The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

Minn. Judge: Solar Beats Natural Gas for Utility Procurement

In what is being called an unprecedented decision, solar energy went head-to-head with natural gas in a competitive evaluation for utility resource planning — and solar came out on top.

Minnesota's renewable portfolio standard (RPS) calls for 25 percent of generation by 2025 from renewable energy sources. For Xcel, the state's largest electric utility, the rules are more aggressive at 31.5 percent by 2020. Last spring the state added a solar carve-out of 1.5 percent from solar by 2020, equivalent to about 450 MW of new solar capacity. The Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC) determined that Xcel Energy demonstrated need for 150 MW of new electricity generation by 2017 (and possibly 500 MW by 2019) and directed the Office of Administrative Hearings (ALJ) to look at several proposals to decide "the most reasonable and prudent strategy" to meet Xcel's needs. Five proposals were received and accepted:

  • Xcel: three 215-MW natural-gas-fired, simple-cycle combustion turbine generators, two at its Black Dog facility in Burnsville, MN and two others at its Red River Valley facility in Hankinson, ND;
  • Calpine: a 345-MW combined cycle gas plant at its Mankato Energy Center, adding 290-MW of intermediate combined-cycle capacity and 55-MW of peaking capacity;
  • Geronimo Energy: 100-MW (AC) distributed solar capacity intermittent resource, spread across approximately 20 sites;
  • Great River Energy (GRE): proposed sale of capacity credits;
  • Invenergy: a 179-MW combustion turbine peaking facility at Cannon Falls and two 179-MW combustion turbines near Hampton, MN

Geronimo's proposed Aurora solar project encompasses roughly 20 different commercial-sized sites (2-10 MW) adding up to 100 MW, sized to offset roughly 20 percent of the existing load at each respective substation. Construction would begin in 2015 and all of the sites would be online by the end of 2016 to serve Xcel's capacity needs in 2017 (and to qualify for expiring investment tax credits). Two different pricing proposals were submitted under a 20-year PPA structure: one with a fixed monthly payment per kilowatt (kW) for capacity and an energy payment for all energy generated, and another as an energy-only payment bundling everything into a single dollars/MWh price. The total cost of Aurora is projected at $250 million.

Using computer models, the ALJ's administrative law judge Eric Lipman compared each proposal against each other, gauging cost savings, fuel consumption, pollutants emitted, and other factors, and then added a number of contingencies for mandated CO2 reductions, market pricing fluctuations for each energy source, and both short- and long-term demand projections — as well as the mandated RPS and solar carve-out. Lipman also added criteria to be "compatible with protecting the natural and socioeconomic environments, including human health." He also narrowed the scope to a short-term window, since Xcel could face a capacity deficit of 93 MW in 2017, and as much as 307 MW by 2019; calculations for demand beyond 2019 should revisited later, he said. (Here's the full PDF from the state's PUC.)

Thus, Lipman decreed that in the short-term "the greatest value to Minnesota and Xcel's ratepayers is drawn from selecting Geronimo's solar energy proposal" and possibly adding GRE's capacity credits. Geronimo's proposal, he declared, "when properly analyzed under either a LCOE or strategist modeling, is the lowest cost resource proposed," plus it represents the lowest risk against policy compliances.

Lipman himself noted the importance of this decision, calling it "an important turning point in Minnesota's energy resource planning process." For twenty-odd years the state has had policies supporting renewable energy sources, yet "nonrenewable energy sources always won the head-to-head cost comparisons. Not anymore." This time, he noted, "Geronimo entered this bidding process as the sole renewable technology and beat competing offerors on total life-cycle costs."

Responding to the ruling, Xcel issued a statement saying it appreciates the work of the ALJ toward resource acquisitions but it "disagree[s] with some of the findings and recommendation," and the company pledged to file a complete response once exceptions are filed with the commission, expected later this month. The PUC's final ruling should come a month or two after that.

Lead image: Illustration of boxer punch, via Shutterstock

Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox - FREE!

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World Magazine and our award-winning e-Newsletter to stay up to date on current news and industry trends.

 Subscribe Now


US Senate Democrats Unveil Energy Bill That Restores PTC and Extends ITC

Brian Eckhouse, Bloomberg Senate Democrats unveiled a bill that would provide more tax credits for renewable energy while killing some tax ince...

US, China Solar PV Players Team Up, Invest $100MM in Chile, Uruguay and Japan

Andrew Burger Private equity infrastructure specialist Hudson Clean Energy Partners and Hong Kong-based independent power producer ...

CEO Gilles: Challenge in Geothermal is to 'Level Playing Field' with Wind, Solar

Jennifer Delony The current challenge for the geothermal energy industry is what U.S. Geothermal CEO Dennis Gilles calls “leveling th...

NRG Energy to Form Renewable Unit, Sell Wind Assets to Yieldco

Mark Chediak and Matthew Monks, Bloomberg NRG Energy Inc., the worst-performing member of the S&P 500 Utilities Index this year, said it will form a renewa...


NC State University Installs Student-Funded Spotlight Solar Structure to Drive Awareness and Adoption of Clean Energy

North Carolina State University (NC State) will today showcase its commitment to clean ...

Canadian Solar Signs Agreement with Mashiki Town and Kumamoto Prefecture to Build 47 MW Solar Plant in Japan

Canadian Solar Signs Agreement for 47 MW Solar Plant

NEC Energy Partners with Eos Energy Storage to Bring Revolutionary Energy Storage Product to Market

NEC Energy Solutions (“NEC ES”), a subsidiary of NEC Corporation, announced today that ...

$100 Discount on 5-day Advanced PV Project Experience Workshop

Upcoming 5-day Workshops: Nov. 7 - 11 Feb. 6 - 10


Beyond Utility 2.0: Part 4 “Next Steps”

Principles, Structure, and Policies of Energy Democracy Energy democracy can best be described as an electricity sy...

30 Minutes Off

Smartphones have become one of the most valuable tools in the business world. They give us access to our email, conta...

Weather watching

GCube, the renewable energy sector insurance underwriter, has launched a new Weather Risk Transfer mechanism to provi...

How to Save on Your Next Power Bill

  Your rooftop solar is going to generate less electricity over the winter months. Your hot water and he...


Jim is Contributing Editor for, covering the solar and wind beats. He previously was associate editor for Solid State Technology and Photovoltaics World, and has covered semiconductor manufacturing and related industries, ...


Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



Successfully Integrating Solar: A Proactive Approach

•      What does the increasing solar penetrati...

Canadian Solar Inverters Webinar

Canadian Solar is proud to be hosting two free webinars in October! The ...

JuiceBox Energy Certified Installer Class

JuiceBox Energy is rapidly building out its national certified installer...


How To Speak, How To Listen

As sales professionals, effective communication is paramount to our succ...

Get In The Habit

We all develop habits throughout our lives. Sometimes they’re bene...

Becoming An Efficiency Sales Professional

In order to become a sales professional, you must first realize that: E...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now