New Look, Same Great Website.
Be on the lookout for our re-design for 2010 launching Friday, March 12!

Close
 
article tools
Increase Text Size Increase Text Size Decreate Text Size Decrease Text Size
Share Email This Story Share Share This Story Reader comments Reader Comments (17) View image gallery Image Gallery (1) Add to favorites Add to Bookmarks Printer friendly version Printer Friendly Version
Article Tool Sponsor:

Advertise with us

More Jobs
0 ratings - Sign-in to rate this article
July 9, 2006

Grid-Connected Cars and Renewables: Understanding the Potential

by Steven Letendre, Prometheus Institute

The prospect of having millions of vehicles plugging in to the nation's electric grid in the coming decade has never been better. The car-buying public has firmly demonstrated the commercial viability of hybrid electric vehicles (HEV), with HEVs reaching 1% of new car sales in 2005. Most vehicle manufacturers are betting on this trend accelerating in the coming years, and are rushing to bring hybrid vehicles to their dealer's showrooms. The evolution of HEVs to allow charging from the electric gird is assumed by many as desirable, and I would argue inevitable. The underlying economic and national security advantages of displacing gasoline with electricity are undeniable.

"As the vehicle fleet moves toward at least partial electric drive and grid charging, this creates the opportunity for renewables -- beyond biofuels -- to serve as a source of energy for the transport sector."

- Steven Letendre, The Prometheus Institute for Sustainable Development

While the renewable energy community is generally supportive of PHEVs, they have yet to fully appreciate the new opportunity that this would create for their industry. As the vehicle fleet moves toward at least partial electric drive and grid charging, this creates the opportunity for renewables -- beyond biofuels -- to serve as a source of energy for the transport sector.

Although solar photovoltaics (PV) is not viewed as cost-effective without significant subsidy when compared to grid power, it begins to look interesting when compared to the price of gasoline for transportation. Furthermore, the opportunity that solar hybrids offer is exciting, whereby a new generation of solar PV technology is developed specifically for vehicle integrated (VIPV) applications (see Solar Today, May/June 2006, Letendre, Perez, and Herig).

Growth in VIPV applications could one day mimic the current explosion in new product development for building integrated PV applications. While PV may serve just a small part of a vehicle's overall energy needs, the modest additional costs from a 500 watt VIPV system may be well worth the investment. VIPV should be considered as an avenue to enhance a PHEV's overall efficiency, similar to regenerative breaking.

It is generally understood that PHEVs would charge during the evening and early morning hours when electricity demand is low and there is significant excess capacity available on the network. In some areas, wind resources are strongest at night, thus allowing wind power to serve as an energy source for vehicles. With smart charging, the rate of charging could be adjusted to match the power production from a distant wind farm. I can envision interesting marketing schemes whereby PHEVs are sold in conjunction with a wind power supply contract further enhancing the vehicle's "green" attributes.

The potential of grid connected cars is even more exciting when the notion of vehicle to grid (V2G) is considered. The emerging V2G concept envisions grid connected cars with bi-directional chargers that both accept power from the grid and deliver power to serve different ancillary services markets. Initial economic analyses suggest that V2G capable vehicles could generate significant revenue for vehicle owners by providing specialty grid services such as regulation (frequency response) and spinning reserves. Ratepayers pay over $1 billion for these services each year.

The battery wear and tear from providing these services would be minimal given that regulation services would include both charging and discharging energy from the vehicle's battery pack in response to signals from a grid operator striving to maintain grid frequency at 60 Hz. Spinning reserves is another ancillary service needed to maintain grid reliability; these reserves are infrequently called upon, and when they are dispatched, are only used for a short duration and thus would have minimal impact on the vehicle battery pack.

While a small number of PHEVs have been built and are being tested, there are still hurdles to be overcome, the most important of which is the batteries. The U.S. Department of Energy recently convened experts from across the country to discuss the potential of PHEVs. While batteries were identified as a key technical challenge, the general consensus was that this barrier can be overcome. Additional research and development funding should be directed toward developing advanced batteries for PHEV applications. There is general agreement among electro chemical engineers about the potential that lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries offer in serving the hybrid vehicle market. In fact, several battery companies are currently developing Li-ion battery packs for vehicle applications.

A more distant potential that grid-connected cars may offer is their role in serving as storage to allow greater penetration of intermittent resources on to the nation's electric grid. I envision a future with millions of vehicles connected to the electric grid providing storage to allow large amounts of wind and solar to become seamlessly integrated in to the electric grid ushering in a truly sustainable energy future. In addition, PHEVs would require less liquid fuels making it more likely that biofuels could meet the challenge of displacing 100% of petroleum as a transport fuel.

While the renewable energy community must address a number of issues, I would urge renewable energy industry associations and advocacy organizations to join the growing chorus directed at the major automobile manufacturers to commit to bringing PHEVs to the market place. Grid-connected cars offer many fascinating opportunities to allow renewables to play a greater role in fueling society's transportation needs.

About the author...

Steven Letendre serves as the Director of Research at the Prometheus Institute for Sustainable Development, located in Cambridge, MA. Dr. Letendre has over ten years of research experience in the field of renewable energy. He has published widely on the topic of solar energy and advanced vehicle concepts. Dr. Letendre has served as a consultant on a range of projects for a variety of organizations including the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, California Air Resources Board, Union of Concerned Scientists, Northeast Sustainable Energy Association, and SUNY Albany's Atmospheric Sciences Research Center. Prior to joining the Prometheus Institute, Dr. Letendre was an Associate Professor of Business and Environmental Studies at Green Mountain College in Poultney, VT. In 1997, he received a Ph.D. from the University of Delaware in Urban Affairs and Public Policy with a concentration in energy policy and economics. In addition, he holds a masters degree in economics from Binghamton University, formerly State University of New York at Binghamton. Prior to pursuing his doctoral studies, Letendre was employed as an energy economist with the Research Triangle Institute in North Carolina.
Image Gallery (1)
 
For Further Information
Please Note: RenewableEnergyWorld.com does not endorse the sites behind these links. We offer them for your additional research. Following these links will open a new browser window.

The information and views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily those of RenewableEnergyWorld.com or the companies that advertise on its Web site and other publications.

Reader Comments (17)
 
No image available
July 10, 2006
Dr Manwell and his staff at UMASS have provided wind power systems data which states that wind velocities increase in the afternoon and subside at night. Where does the wind blow at night? Remember air conditioning loads can be highest from 4pm till 6pm due to storage of heat during the day and release in the late afternoon. Make sure alternatives will match this load. Can UMASS Boston, a commuter school get this
type of system installed has a pilot project?
The wind resources are good but the FAA has to allow the towers to be installed within the 3 mile zone of no tower installations. There also is plenty of room for a PV systems to be installed over the parking lots ( a Canopy ).
Comment 1 of 17
No image available
July 11, 2006
I am not sure if grid stability could or should rely upon PHEV batteries. People would not want any demands placed upon their personal property to serve a grid system when there must be other ways to steady grid load.

I think we need multiple renewable sources of all types entering the grid in gradient level. This would mean that the electricty would be in batches set for short time intervals so that fluctions over time could be accomodated by other input. I envision this type of control system to be computerized.

Secondly, there should be some storage but not necessarily from PHEV batteries. It might be from hydrogen generated during the day to fuel cells when needed or it could be even hydropower storage. In fact, since flowing water converts to higher energy than water from dams, flowing water hydropower could be reclassified as intermittant where the water sources are small.

adrianakau@aol.com
Comment 2 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
In Arizona, we average 5.8 hours of sunshine per day.
Our shade structures built on corporate parking lots serve
two purposes: provide shelter for workers' autos, generate
DC power and will fill the "electric tank" of a PHEV while
the worker is inside at the plant or office. Get those "plug
ins" on the road so they can be plugged into the grid or
our solar enabled shade structures. We are ready!

Solarscape Energy LLC.
by Jonas Weil, President
Comment 3 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
Ken; you might want to look at some of the projects already being done with wave energy. Just go to :

http://members.aol.com/mamoenergy/e_08.htm

adrianakau@aol.com
Comment 4 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
HoooraH,
Were on the track for electric cars, so why not supply the main grid with cheap and never ending supply of electricity from an old source in a new way that I am about to expose to the world? Don't laugh yet, because as soon as we can get the government to allocate some ocean area for recovering energy from water waves, I may have solved how to supply most of the electricity! Using twenty, 20 foot height waves, (perhaps 3 to 5 acres of water), I can produce from 120 to over 6oo MW. of electricity. (I class myself as an inventor, and am just doing my working model
and drawings. No I am not kidding on the power either. Any comments? Ken Weldon
Kenweldon@msn.com
Comment 5 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
A couple of questions about all this: not being an engineer, I can not make realistic suggestions. I can, though, point to some ideas and ask if they would be useful.

1. If plugging in after work would overload the grid (17-19:00), how about an intermediate power source such as another battery in the garage that would take in power from the grid at 01:00 during the off-peak hours and store it until the owner plugs the car in? Are batteries at least efficient enough to make that intermediate link feasible?

2. Is AC the most efficient way to run a grid? What if our power, generated from wind or solar, were to remain DC, avoiding the inverters, and the internal converters on most of our appliances (and batteries). I have read about a renewed look at DC taking place somewhere. Does anyone know about it?
Comment 6 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
Based upon breakthrough discoveries, Magnetic Power Modules(TM) are being designed that operate continuously, without fuel, extracting electricity by converting abundant, renewable, Virtual Photon Flux (VPF), an energy source that exists everywhere in the universe.

Prius plug-in hybrids typically need a 1 kW recharge connection. Magnetic Power Inc. is developing solid-state Magnetic Power Modules that can be combined to yield 1 kW or more. This would provide all the advantages without any need to plug-in to the utility grid, the first step toward driving automobiles, trucks and busses, without any need for gas or oil.

Based on current progress in our laboratories, patent-pending pre-production prototypes suitable for a car could be completed during 2007. This could become the first example of the use of this so far unknown, potential source of electricity in an automotive power system. Perhaps 20-50 miles of driving would be fuel-free, with no need to plug-in.
Comment 7 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
The problem with plug-in vehicles is the fact that people will want to recharge them when the distribution network is highly stressed - in the early evening upon returning home from work. New utility infrastructure such as transformers and larger conductors will be required to meet this new, peak-sharpening load. The cost will be huge and fully attributable only to this use. Who will pay?

"We can recharge them off-peak, in the middle of the night," some will say. You could, but residential load-shifting programs are, in general unsuccessful. Regulators loathe setting differentials high enough to make on-peak use painful. The utilities could control recharging in much the same way that some load control air conditioning. That compromises the usefulness of the vehicle and adds control infrastructure costs of its own.

Until the greater issues of integration with the existing utility infrastructure are dealt with, plug-in vehicles will never see much market penetration.
Comment 8 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
Music to my ears. I am developing a small cogen power plant and the prospect of selling electricty to cars and trucks is not an Orwellian dream, it will happen. I could see my Purchase Power Agreements extending to fleeets of taxies etc.. If batteri life is the hurdle then we know what has to be done. More R&D. Let's make it happen.
Comment 9 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
It all boils down to batteries and after trying for
30 years, we still don't have a low cost, high capacity, lightweight, easily rechargeable, long
lasting battery. Period. The statement that this
problem can be overcome will be believed when it is seen. I don't have ANY confidence that a magical battery solution iss just around the corner. They've been saying that for three decades now. They hornswoggled GM and the DOE into developing the EV1 back in the early 90's under the assumption that a practical battery was just around the corner. 15 years later we still haven't seen that corner, and I don't expect we will.
Comment 10 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
Over the past 50 years, most have adopted, for better or worse, a personal vehicle as a lifestyle necessity. We have traded technology for time and, I believe, we will continue to do so.

The PHEV must demonstrate that it has sufficient multiple recharge capacity so aftermarket value is sustained. A one or two thousand charge capacity may not do this unless the battery system is cost effective as a replaceable throw away after 7-8 years.

Right now, I would think that the PHEV has the potential to be a silver bullit, not withstanding the issue of the technological lifestyle it would sustain. A significant reduction in imported oil would not break my heart.
Comment 11 of 17
No image available
July 12, 2006
Plug-in hybrids come closest to a sustainable solution in the transportation sector. Distributing energy in the form of Hydrogen, even if it is only used for temporary electricity storage, cannot provide meaningful answers, because of the high parasitic energy consumption of a hydrogen economy. We cannot solve the energy supply problem by energy waste.

As most renewable energy is harvested as electricity, we need electricity storage at the end user like batteries in PHEVs. After all, these vehicles put up to 80% of the green power on the road, while hydrogen fuel cell vehicles have a "wind-to-wheel" efficiency of less than 25%. Compared to the efficient electricity distribution by wire, four times more renewable power plants are needed to feed a hydrogen economy. Three of these plants have to cover the losses of the hydrogen path. Who wants to invest in a hydrogen economy? More information can be found on www.efcf.com/reports.

ubossel@bluewin.ch
Comment 12 of 17
No image available
July 13, 2006
As GM said after their electric car disaster: we learnt that an infrastructure must first exist. Mainly what was needed was a practical battery. Until one comes along, talk of cars running off the grid is a pipe dream or a very limited benefit, considering the communting distances involved and the lack of an access to power supply for many commuters. There is also the problem of the massive increases in electrical output capacity that would be necessary. There are no off peak hours for most parts of the year, and batteries take a long time to recharge.
Comment 13 of 17
No image available
July 13, 2006
Mike,

You are right that a simple timer that prevents the vehicle from charging before a certain time will solve the peak power surge when residents return from work.

I am curious what a "reasonable" return on investment is for you?

In my biased opinion, several U.S. states provide PV subsidies that make the ROI very reasonable (Payback of 10 years or less). I am biased because I work for a solar company (REC Solar), but even with my work affiliation aside, PV makes sense financially and environmentally. That's why it's on my home...
Comment 14 of 17
No image available
July 13, 2006
Charging PHEVs off-peak on the grid can be done very simply with a timer-switch between the PHEV and the grid AC plug -- without even involving the utility -- unless you want be charged less per Kwh for off-peak energy. (A special timer could also be installed by the utility to limit charging to off-peak hours -- if the charging of PHEVs becomes a significant load during peak hours -- with a reduced cost per off-peak Kwh incentive.)

Most utilities see this as a win-win for their businesses and they have already investigated the grid's ability to charge electric vehicles.

I own/ drive a Prius and am considering "upgrading" it to a PHEV and adding solar power to my home to make the PHEV carbon neutral if the return on investment is "reasonable".
Comment 15 of 17
No image available
July 14, 2006
kerry: if you need to see it to believe it, then buy one of the DeWalt 36V power tools and take it apart. You will then have a battery of the necessary parameters sitting right in your very own hands.
Comment 16 of 17
No image available
July 18, 2006
Brian is correct. The A123 batteries that MIT developed in the DeWalt 36 volt rechargeable battery pack are amazing. For more specs see: http://www.a123systems.com/html/products/ANR26650M1specs.pdf

Since the PHEV's are intended to be recharged over night, a fast recharge time is not a limiting factor holding back PHEV's. If you run out of electric charge, the vehicle still runs like a regular gasoline/hybrid electric vehicle.
PHEV's are not a pipe dream. A pipe dream is thinking we are going to drill our way out of the peak oil pickle we are in.
Comment 17 of 17
Add Your Comment

Registered users, please make sure to Sign-In. We and others want to know your ideas and opinions. If you are not yet Registered -- it's quick and easy. Just click below.
Thanks!

Register Now   Sign-In
Featured Total Access Partners
Click company logos to learn more
martinHerzfeld Biomass Thermal Energy Council (BTEC) NESEA Morningstar Corporation The Stella Group, Ltd. UniRac, Inc.
WORLD'S #1 RENEWABLE ENERGY NETWORK
World's #1 Renewable Energy Network Logo