrating renewable energy into our economic and social structures will happen from the bottom up.

The current development of the various forms of renewable energy and how they are to be deployed reminds me of the old expression, "all things great and small"

Little PV systems for homes, bigger ones for commercial buildings and very large systems for industrial applications.

In a similar vein, wind power can be deployed in varying sizes to suit a particular application.

On an aggragate basis these systems can add up to a significant amout of total power produced in a clean and environmentally sound basis.

As the renewable industry grows and revenues increase more "market place" impact will occur. It appears that the necessary momentum is there to fuel the R&D work and find more cost efficient manufacturing methods.

John Dolan
Comment 15 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
i hate to be a sh------ disturbur but ins't that a nice place for pigeons to make nest on those nice flat surfaces..i think it's a supper idea and also i agree with the person that said we could use the roof-tops of bldgs with a incentive for renting...my wish for 2008 is someone that invents a cheap enough solar system that the average JOE does not need $30,000 to get started.
Comment 16 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
It certaintly is about time thatt Solar becomes more
available for all inclusive use. There is more energy for sumlight than world need are. To bad our oil controled "Genius's" in Washington took aaway the solar
credit/rebates of the '70's. I guess they had to give themto the oil companies!! All this newer research is very encoraging to say thr least.
Comment 17 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
Thomas is right. Why do we need to have our cities lit up like a Christmas tree?

These things are ugly. Calling them trees doesn't improve it one bit.

They only continue the wasteful ideas we have. What do they cost? Not just the final delivered cost but resourses used to make them and the waste left over.
Comment 18 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
I think,it's a terrific idea but the price will make the difference for local usage.There is no reference for prices.
Comment 19 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
it was meant to be:
...it is not AS EASY as it should be.
Comment 20 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
It's a never ending exercise for us North of the USA to remind that Canada is much closer than Spain , Germany etc.
Canada has also good Feed-in tarriffs.
Example: Ontario pays 42 cents for site generated electricity while we pay 5.8 cents (all costs considered it really is approx.10 cents) buying it from utilitiy (Ontario Hydro). All provinces are ready to go although, as everywhere, it is not as it should be.
Comment 21 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
Couldn't this money be better spent on conservation measures...Ohhh you can see conservation.
Comment 22 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
I want to reiterate Jane's question posted on 12/22/07 - How much do these fixtures cost? Better yet - who would I best contact to help determine a general cost range - for rough planning purposes?
Comment 23 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
Solar Trees can certainly brighten the lives of all those living in the remote villages and rural areas.Especially it will be a blessing for the poor farmers to have a few solor trees around their cultivations to keep away wild elephants and other animals which destroys their crop after night fall, besides, those living in Tea and other plantations also can be benefitted. Can any manufacturer pls submit a price list to this mail. I am based in Sri Lanka.
Comment 24 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
It is really very good event it has to be developed in the Rural areas where there is no poer in India or shotsage of power ,it is really a great cost saving event Iam interested to do the same venture in India provided if any company come forward on my mail
vdprao@vsnl.net
Comment 25 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
I guess being from the country I miss the point of street lights all together. Whats is the reason for all of those street lights anyway?
If I need a light on outside to complete a task I turn it on, if I dont, I turn it off.
I am going to ask another seemingly dumb question now.
Do these "solar tree lights" have an off switch?
While I am at it here is another.
Do the existing street lights have off swithes and if so why dont these city folks just turn them off when they are not using them? Wouldnt that save power too?
Comment 26 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
It is a good idea to popularize the daily round solar energy usage in our life. But what is a good of it for elecric power producers and sellers? This is large barrier for renewable energy systems spread.
Comment 27 of 44
No image available
December 28, 2007
why only street lights , what's wrong with using all roofs of public buildings to light the cities . Bus&tram stops,stations ,schools,stores etc to go solar.Then there would be no need to wreck the country side with wind turbines that kill the birds of prey.Messing up natures fine balance for the well being of all our eco systems .If towns want electricity then let them make as much as they can for themselves.Waste heat from buildings can also be used to run generating systems.Small local systems with modern technology are a good answer to many of todays problems .
Comment 28 of 44
No image available
December 29, 2007
Bill, relative to keeping solar cells clean, you are right, they do not work well when dirty, but most solar cells are not flat mounted, they are on a slope (ours are 38 deg to horizontal in Spain) and wash off really well when it rains. Wintertime they thus need no attention. Summertime, when sometimes we have no rain for 3 months at a stretch, you need a mop and bucket.
Surely not beyond the "wit of man" - when I was a boy the lamplighter came round on his bicycle to light each gas light each winter evening before dusk - I never saw what time he returned to switch off the gas lights because I was in bed, but they had been switched off by morning!
But then I talk about a time (late 1940's) in the UK when the coal was delivered in a horse drawn cart and my job as a younster was to get the horse manure up in a shovel and onto the vegetable patch before the neighbours.
Comment 29 of 44
December 29, 2007
Who is going to keep the solar cells clean? Going to need a bucket truck to get up high enough to clean the "leaves" of bird nests and dust. When calculating cost to benefit, be sure and count all of the costs! Self cleaning coatings are just beginning to come to market, and will help with dust, but will do nothing to ward off the pigeons! Best to design in some spikes to discourage the birds.
Comment 30 of 44
No image available
December 29, 2007
What Robert mentioned about only needing moonlight level lighting reminded me of a study I read about a couple years back about how city lighting levels were overkill, that the safety benefits of the lighting (as far as being able to see where you're going, as well as crime reduction) were maintained even if the light was reduced to a full moon light level. Surely a re-evaluation of how much light is necessary should go hand in hand with any citiwide solar project.
Comment 31 of 44
No image available
December 29, 2007
I´ve been thinking further about this solar tree idea (or more simpply and cheaply some sort of pole mounted overhead solar garden or path lighting - but something that works as opposed to the ground level ones sold in discount stores for 10 to 20 Euros - which do not show the way to the front door unless one buys a hundred!).
Does anyone know what the light intensity is at full moon - that´s all I need.
And I have no problem there are a couple of days of cloud, I can dig out a torch once a month!
And I do not need light outside, say after midnight.
So under those conditions - as opposed as to flat out "high intensity" street lighting - what might the price be?
General question - where you live are the street lights on all night and must they be on all night?
Comment 32 of 44
No image available
December 29, 2007
Another usage for this could be with farming.
The heat of the day is really not a good time to harvest but the cost of lighting an entire area would be costly. Another way to do this is have transportable solar trees so harvesting can be done in the evening. Also, can the solar panels heat up an area. In the apple industry in Washington State the temperature can get below freezing and ruin the buds and this destroys the future crop. No flowers no apples. So this could possible act as a double product one as heat and the other as light.
Comment 33 of 44
No image available
December 30, 2007
Please tell us when we can expect to install solar tree in India. We will be interested to adopt for our projects, can you tell us whom to contact.
Comment 34 of 44
No image available
December 31, 2007
Btw, Happy New Year's
Comment 35 of 44
No image available
December 31, 2007

I am now starting to make solar lights from scratch, it's so fun knowing just about anybody can do it since we have the web to learn from.

Take a few rechargeable AA's, some 140,000 mcd led's, and some 2 - 3/8th inch (~58 mm) glass embedded CIGS panels, a switch,  and some simple electronics theory from the web. It seems that the transister "auto turn on" has leakage though, since the switch version lasts longer.

Now, I know that the city lights will have to have much higher current and thus (i think) a relay instead of transistors, thus more innefficiency.

If i can (almost) do it Why can't our town's leaders??? Hmmm, think I'll hit 'em up (after I learn more)!


Comment 36 of 44
No image available
December 31, 2007
We need more California Arnolds S's; he is self made and doesn't need to worry about money therefore he makes decisions based on scientific fact and world need. He could care less about making another 1-2 million dollars from the oil companies.

The Democrats better come through after the next elections in this country; or all hell is gonna break loose!
All the Best,
Comment 37 of 44
No image available
December 31, 2007
Someone up near the top wrote:
_______________________________________________________
"The US does not need tax credits for renewables -- but a FEEDIN TARIFF which could be easily supported with some of the $13Billion welfare we throw to the oil companies, and we would realize the kind of distributed infrastructure that is developping now on the Iberian Peninsula"."

This is obviously true,....but again, this is the United States. Our givernment lingers and lingers and.....

When fuel costs hit $4-5 a gallon (and they will),our government will not linger; our money will become more deflated, Canadians will be buying all of our stuff due to easy and smart border crossing (I would too) and we'll then manifest large American Mandated changes that had started with individual State programs with wind and solar.
Comment 38 of 44
No image available
December 31, 2007
Is this available in the U.S.? Are there any venodr's in the U.S. that presently distributes this or similar products? What is average cost per tree?
Comment 39 of 44
No image available
January 2, 2008

 

Ian and Gerald,

Christina Werner said it's not possible to put a cost to the solar tree because it is a prototype but there are plans to produce the tree on a large scale.

I suggest you contact Christina Werner yourself, Gerald, to get a rough estimate of the costs. She will be able to put you in contact with the right people, I hope.

Comment 40 of 44
No image available
January 2, 2008
I had this idea 25 years ago when I was studying Architecture.  I'm very happy to see that someone made it happen. 
Comment 41 of 44
No image available
January 5, 2008
Could someone explain how this works.  Are you saying that the oil industry in the US of A is being subsidised by the government to the tune of 13 billion per year.  Importing and selling oil products is a license to print money.  Why do they need a subsidy.
Comment 42 of 44
No image available
January 6, 2008
ps.  If pigeon poop is a particularily persistant problem, divert a small amount of the current into what is essentially an electric fence pulsator.  Electrify the panel with this.  High Volts, tiny Amps, very low energy consumption, no harm to the pigeon but after one zap he will never return.
Comment 43 of 44
No image available
January 17, 2008

Folks,

The solar tree has less to do with its practicality and much more to do with pushing the design envelope. Look around and learn more about Ross Lovegrove the designer of the tree. This is simply one of his many creations.

It's a unique design, probably unavailable to the public.

http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/27
Comment 44 of 44
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In
Featured Total Access Partners
Click company logos to learn more
Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Intertek Poet HESLIN ROTHENBERG FARLEY & MESITI P.C. Standard Solar Inc. Pace Energy and Climate Center
WORLD'S #1 RENEWABLE ENERGY NETWORK
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network Logo