Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

What's the Difference Between Solar Energy and Solar Power?

By Scott Sklar
October 23, 2007   |   20 Comments

Do you like this opinion & commentary?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 

The information and views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of RenewableEnergyWorld.com or the companies that advertise on its Web site and other publications.

20 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 20
October 23, 2007
This is for all the scientists in renewable energy, expecially the ocean renewable energy program. Underwater turbin windows to harness the kinetic energies of the earths' ocean currents. Thus creating enough electricity to supply the world demand. The underwater grids could be routed to all countries in need of electricity. This alternative energy source would be endless and constantly renewable.
Comment
2 of 20
October 23, 2007
It's a good thing, inclusive of all renewable technologies, not only proven, working Customer Cited Photovoltaics (CSPV), Concentrating Solar Power (CSP), ... => kW => kWh, but also power and energy in various contexts specifically efficiency, savings ... like a gift from above and if "photovoltaics", suggest as a resource, http://www.imaginit.cc/faqsolar.htm
Comment
3 of 20
October 24, 2007
Power is the time rate of change of energy. It can be looked as the "velocity" of energy being consumed or produced. Interestingly, the units beg the notion of the integral. The area under the power curve is the energy..
Comment
4 of 20
October 24, 2007
Jeff has it right. Energy is the ability to do work. Power is the rate at which work is performed. The common formula for this is P=W/T Work is measured in Joules.

1 watt = 1 joule per second. A watt is NOT an instantaneous measurement; it consumes a second. Therefore, a watt is a unit of Power. So is a watt-hour. Both measure the rate at which work is done over time.

Energy has multiple forms, such as Kinetic (energy in motion like the blowing wind) and Potential (energy ready to be in motion, like water behind a dam). Solar Energy strikes a PV panel to produce potential electrical energy (volts), but produces no Power until it is connected to a load (Work).

We're splitting hairs here. It's usually not important to explain the difference. But accuracy counts. The notion of a Watt being Power and a Watt-Hour being Energy is simply wrong, even if you're an engineer.

Don't buy it? Take a moment to Google "power vs. energy" and start clicking links.
Comment
5 of 20
October 24, 2007
Hello Catherine
My questions to you are: Who will build, operate and control Tidal power stations?
Who currently owns patents on ALL PV technology?
Who builds and owns all large solar wind farms?
Answer..The same people that own Oil/Natural Gas/Coal
We are spending $330,000,000 A DAY in Iraq. Imagine what 30 days of Iraq spending would look like if it launched dozens of Thermal Solar Power stations in this country. For every two we build, we could designate one for Hydrogen production through electrolysis.
Oh yea I forgot...that spells the end for Big Energy huh? It's shameful...
S H A M E F U L that thermal technologies that were working in THE MID 80's are NOT on the evening news EVERY NIGHT! Front Page of your Newspaper... Talked about By Limbaugh, Hannity, Beck etc...oh yea I forgot all that media is owned by the big boyz too. : (
Comment
6 of 20
October 24, 2007
am going to buil a log cabin in north carolina mountains and would like to use some sort of solar power(?) but still donit quite understand missed the solar project in wash. d. c. this week but still am interested and help would beappreciatated.
Comment
7 of 20
October 24, 2007
It's nice to see someone separate solar energy from solar power. Solar electricity is fine where the power must be shipped a long way, but solar energy is much more efficient where it can be used directly. Making steam to turn rankine engines is about 30% efficient, to which must be added distribution losses. Making on-site solar energy to use for heating, cooling, or desalination is more than twice as efficient. Cooling is 30% of the peak power load in California, and can be supplied by several solar technologies that do not involve electricity generation.
Comment
8 of 20
October 24, 2007
Solar power and energy are used almost synonymously by the press and general public. But to an engineer they are distinctly different. Power is the capability to do work, and energy is the quantity of work done. For example, the quantity of energy created by a generator with a power rating of 10 KW is the connected load (which can range from 0 to 10KW) multiplied times the time the generator runs in hours to give kw-hours. Power is measured in kw and energy is measured in kw-hrs. A PV array is solar powered (the array has a kw rating) but collects solar energy measured by a meter that multiplies powerXtime and accumulates kw-hrs. If you are still confused, don't worry, you have lots of company.
Comment
9 of 20
October 24, 2007
Did anyone else catch NOVA's episode last night? Mainly socio-political discussion, it *was* titled "Is it Time to take Solar Energy seriously" and it would have been nice to see a little more discussion of non-photovoltaics technology as well.
Comment
10 of 20
October 25, 2007
Ok Guys,
Your all smart and educated, that's great. Do any of you use any type of "solar powered" contraptions I wonder? We need you guys to do "home shows" for people who have no clue about PV, solar hot water, etc.

Upstate NY (Albany area)has a home show that allows the interested lot to come and see such arrangements by doing "walk and see" tours.

Good luck to all.
Comment
11 of 20
October 25, 2007
Thanks for the answer Scott. I've contacted NREL, EIA, ASES, Perlin etc while exploring this seemingly simple question. The answers vary but the weight of responses came down along the lines you describe. I completely agree with you.

The terminology problem is reflected in many of the comments above which seek to define solar energy and solar power through the relationship Power = Energy/Time. The qualitative difference between the technologies rather than the relationship between energy and power is a better grounds of distinction.

I'd say geothermal and tidal belong under the solar heading too. If it weren't for the sun the oceans would be frozen so there wouldn't be any tides. The same thing goes for the geothermal gradient which would be much different without the solar input.
Comment
12 of 20
October 25, 2007
I stand corrected. Thanks for the help, Tom.
Comment
13 of 20
October 25, 2007
Tom, glad you finally got everyone straightend out on power vs energy. Too bad Scott didn't get it right in the first place. He really does know better.
It is worth while to point out once again that 'solar power' or 'solar panels' are NOT synonymous with photovoltaic power or panels, although frequently used that way. Solar panels can produce either electricity (PV panels) or heat or hot water (thermal collectors. Solar power can be produced by PV panels or by CSTP systems (concentrating solar thermal power systems such as those operating in the Calif. deasert to produce up to 345 MW of solar electric power). Of course, wind, hydro, OTEC, etc. are also producers of solar power (and of solar energy, of course). Hence, anyone thnking of PV should NOT use the term solar power or solar panels. Just say PV power and be clear about it.
Comment
14 of 20
October 25, 2007
Correction: Energy=Work = the integral of P X dT.
Comment
15 of 20
October 25, 2007
I wanted to avoid higher math but you are right Mr. Breza. Energy=Work = the integral of dP X dT. In a PV array the power=watts=(volts X amps) none of which are constant due to cloud passage, shading, and sun angle. The integration of instantaneous power (watts) X delta time (hours) is done in the kw-hour meter to give the amount of energy produced. Mr. New has the right equation Power=Work/Time or transposed Work=Power X Time, but then he mixes units. Enough said.
Comment
16 of 20
October 31, 2007
There is the vast different between Solar energy and solar power.Solar power is the sum amout of power of sun and it is measure in jules on the other hand solar energy defined as the energy of sun can be converted into any applications.
Comment
17 of 20
November 2, 2007
We've lived with inefficient machines for so long, the issue of continuing their use is no big deal. Photo voltaic processes are extremely poor, less than 15%. Solar thermodynamics however are much better. (Around 80%?) But if you are selling solar panels to generate electricity, you do not point out this weakness.
Comment
18 of 20
April 12, 2008
I am a student and I am still confused about the terms used, could someone kindly describe what the following terms mean without equations/formulas or scientific gibberish, just a simple definition would do? I tried to google these terms and some of the websites mix them up!


Tandem PV = ?
Tandem Cell = ?
Photo-voltaic = ?
Photo-thermal = ?
Solar energy = ?
Solar power = ?
Solar cells = ?
Hydrogen solar cell = ?
Hydrogen Power = ?
Solar hydrogen power = ?
Solar hydrogen tandem Cell = ?
Dye sensitised solar cell = ?
Photo-chemical cell = ?
Photo-electrochemical cell = ?
Electrochemical cell = ?


Many thanks in advance.
Comment
19 of 20
April 12, 2010
Do not confuse about the solar power and solar energy. See http://www.sunpowerport.com
Comment
20 of 20
February 27, 2011
This article still ranks high in Google when searching "power vs. energy," which is great. Unlike previous comments, I don't find discussing the different technologies helpful to clarify the terms "energy" and "power" as they relate to solar technology.
I've seen more clear explanations from Dr. Sklar, and my favorite as it applies to solar is from Dr. Sean White: http://www.pvstudent.com/Power-v--Energy.html

When you google "difference between power and energy" you get 50% sites stating Power is time related, and the other half stating Energy is time related.

I'm sticking with Sean's memory trick: PoWer = Watt (think W's.)
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Scott Sklar

View Scott Sklar's Profile
About: Scott, founder and president of The Stella Group, Ltd., in Washington, DC, is the Chair of the Steering Committee of the Sustainable Energy Coalition and serves... more »

Advertise With Us

SunMaxx Solar Mersen (formerly Ferraz Shawmut) groSolar Free Hot Water Planet Solar Inc Delta Rigging & Tools Hydrogen Education Foundation
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters