The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.

India May Impose Solar Tariffs After Probe Says US, China Dumped Panels

India May Impose Solar Tariffs After Probe Says US, China Dumped Panels

India may recommend duties on U.S. and Chinese solar imports after finding evidence of dumping, broadening a global trade dispute in the $130 billion market.

More than 20 overseas suppliers, including First Solar Inc. and Yingli Green Energy Holding Co., sold equipment in India for as little as half the cost as in their home markets and undercut local prices by as much as a third, according to a summary of a 1 1/2 year probe by the Ministry of Commerce & Industry sent to the parties involved yesterday and obtained by Bloomberg News.

The document indicates the ministry will recommend duties on imports from the U.S., China, Taiwan and Malaysia, said Jagdish Agarwal, spokesman for the Solar Independent Power Producers Association, which opposes tariffs.

If Asia’s third-biggest solar market imposes duties, it would escalate a protectionist trend that’s threatening the viability of projects as they compete against conventional power sources. The U.S. applied tariffs as high as 250 percent on Chinese products in 2012, and the European Union followed with its own measures a year later. Australia today announced a dumping probe.

India, which had virtually no solar power in 2010, has built $10 billion of projects and driven down the cost of generation by half, making it cheaper today than grid power in Delhi and Mumbai. Tariffs will derail that trajectory, making solar power more expensive and causing projects to fail, said Vinay Rustagi, joint managing director of Bridge to India Energy Pvt., a New Delhi-based consulting company.

‘Wafer-Thin Margins’

“It will make most large-scale projects, currently developed on wafer-thin margins, unviable,” Rustagi said. Developers, who depend on imports for 90 percent of panels, could back out of projects, government programs may be scrapped, and India could set itself back two years on its goal to makesolar competitive with conventional power, he said.

Yesterday’s document was the first indication of which side India’s government is favoring since the start of the probe in November 2012. The dispute pits local panel and cell makers against project developers and overseas manufacturers.

“We disagree that we have dumped imports,” Tempe, Arizona-based First Solar, the largest U.S. panel-maker, said in an e-mailed statement. “The preliminary decision by the Indian authorities, if upheld, would make serving the Indian market very difficult.”

The ministry has until May 22 to decide whether to impose duties before the case expires. Any tariffs it proposes could take six months to implement and may be scrapped by a new government, said Bridge to India’s Rustagi.

Results in national elections will be announced in two days. Narendra Modi, the frontrunner who pioneered India’s first incentives for large-scale solar power, has called for a clean- energy revolution during the campaign.

Inferior Quality

The document upheld many of the arguments submitted by domestic makers Indosolar Ltd., Websol Energy System Ltd. and Jupiter Solar Power Ltd., concluding that “the domestic industry suffered material injury due to dumped imports.”

The ministry dismissed arguments by the opposing side that Indian products are inferior in quality. Opponents including China Sunergy Co., Canadian Solar Inc., JA Solar Holdings Co. cited World Trade Organization rules, which say an anti-dumping probe can’t be initiated if the producers supporting the application account for less than 25 percent of national production. Indosolar, Websol and Jupiter account for just 12 percent of production, according to the opponents’ submissions.

Project Dropped

The value of photovoltaic imports into India has reached $2.4 billion since 2010 when the nation started its solar program, according to commerce ministry data. Domestic manufacturers benefited little from that growth, idling 70 percent of their production capacity after losing orders to foreign competitors.

Duties won’t create globally competitive Indian manufacturers because they can’t match the scale of Chinese rivals, according to Bridge to India. BlackRock Inc.-backed SunEdison Inc. dropped a project in India last month on doubts that local producers can meet demand.

The annual production capacity of China’s Yingli, the world’s biggest panelmaker, dwarfs the largest Indian maker by 10 times, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. If India imposes tariffs, developers would probably look to Singapore and South Korean suppliers instead, said Jenny Chase, head of solar analysis for Bloomberg New Energy Finance in Zurich.

Parties involved in India’s anti-dumping probe have until May 16 to respond to the document.

Yingli spokeswoman Qing Miao wasn’t available when called at her office and didn’t respond to an e-mail requesting comment. JA Solar Holdings Co. and Canadian Solar Inc., also among the biggest Chinese exporters to India, didn’t respond to inquiries.

Commerce Secretary Rajeev Kher and D.P. Mohapatra, a director in the ministry who signed the document, didn’t respond to e-mails and phone calls seeking comment.

Copyright 2014 Bloomberg

Lead image: Investigation concept via Shutterstock


A biogas plant concept from Weltec Biopower

Europe Versus Renewable Energy?

Tildy Bayar, Contributor Wednesday morning’s 'Regulation and the Marketplace' panel discussion at POWER-GEN Europe in Amsterdam got off to a lively start with a presentation from Randy Mott, president of Polish biogas- and geothermal-bas...
US currency

First Solar and SunPower's Yieldco Venture Seeks $483 Million in Stock Offering

Justin Doom, Bloomberg

8point3 Energy Partners LP, the renewable energy parnership formed by First Solar Inc. and SunPower Corp., is seeking to raise as much as $483 million in an initial public offering.

Wind turbines dusk

India's Solar Embrace Is Leaving Wind Power in the Shade

Anindya Upadhyay, Bloomberg

India is set to add more solar capacity than wind power for the first time as Prime Minister Narendra Modi looks to harness the sun’s rays to curb energy shortages.

The Real Price of Free Solar

William Hirshman, International Correspondent

For a technology known for its tranquility and quietness, the noise surrounding PV as solar leasing becomes the driving force for sales is getting uncomfortably shrill — the pitch of sales pitches is rising.


Volume 18, Issue 3


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:



Microgrid Global Innovation Forum

Microgrid Global Innovation Forum  This event brings together thoug...

Grid Edge Live

Grid Edge Live 2015 The impressive two and a half day agenda addresses k...

2015 Solar Power International

Stop by and visit Canadian Solar at the 2015 SPI show!


A Baseball Cap, the #ElonEffect, and the Power of a Personal Solar ...

A few weeks ago, I wrote about the ElonEffect in relation to Tesla&rsquo...

7 Tips For Active Listening

Selling efficiency is a two-way street: You can’t just bombard you...

Signing a Solar Lease? Here are Five Things You Need to Know

Solar leases have grown in popularity, and they continue to be one of th...


Tweet the Editors! @megcichon @jennrunyon


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now