The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

US Leads, Europe Second as Wind Industry Spends $430 Million on Patent Protection

Utility scale wind turbines have become so technologically advanced that they have improved the cost of energy (COE) of wind enough to compete with today’s conventional energy sources. The ensuing reduction in COE has been the result of two governing forces: public policy and technological innovation. The technological trends which have emerged thus far and what might be in store for the future direction of wind turbine technology are explored here. Policy and governmental R&D support will continue to be essential, and barriers to wind technology commercialization must be further broken down.

The patent landscape can shed significant insight into what technological trends have emerged thus far and what we might be able to infer for the future direction of wind turbine technology.  The patent landscape analytics, as well as extensive analysis of forward looking competitive intelligence, helps shape our view of future technology trends for the industry.


Figure 1 - Analysis Methodology

 The patent search results comprise over 8,665 patent families and over 32,834 global filings from 67 different countries, dating back to the year 1916 when some of the first grid connected technology took root.  In addition to a component and technology keyword classification, an assessment of the relevance of each patent filing to the industry was performed and results were classified as Low, Medium, Medium/High, and High.  The assessment of industry relevance indicates the degree to which the patent owner has asserted their patent rights in the past or would be able to seek licenses or otherwise enforce the patent due to usage of that patent protected technology by their competition.


Figure 2 - Industry Relevance Assessment

 With the results grouped by assignee (or patent owner), it should come as no shock to industry watchers who are the top assignees for wind patent filings.  The list largely coincides with the top market share holders in the sector, and the chart below shows the number of patent families held by each company.


Figure 3 - Assignees (by Patent Family)

The industry relevance results indicate that only 0.8 percent of issued patents would have a high impact on the entire industry as a whole if those patents were universally asserted, with another 6.9 percent which may become relevant in the future depending on technology evolution and use.  The remaining 92.3 percent of filings are merely providing owners with basic defensive IP protection on technologies they use in their own product lines, but are not widely used in the industry.

All combined, the top 10 turbine OEM patent holders control 54.5 percent of patent filings.  Only 67 patent families out of 8,665 catalogued thus far comprise technology which is broadly applicable to products and services offered commercially within the industry worldwide.

General Electric Company (GE) controls not only the largest number of patent families, but the largest percentage of all wind-related IP with over 15 percent of patent filings.  While most companies are in-line with industry averages in terms of overall portfolio distribution of Low, Medium and High risk filings, GE’s High risk patents as a percentage of their overall portfolio is double the industry average at 1.8 percent vs. 0.8 percent.  Their portfolio also comprises over 35 percent of all High risk patents held by all companies throughout the industry.


Figure 4 – Global Wind IP Ownership Share

 Also notable is that top-tier companies have a combined High and Medium/High set of filings which is above the industry average of 7.7 percent.  The top 10 control over 77 percent of Medium/High and 80 percent of High risk patent filings.  This confirms the strong correlation between investment in both R&D and IP protection and the commercial success of top-tier companies.  There is a strong link between the reduced CapEx and optimized energy production resulting from the development and introduction of those patent protected technologies.

The heat map of the filing dates for the patent filings confirms that the majority of filings have occurred in the past decade or so.  Comparison of this trend to turbine capacity additions worldwide is reflective of the shared influence of public policy on technology adoption and the subsequent cost efficiencies enabled by widespread deployment of wind turbines.  IP capture will continue to be an important consideration for top tier companies who are developing and commercializing new products.

Please note that the 2012–2013 filings have not all yet published because of an 18 month window in which the patents are not made public.  Filing count up to 2011 is comprehensive.


Figure 5 – Wind Industry Patent Filing Trends (Patent Families)

Countries favored for filing include the U.S., Europe and China, with PCT applications being used heavily in the past few decades. Collectively, the wind industry has spent nearly US $430 million (in 2013 dollars) to date on patent protection across all jurisdictions since 1916. Our projections indicate that the total will exceed $1 billion by 2020 and $2 billion by 2030, with escalation of filing pace assumed to be consistent to that of the past five years.  Annual expenditure will top $100 million per year by 2022.


Figure 6 - Global Wind Industry Patent Filing Costs


Figure 7 - Global Wind Industry Patent Filings (Top 30 Countries)

The following are what we believe to be the emerging trends in wind turbine technology, and therefore patent protection.

Component Size and Weight Reduction (i.e., maintaining tower head mass ratio) – transportation across land and sea of increasingly heavy components:

  • Advanced materials such as low cost carbon and hybrid fabrics for blades, graphene-based power electronics and alternatives to rare earth magnet materials;
  • Sectional components such as blades and towers;
  • ‘Self-erecting’ capabilities;
  • On-site assembly procedures while maintaining component quality/integrity;
  • Load mitigation tech/controls, especially incorporation of forward-looking capabilities like LIDAR as well as model based controls and anticipatory controls.

Turbine Reliability:

  • Drivetrain/turbine architecture (fewer gearbox stages – move towards medium speed)
    • Elimination of gearbox - direct drive;
    • Gearbox load mitigation utilizing flex-pin architecture;
  • Simplified electrical component design – solid state power electronics.

Fleet Management/O&M:

  • Deployment of condition based maintenance solutions (CBMS) with emphasis on:
    • Calculating component damage accumulation;
    • Calculating remaining useful component/system life;
    • Turbine output optimization based on remaining useful life;
    • Trend analysis of SCADA data;
    • Predictive maintenance scheduling;
    • Spares demand scheduling;
  • Remote inspection technologies:
    • Remotely monitored sensor systems;
    • Wireless data transmission technologies;
    • Optical / video camera based blade tower inspection;
    • Tower climbing inspection "robots";
    • Aerial remote controlled vehicles.

 Performance Optimization:

  • “Maximum energy, all the time”:
    • Optimal energy production regardless of prevailing conditions;
    • Derate / Uprate control capabilities;
    • Active power curtailment while maintaining wind farm local grid stability.
  • Site-specific design and assessment tools – modularity of component design and the ability to have multiple options for hub height and rotor size mean more opportunities exist for a common platform architecture to serve a particular wind site regardless of variation in average sped and wind shear;
  • Integration of turbine controls with the condition monitoring system (CMS);
  • Blade aero / structural performance – flaps, vortex generators, plasma actuators.

Grid Friendly:

  • SCADA and power plant controls – ensuring wind parks operate much like conventional energy plants today, where output can be throttled and grid fluctuations can be absorbed, etc;
  • Multi-level, medium voltage converters/electrical system components;
  • Enhanced LVRT and VAR support;
  • Energy storage for time shifting, black start and grid smoothing;
  • Mitigation of grid harmonics and sub-synchronous inductance;


  • Custom installation vessels and methods;
  • Load mitigating foundations – floating, jacket, monopile, suction bucket and gravity base;
  • Co-generating foundation structures.

To keep reducing COE there will need to be enormous R&D expenditure to get even a 5–10 percent improvement going forward, due to diminishing returns being reached in turbine CapEx. 


 Figure 8 - Wind Industry Technology Maturity Trend

Another factor which contributes significantly to the commercialization gap are project financiers who do not incentivize the development and introduction of new technologies and products due to the associated technical and commercial risks. This leaves turbine OEMs and key component suppliers to vendor-fund prototypes, form JVs, partner with developers/customers or seek external investment.  All of those options can be expensive propositions, and are likely more suited to the domain of the larger industrial conglomerates.

Images courtesy Totaro and Associates

Lead image: Wind turbines in field, via Shutterstock

Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now


offshore wind

Hitachi Plans to Add Production Line for Offshore Wind Parts

Chisaki Watanabe, Bloomberg Hitachi Ltd. plans to expand its reach into the market for offshore wind projects by adding a production line to make...
Renewable energy

Leading US ICT Companies Renewables Use at 14%, and Growing

Andrew Burger Electricity consumption in the global information and communications technology (ICT) industry is growing rapidly. An...
Wind farms

Western: Streamlined Environmental Review Process for Wind Farms in Midwest ‘Takes Effect Right Away’

Jennifer Delony Western in an Aug. 26 record of decision (ROD) adopted a standardized process for collecting information and evaluati...

NextEra Commits to Hawaii’s Clean Power Goal, Local Management

Lynn Doan, Bloomberg NextEra Energy Inc. and Hawaiian Electric Industries Inc. made 50 new commitments as part of their proposal to merge ...


Array Technologies Finalizes Shipments to E.ON’s Maricopa West Solar Project

Array Technologies, Inc. (ATI) has completed DuraTrack® HZ shipments to the 20 MW (ac) ...

B.C. Energy Minister to provide keynote at renewables for mines summit.

BC Minister of Energy and Mines to address the challenges of providing alternative powe...

Mining leaders seek renewables solutions at Toronto Summit

The global mining sector is facing a tough business environment with low commodity pric...

American Renewable Energy Institute Gears Up for 12th Annual Summit

"Racing Climate Change: Green Bridge with China, The Road to Paris” is the theme of th...


New Mexico Attracts Jobs and Revenues with Renewable Energy Tax Credit

New Mexico has abundant fossil fuel resources: in 2013, it ranked sixth in the nation for crude oil production, seven...

The Vice President Stole My Show (Not Really)

When I finished my Solar Power International (SPI) panel discussing what future opportunities the panelists saw in so...

The Value Of The Building

If you’re selling efficiency solutions in the built environment, you may find yourself being asked by your pros...

Sewage provides energy through processing

Many nations are investing in new technology to turn sewage waste into usable energy. Japan has recently revised its ...


Philip Totaro is the Founder and CEO of Totaro & Associates, a market research and innovation strategy consulting firm based in Santa Barbara, CA, USA. Mr. Totaro is regarded worldwide as the foremost expert on wind industry technology and intell...


Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



Doing Business in Europe – in partnership with GWEC, the Global Win...

There is now 128.8 GW of installed wind energy capacity in the EU (appro...

Doing Business in South Africa – in partnership with GWEC, the Glob...

Wind Energy in South Africa has been expanding dramatically, growing fro...

Distributed Wind Energy Workshop

Description: Distributed wind energy is electricity that is produced for...


Clean Energy Patents Maintain High Levels in First Quarter, Solar L...

U.S. patents for Clean Energy technologies from the first quarter of 201...

Fact Check: AWEA represents American wind power

The American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) is proud of its members for ...

Koch Professor drops his Koch title, still makes same errors plus s...

The Koch Professor’s title isn’t the only thing that’s...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now