The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.

WTO Faults Ontario on Renewable Energy Complaint From EU and Japan

WTO Faults Ontario on Renewable Energy Complaint From EU and Japan

World Trade Organization judges largely backed complaints by the European Union and Japan against Canada over subsidies the province of Ontario gives to renewable-energy producers that use domestic technology, according to the Sierra Club and Public Citizen.

Under Ontario’s feed-in tariff program, created by the province’s Green Energy Act, above-market rates are paid to producers of renewable energy provided it is generated with a certain percentage of Canadian-made equipment. The act was designed to help Ontario meet its goal of shutting all its coal- power generators by 2014.

A provision of the program that began in October 2009 requires projects to use goods and labor from Ontario for as much as 60 percent of supply costs, depending on the type of renewable-energy source.

WTO judges agreed with the EU and Japan that provisions of the program discriminate against foreign suppliers of equipment and components for renewable-energy generation facilities by affording less favorable treatment to imported equipment and components than given to like-products originating in Ontario, according to the Sierra Club and Public Citizen. Judges rejected the EU and Japanese argument that the program provisions constitute an illegal subsidy.

Punching Bag

“As countries take steps to address the climate crisis, the last thing we need is the WTO interfering with innovative climate programs,” Ilana Solomon, the Sierra Club’s trade representative, said in an e-mailed statement. “Ontario’s solar and wind incentives program seeks to reduce dangerous carbon pollution and create clean-energy jobs, and it should serve as a model for other countries, not a punching bag.”

The confidential ruling was given to the involved governments. A WTO spokesman in Geneva declined to comment.

The complaints stoked a broader debate over plans by countries including Canada, the U.S. and China to reserve public works as well as energy and environmental projects worth billions of dollars for local companies. Japan’s Trade Policy Bureau has said it is “seriously concerned about a proliferation of such protectionist measures all over the world.”

The Sierra Club and Public Citizen said they were “particularly disappointed” that the U.S. weighed in on the complaint by submitting a brief arguing that Ontario’s program violated WTO rules.

Government Role

“Instead of attacking another country’s clean energy program, the U.S. government should focus on how we will build on our own solutions to tackle the climate crisis and create clean-energy jobs,” Solomon said.

Canada argued that governments have a role in securing a stable supply of electricity for the public benefit and securing renewable electricity to help protect the environment, and that Ontario’s program helps achieve these goals.

EU exports to Canada in wind-power and photovoltaic power- generation equipment are “significant,” according to the Brussels-based European Commission, ranging from 300 million euros ($384 million) to 600 million euros between 2007 and 2009.

Copyright 2012 Bloomberg

Lead image: Golden gavel via Shutterstock


India's Seabiscuit: How Solar Energy Can Be the Symbol of Hope for Electricity Woes

Aditya Goel, Ornate Solar For those unfamiliar with the story of the horse that Hollywood made famous, Seabiscuit was a small horse who had an inauspicious start to his racing career. History though, remembers Seabiscuit not for his diminutive...
Tesla batteries

Advanced Microgrid to Buy Tesla Batteries for Storage Projects

Justin Doom, Bloomberg Advanced Microgrid Solutions, a provider of energy-storage systems, agreed to buy as much as 500 megawatt-hours of battery capacity from Tesla Motors Inc.

Three Chinese Solar Panel Groups Lose Exemption From EU Tariffs

Jonathan Stearns, Bloomberg

The European Union applied tariffs on three groups of Chinese solar-panel makers that have been exempted from the levies, potentially reviving tensions in the EU’s biggest trade case of its kind.

Stock graph

Green Bonds Sprout as Wall Street Embraces Renewable Energy Debt

Cordell Eddings, Bloomberg Bonds backing clean energy and other sustainable initiatives are booming. Investors are snapping up green bonds at the fastest pace on record, as big banks like Morgan Stanley and Bank of America Corp. pile in with new iss...


Volume 18, Issue 3


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:



PV-301: Advanced PV Design & Installation

This highly desirable and advanced course is intended for the profession...

PV-401: Advanced Field Training

Real world on the job solar installation, training, and experience is th...

PV-201: Introduction to PV Design & Installation

PV 201 Introduction to PV Design & Installation is simply the best i...


Five Reasons to Go Solar Now

Solar’s popularity has skyrocketed recently, thanks to a price dro...

Community Solar Solutions Appeal to Eco-Conscious Millennials

Tech savvy and convenience oriented, the millennial generation is the mo...

Building Rapport

How do you build rapport with your prospect? This is a question that I a...


Tweet the Editors! @megcichon @jennrunyon


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now