The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

The Interconnection Nightmare in Hawaii and Why It Matters to the US Residential PV Industry

Since January 1, 2011, Hawaii’s three investor-owned utilities interconnected more than 250 MW of solar PV (almost two-thirds residential) to grids with aggregate peak loads around 1,500 MW. This boom ended five months ago when Hawaiian Electric Company (HECO) abruptly stopped approving residential net metering (NEM) applications for most communities on the island of Oahu. HECO claimed the grid was over-saturated with solar and that further study and infrastructure upgrades were needed to restart the interconnection process. The sudden shift left thousands of consumers stranded in “solar limbo” and caused large-scale lay-offs. Yet for all the media attention the ongoing fiasco has received, its primary lessons remain poorly understood.

HECO’s Residential Interconnection Policy Changes

Paradoxically, the changes that caused the current crisis appear, on paper, to expand interconnection opportunities. To understand how this is possible, we need to go back to September 6th of 2013 when HECO sent PV contractors an email announcing the immediate implementation of the following interconnection policy changes: 

(1)  Caps Increased. Circuit level distributed generation (DG) penetration caps increased (a) from 75 percent to 100 percent of daytime minimum load (DML) for under 10 kW NEM systems and (b) from 50 percent to 100 percent of DML for systems between 10 and 100 kW. (Please note, percentages are total DG nameplate capacity on a distribution feeder divided by minimum load served by the utility on that feeder between 9:00 AM and 5:00 PM. To correct for the DG’s impact on observed minimum load 75 percent of the numerator is added to this number.)

(2)  Pre-Authorization Introduced. HECO directed consumers to seek interconnection approval for <10 kW systems prior to installation, whereas previously contractors notified HECO of a NEM application following permit closure.

The switch from post to pre-installation notification was extremely disruptive for active projects, which had started the installation process relying on one set of rules and now faced interconnection under different set of rules. HECO offered no specific guidance on how work in progress would be affected - only vague assurances that existing projects would not be penalized.  Sales to new customers dropped precipitously, because consumers suddenly faced the prospect of lengthy utility review delays and unpredictable utility connection fees, even though their neighbors and friends had connected easily without additional charges. Switching to pre-notification also swamped HECO’s NEM department by flooding its offices with three-months-worth of NEM applications in just a few days. 

As the public outcry grew, state legislators summoned senior HECO executives to the state capitol to explain their actions.  The hearing ended with Representative Chris Lee, Chair of the House Energy and Environmental Protection Committee, expressing his concern that HECO might need a state bailout as a result of its unwillingness to meet the challenges of a twenty-first century electric utility. 

The Legislature then instructed HECO to work with stakeholders in the solar industry to establish a grandfathering system that fairly treated NEM applicants who had begun their process before the policy change. This group’s solution ultimately resulted in most of these applicants receiving permission to interconnect, and the remainder receiving guarantees that they will eventually be interconnected without additional cost.

The Ongoing Issue is Circuit Penetration

Although the fate of applicants caught in the transition is important, of greater concern is how the sudden crisis occurred in the first place.  The first part of the answer lies in the fact that roughly one-third of HECO’s residential circuits were already above the new 100% DML on September 6th. This number has since grown to about half, and includes much of the buildable residential market. In effect then, the key policy change that took major swaths of the PV market offline was simply HECO’s implementation of the new practice of checking penetration levels when customers proposed projects less than 10 kW.

Given the severe impact on the solar industry and public, the next question is why HECO so urgently imposed its new policy on circuits with solar DG penetration “above 100 percent of DML.” Utilities encourage the public to assume that “being at 100%” indicates that the circuit is “full” and cannot handle additional DG. But this characterization is misleading at best.  The 100 percent DML number is nothing more than a flawed proxy for the possibility that generation may exceed load between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. This cannot actually happen unless generation reaches its peak at the same time load reaches its minimum. When the cycles of peak solar electricity generation and peak customer usage are evaluated, generation on the vast majority of feeders “above 100%” never exceeds load.

Further, even if DG solar generation does sometimes exceed load, it does not automatically follow that the circuit is full and unable to accept more PV without upgrades. Utilities often cite their concern that too much DG may cause reverse power flow at the substations. And yet several of HECO’s substations already experience reverse power flow as a result of distributed generating resources without ill effects. 

So, if reverse power flow is not inherently problematic, what technical concerns might justify the use of the 100% DML standard? The only concrete concern identified by the Hawaii experience is the potential for transient overvoltage on the feeder – essentially a short duration voltage spike. In order for this to occur, however, generation on a feeder must exceed load at the precise time the utility seeks to isolate that feeder from the grid. That is, transient overvoltage arises only in the improbable event that a utility breaker is opened while generation exceeds load on a feeder. 

Although this scenario is anomalous, it cannot be ignored. Nonetheless, only a quick evaluation is needed to establish that this concern is not justified with solar DG, because the majority of today’s inverters trip before any voltage spike can occur. The utility can fully mitigate this small risk by requiring the installation of proper equipment.  Accordingly, the entire chain of reasoning that begins with alleged technical concerns about DG penetration exceeding 100% DML and then attempts to link itself to concerns about reverse power flow and voltage spikes, falls completely apart.   The current levels of solar DG penetration appear to be fully compatible with Hawaii’s electric grid thanks to the technology already installed as components of the DG systems themselves. 

Where Are We Now?

None of this means that high DG penetration is incapable of causing safety or reliability challenges for utilities or their customers. However, it is wholly inaccurate to claim that Hawaii has “reached the limit” or that a DG share “above 100 percent DML” spells the end of interconnections on that circuit. In Hawaii, the hasty imposition of this standard has already resulted in tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars in lost construction activity, layoffs on a massive scale – a more than 50 percent reduction in employment in the sector on Oahu by my estimation — and the denial of relief to customers struggling with electric bills that commonly reach $350 per month.

Hawaii’s experience with high penetration repeatedly reveals that the grid can handle much more DG than previously thought.  Reaching this point has been painstaking and the insights developed have by no means been fully incorporated in to the regulatory process around DG interconnection. However, it is fair to say that based on Hawaii’s experience, there is virtually nowhere else in the U.S. that currently has any justifiable technical concern about the level of DG penetration.

Untitled Document

RELATED ARTICLES

States Already Seek To Delay Clean Power Plan

Andrew Harris, Bloomberg Fifteen states led by coal-rich West Virginia asked a federal court to stall Obama administration rules intended to c...

Stolen Solar Panels and Sabotage A Challenge for Powering India With Renewable Energy

Anindya Upadhyay, Bloomberg Disappointment spread across Tarun Singh’s face when he saw that parts of his solar power microgrid in eastern India’...

Suntech Parent Company Buys Majority Share of US-based Suniva

Ehren Goossens Shunfeng International Clean Energy Ltd., the Hong Kong-based solar company controlled by billionaire Zheng Jianming,...

Sunrise in Pakistan as the Country Delves into Solar PV

Robert Harker Pakistan has joined the list of countries that are exploring solar power as a means to bridge critical energy generat...

PRESS RELEASES

Array Technologies’ DuraTrack HZ v3 Continues to (R)evolutionize at SPI

Array Technologies, Inc. (ATI) prepares to showcase its recently launched tracking syst...

Appalachian's Energy Center assists counties with landfill gas to energy projects

The Appalachian Energy Center at Appalachian State University recently completed a proj...

Early Bird Registration Deadline for GRC Annual Meeting is This Week

The deadline for early-bird rates for registration for the biggest annual geothermal ev...

Redesigned HydroWorld.com Video Gallery

Hydropower news and information, and interesting promotional announcements are now avai...

FEATURED BLOGS

Transitioning to Net-Zero Living

Judith and Jeffrey adore living in Belfast, Maine – a quaint harbor town of Belfast, Maine. They previously res...

The True Cost of Electric Vehicles in Australia

In order to avoid increased congestion, further greenhouse warming and lessen Australia’s reliance on imported ...

The Coming Multi-trillion Dollar Energy Investment Drive

In coming years, a multi-trillion dollar low-emission energy investment drive will get underway. Three catalysts wil...

The Perfect Elevator Pitch

The elevator pitch is a concise statement that grabs attention and communicates value, ideally leading to a next step...

FINANCIAL NEWS

Colin Yost is a Director of RevoluSun Solar Corp. He is also a Principal and General Counsel of RevoluSun LLC (RevoluSun) and Distributed Energy Partners LLC (DEP), and has managed the legal affairs of RevoluSun and DEP since 2010. Colin’s lega...

CURRENT MAGAZINE ISSUE

Volume 18, Issue 4
1507REW_C11

STAY CONNECTED

To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon

FEATURED PARTNERS



EVENTS

Intersolar South America 2015

Exhibition and Conference: September 1-3, 2015 Intersolar South America ...

Intersolar Europe 2016

Exhibition: June 22-24, 2016; Conference: June 21-22, 2016 Intersolar Eu...

Intersolar India 2015

Exhibition and Conference: November 18-20, 2015 Intersolar India 2015 I...

COMPANY BLOGS

How To Recruit An Internal Ally

When you’re collecting information for a proposal, the person with...

The Proof Is Not Always In The Pudding

One of the best ways to turn a skeptical prospect into a buyer is to giv...

Pushing Beyond The Cushion

Efficiency projects are all too often viewed as “optional” o...

NEWSLETTERS

Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now  

 

FEATURED PARTNERS