Photo Credit: U.S. DOE EERE
article tools
Increase Text Size Increase Text Size Decreate Text Size Decrease Text Size
Share Email This Story Share Share This Story Reader comments Reader Comments (8) View image gallery Image Gallery (1) Add to favorites Add to Bookmarks Printer friendly version Printer Friendly Version
Article Tool Sponsor:

Advertise with us

More Jobs
0 ratings - Sign-in to rate this article
March 27, 2007

Chinese Biofuels Expansion Threatens Ecological Balance

by Yingling Liu, Worldwatch Institute

The recent agreement between China's top forestry authority and one of the nation's biggest energy giants to develop biofuels plantations in the southwest reflects rising Chinese attention to non-fossil energy sources. But the excitement may come at great environmental loss to the region's forests and biological diversity, suggesting significant trade offs associated with the renewable fuels.

The biofuels plantations will allegedly be built on marginal lands, including degraded forestlands and croplands, of which Yunnan province alone has more than 4 million, according to a local official. Yet it is not rare in China for local governments to sell off lush hills to logging companies as "waste forestlands."

According to the agreement, signed by China's State Forestry Administration (SFA) and the oil company PetroChina in January, the parties will join efforts in developing two Jatropha curcas plantation bases in Yunnan and Sichuan provinces, with biofuel production capacities of 10,000-30,000 tons each and a combined area of more than 40,000 hectares, according to China Green Times.

Jatropha, a hardy oilseed bush with seeds containing over 30 percent oil, is regarded as an ideal raw material for biodiesel production.

The Chinese government has since embraced additional biofuels expansion. On February 7, an SFA spokesman told the press that the country was ready to devote more than 13 million hectares of forestlands to biofuels production, Xinhua News Agency reported. And several local governments have embarked on or are planning ambitious long-term oilseed plantation projects.

According to blueprints from the Yunnan Provincial Forestry Department, the province will construct 1.27 million hectares of biofuels plantations and aims to become China's biggest biofuels base by 2015, achieving an annual production capacity of 4 million tons of ethanol and 600,000 tons of biodiesel. Forty counties in the province have begun to develop biofuels plantations.

Ever-rising demand to fuel the country's motor vehicle fleet is driving these developments. A recent study by the National Bureau of Statistics reports that private vehicle ownership in China reached 29.25 million by the end of 2006, a 23.7 percent increase over 2005.

While it took nearly two decades for Chinese car ownership to exceed 10 million (in 2003), an additional 10 million cars were added in only three years. China currently shows a ratio of 60 people per motor vehicle, compared with a world average of 11.5, indicating huge growth potential for the Chinese market.

Development of the new biofuels plantations will be funded by PetroChina and carried out by forestry authorities at various levels. Both parties have stated that the efforts will be undertaken in the interest of national sustainability, though there is strong suspicion that these actors are placing greater priority on fast and lucrative returns.

An all-out development in ecologically sensitive southwestern China will almost certainly wreak havoc on the environment. The region is home to the country's largest remaining intact natural forests, which are vital for maintaining the local and regional climatic balance.

These areas have already shrunk rapidly due to rampant logging in recent years, while the new biofuels craze will likely pull the last string of ecological collapse in the region.

The biofuels plantations will allegedly be built on marginal lands, including degraded forestlands and croplands, of which Yunnan province alone has more than 4 million, according to a local official. Yet it is not rare in China for local governments to sell off lush hills to logging companies as "waste forestlands." With the new incentives created by biofuels, such "black-box" deeds will likely continue and possibly worsen.

Equally daunting is the looming damage to the region's biodiversity from massive monoculture plantations of biofuels crops. Blessed with a favorable geographic location and unique landscapes, natural forests in southwestern China have long been a paradise for flora and fauna, home to more than 6,000 plant species and over 1,000 animal species.

Nibbled away by plantations of jatropha and other biofuels plantations, the future of those species appears startling bleak.

Yingling Liu is the China Program Manger at the Worldwatch Institute. This article was reprinted with permission from the Worldwatch Institute.
Image Gallery (1)
 
For Further Information
Please Note: RenewableEnergyWorld.com does not endorse the sites behind these links. We offer them for your additional research. Following these links will open a new browser window.
Reader Comments (8)
 
March 27, 2007
The problem is always the same. The capitalist models end is profit, not the environment. The environment will only win when the two happen to coincide. It is ironic though that the whole "public buzz" environmental movement, now and before, ends up failing because of capitalism, on any continent. To focus on any one solution, like bio fuels as a end all is foolish for so many reasons. Particularly in bio fuels case where you are still burning for energy. As long as money plays a part in solutions, success will be hit and miss at best. The rich will be insulated the poor dead, and that has not changed for thousands of years, no matter who's political system you are under.
Comment 1 of 8
No image available
March 27, 2007
Thanks Jim Berry for that Marxist explanation of the economics of biofuels.
Comment 2 of 8
No image available
March 27, 2007
When biofuels are economical, they directly compete with farm land and forest and park lands for resources which are primarily land and water.

WIth large scale adaptation of biofuels, rich people, inlcuding Al Gore, will have clean burning SUVs and limos, while the world's poor will starve and drink dirty water.

The trend is already visible in Mexico (corn) and Brazil (sugar cane). If the poor people can not afford to pay agriculture products that exceed the price of the biofuel plants, then the acreage of biofuel plants increases at the expense of acreage for consumer crops.
Comment 3 of 8
No image available
March 28, 2007
I don't understand what all this passimism is about how rising corn prices
For the first time in 100 years it seems possible that oil will not have a 100% monopoly on powering cars in America.
This is a threat to Exxon/Mobile, Chevron, Texaco, etc. In the same way that the oil companies pay millions to "experts" to confuse the public about Global Warming, they are spending millions to slow-down bio-fuels.
Comment 4 of 8
No image available
March 28, 2007
Regarding the first comment about how rising corn cost is a problem in Mexico I have something to add to that. I am a student at the University of Tennesse but I come from Belize a small country just south of Mexico and as a matter of fact Belizean Farmers are as happy for rising corn prices as are American Farmers. So I don't understand what all this passimism is about how rising corn prices will negatively effect Mexico and Central America. My brothers are whoppin and hollerin down there and are greasing there field equipment in preperation for planting corn once again.
Comment 5 of 8
No image available
March 28, 2007
Provided the new biomass fuels are produced in a carbon neutral way, like trees and perennial plants that use minimal fertiliser and other chemicals, these crops help save the planet by substituting for coal and oil. For instance Miscanthus has an energy balance of 32:1 and carbon balance 53:1. This means the crop only needs one part of manmade carbon product per 53 produced by photosynthesis. Ditto 32 for fossil fuel energy. Some other crops are much les favourable or even negative in environmental benefit. Jon Harvey
Comment 6 of 8
No image available
March 28, 2007
The world simply does not have enough space for the use of biomass as a renewable energy alternative. The ecological footprint globally is many times the space available per person, therefore, the increased use of biomass is already doomed to failure. Forget biomass. Ocean Wave energy for future electricity generation is the way forward. With free electricity from the ocean we can then use that electricity freely in order to make hydrogen to power our vehicles because the amount of energy required to make hydrogen will no longer be more than the CO2 emissions levels which emanate from fossil fuel electricity production. So, we have the electricity sorted, and the transport fuel sorted. Home heating? Well sure, with all the global warming we won't need it. And we'll have the 'free' clean, green ocean wave energy generated electricity to power the air conditioners. Not that we'll have any life left to live if things carry on ......................
Comment 7 of 8
No image available
March 31, 2007
The Bio Fuel Path

Bio fuel crops we're not liking,
Taking food from desperate poor,
Cause food prices to be spiking,
Turn away those at our door.

Using land and water sources,
Needed for our market crop,
Cannot justify land losses,
Increased hunger we have brought.

Governments must make decisions,
Rules on how land's to be used,
Need to scrutinize revisions,
In preventing land abuse.

We should move away from fossils,
Powering our transport fleet,
Turn to 'electric driven motors,
From the sources at our feet.

Wind and concentrated solar,
Geothermal, ocean wave,
Natural clean and good to harvest,
Plus our land and water save.

Thank we God for us providing,
Ways to lead our life with care,
We should set our path deciding,
To keep far from bio snare.

adrianakau@aol.com
Comment 8 of 8
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In
Featured Total Access Partners
Click company logos to learn more
Photovoltaics World Trina Solar Ltd. National Hydropower Association Applied Materials altPOWER, Inc. bees - bioenergy events & services
WORLD'S #1 RENEWABLE ENERGY NETWORK
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network Logo