Renewable Energy Solar Energy Wind Energy Geothermal Energy Bioenergy Hydropower
 

The Economic, Social & Technological Case for Renewable Energy

February 21, 2007   |   15 Comments
Herman Scheer, the architect of the German feed law, presents his vision on a book tour throughout the U.S. and Canada through February 27.

Do you like this research & reports?

Email   Bookmark Bookmark   Print   Feed   Share
 
"In urging an acceleration of the transition to renewable energy, Scheer exposes the fallacies surrounding the current paradigm and looks beyond the purely environmental benefits to outline the path to energy security."

-- Lester Brown, Earth Policy Institute, president
15 Reader Comments
Comment
1 of 15
February 23, 2007
We are still at the problem of economic viability. Those that can afford to by their energy 30 years in advance are looking for a return ON their investment not only a Return OF their investment. To change the economics the design of the utility must be fully thought out from where one places the collectors, how ones transmits the energy to the consumer.

The solution ISN'T to decenteralize the power distribution or even live at a lower standard of living. To get SELL-ABLE spin-off benefits to subsidize the cost of the required infrastructure may require having a higher standard of living & even appear more wastefull.

Mandating 20% of the utilities sell-able energy comes from Renewable Sources means our cost of energy skyrockets to cover the cost of the infrastructure, or the suppliers of the Renewable Energy is subsidizing the cost by aborbing the capital costs.
Comment
2 of 15
February 23, 2007
Ahead of the US but only replaces "head in the sand" with "have your cake and eat it". Industrial civilization is fundamentally non-viable. All natural sustainable ecosystems recycle EVERYTHING. "Renewable Energy" is an illusion. At best it will delay our demise.
Comment
3 of 15
February 23, 2007
Few people recognize the immensity of the energy problem, and "renewables." If you define "renewables" as agriculturally grown fuels, it is simply unrealistic. Enough land doesn't exist. However, an alternative energy solution does exist - total electrification, with the power being generated by "renewable" solar, wind, geothermal, etc. There is about 20 times the amount of usable solar energy falling on us, than we presently use. If we were all-electric (heating, cooling, cooking, hot water, railroads, even commuter cars) the "energy crisis" would disappear, and we wouldn't run out of petroleum in 2050. Think how much carbon-based energy would be replaced. And when 40% efficient solar panels become real, most of it could be generated at home - but not now. The only other thing needed - mandate 35 MPG on the highway, by putting smaller engines in passenger cars.
Comment
4 of 15
February 23, 2007
Hi Christina Nelson. Well put!! and right on the money...

.....Bill
Comment
5 of 15
February 23, 2007
We are not one of the "Green Advertizing Execs"
We are the real "solar boys" ready to implement what others are just talking.

However, when we talk via our "Politically Correct Web Site" many others do not want to admit it.
Nor, they want to put down on the table one red penny to get off-the ground solar power plants.

Exept, one of the best in the World agencies, the California Public Utilities Commission. They care about solar boys and can overide others "discretionary decissions"
Comment
6 of 15
February 23, 2007
Without a counterpart like Mr. Scheer here in the US, we, the people must do it ourselves. Where is the "Renewable Energy" Cable channel? Where are the Green Advertising Execs that can make people feel that they need to embrace Renewables. If they can make people embarrassed to drive there kids to school in anything but a Hummer (Seen the ad?) then they can certainly do the same for Renewables. Where is the Solar thermal turbine?
Comment
7 of 15
February 23, 2007
-continue-Page 2 of 2

It appears that all that noise is just that. The big interest power (coal/fossil) generators are not just going to shut down their plants. They spent $billions.

On the other hand, we shall stop terming solar power as renewable, green, and whatever other, good to hear name. We have to termed the solar electric power cogeneration as "Mandated Energy", if is to comply with these Bills, codified into law.

Otherwise, we are just talking, and we are just getting deaf with both years, due to many "Christmas Bells ringing in our years".
Comment
8 of 15
February 23, 2007
Just a note form Nick Panchev, CEO Ecosystem Solar Electric, Corp.
www.esecorp.org

Plenty of exuberant talk, but hardly any real action.
So many Bills in Senate and so many initiatives, but that is again just talk, even codified into law.
The years of 2017, 2020, 2030 an on an on.

In the meantime there are, not in 2017-2030, but right now,solar electric power cogenerating companies, like we are, ready to implement what they and what we say will do.

However, conflicting, in major way are these Bills vs. environmental laws, which either prevent the development of solar power plants, or simply by paying exuberant fees to mitigate, results in such developments being economically unfeasible.

So, can we just stop the talk and walk the walk?
Indubitably, we have to collide due to hurdles and such hurdles have to be resolved by virtue of Lis Pendens. Unfortunately, we have to place in the front line of this battle our attorneys.
Comment
9 of 15
February 23, 2007
Great to hear we have humans that can actually think! Yes social reform in the major power centers of the world need to change. Al Gore seems to have been able to reach this center when others before him have not. From what I see there is an epeck battle taking place right now. Good(green energy) vs Bad (fossil, nuclear) Lets revisit the smaller community model. Ech community can be self sufficient in energy requirements by implementing any and all green energy that is available to them. While we're at it lets bury or find a way to get rid of the power lines! I may have a way to do the latter.

Ian Bowhey
Comment
10 of 15
February 24, 2007
I attended a book signing and Dr. Scheer spoke for ~30 minutes. It was very enlightening. I am expecting a link of the video from this speech to be sent to me. If you are interested email me at millermtu@hotmail.com and I will forward it on. I will try to post is here, but I am not sure how soon I will get the link.
Comment
11 of 15
February 24, 2007
On A Day Like Today

On a day like today, coal and oil lead the way but their fighting a losing cause,
When the sources decline and climate isn't fine then the carbons will be going away,
For the momentum will swing from carbon loaded fuels, and big boys will find the've got to change their rules,
As destructive to air, the fossils have to care by responding to future laws.

adrianakau@aol.com
Comment
12 of 15
February 26, 2007
Why do none of you attempt to think outside the box to change the economics of Renewable Energy? Yes it will take 2 international governments to allow sell-able spin-off benefits to be created. Their doing what is required would do the due diligence for the investors while publizing both the real need & the solution.

Many talk about Renewable Energy as if it can be done by a flip of a switch. To create the capacity to build the infrastructure required to replace the energy shortfall over night would be diliberately forgetting the listens learned from ENRON & Global Crossing. Granted the press NEVER bring up the reason they did the illegal finacial deals. They were hoping that with time the paying demand would catch up with the cost of the installed infrastructure cost.
Comment
13 of 15
February 27, 2007
"Industrial civilization is fundamentally non-viable. All natural sustainable ecosystems recycle EVERYTHING. "Renewable Energy" is an illusion. At best it will delay our demise.

This is beautiful, sigable. I'm going to steal it and use it in other forums OK? I'll list Brian Marsden as the author, I promise. I live off-grid and completely agree with this statement. Al Gore makes movies telling us all how we should behave and uses 100x more electricity than I do in one day. I simply cannot get behind this whole mandated carbon-tax, global warming, climate change thing, and I've tried, really! It just doesn't feel right to me. The reasons I went off-grid are none of the reasons promoted by the media today.

Something is wrong here, I can't put my finger on it, but I have this gut feeling that it is wrong.
Comment
14 of 15
February 28, 2007
Bob,off-grid, I applaud you.

What is wrong is that we are tip-toeing around what the utility and oil companies want, instead of what we really need, decentralized power generated at or near the point of use. The politicians are trying to make everyone happy. There is no point at which the oil/utility companies will get there investments back if we run out of oil, gas, coal, etc. If they admit this will happen in 40yrs then no one will invest in them and their stock will crash. So they cannot admit to the fact that it has been proved that renewables can replace 100% of our needs.

I am working my way off-grid as soon as I can.
Comment
15 of 15
March 5, 2007
We have been "talking " a lot about sustainability and renewables etc since last, say, at least 20 years ,if not more.
It is time that, like Germany, all industrialised and industialising countries set out their own programs for "renewablizing" and ACT accordingly.
The earlier the better.

<cgpandya@yahoo.com>
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In

Advertise With Us

DNV National Solar Trainers Poet Concepts NREC Hydrogen Education Foundation Nextronex, Inc. EnPower Systems Inc.
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network
PennWell
Renewable Energy World Magazine North America Renewable Energy World Magazine International Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Europe Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Asia Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo India Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo Africa
RenewableEnergyWorld.com Photovoltaics World Magazine Solar Power Gen Conference & Expo Hydro Review Magazine Hydro Review World Magazine
HydroVision International HydroVision Brazil HydroVision India HydroVision Russia
Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feeds e-Newsletters