The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

NREL, MIT: Chinese Solar PV Manufacturing Advantages Not Set in Stone

Chinese solar photovoltaic (PV) manufacturing, specifically crystalline solar PV, have dominated the industry's total global production for the past several years. But a new report co-produced by NREL and MIT suggests the real reasons for regional price differences are not indigenous -- meaning China's current competitive advantages can be matched.

Their new study, hot off the press in the latest issue of Energy & Environmental Science, calculates a minimum sustainable price (MSP) for solar panel manufacturing in both the U.S. and China, taking into account not just the technical costs to make a PV module but how to do so with a profit. The MSP includes other factors like labor costs, equipment depreciation, R&D, taxes, and other strictly nontechnical factors.

Looking beyond manufacturing steps and associated costs more accurately represents how companies have to exist in the real world, explained Tonio Buonassisi, report co-author and associate professor of mechanical engineering at MIT. "You can survive as a company selling below that [minimum price] if you ignore depreciation of capital equipment or other expenses, or present a best-case scenario of uptime, but that ignores reality," he said. The report addresses the PV industry's problem of unsustainably low panel prices.

Adding up all production factors (except shipping costs) the researchers found Chinese-based manufacturers have a 23 percent advantage in MSP over U.S.-based manufacturers, about $1.19/W vs. $0.91/W. What makes the most difference by far, they found, is how the Chinese PV module makers have scaled up: Chinese factories being several times larger than those in the U.S., and certain supply-chain advantages including extensive discounts on materials and equipment (often from domestic sources). Regional incentives, low-cost debt, and other country-specific factors do help enable that scaling, but they have less affect on the MSP equation, they show.

One takeaway from the report is that solar PV scaling isn't an inherently Chinese advantage; it can be replicated elsewhere. The flip-side of that thinking, though, is that regional advantages do exist even if they're less influential to the MSP. So multinational companies who can spread themselves globally and take advantage of various regional benefits will clearly be in the best position.

The other takeaway is that today's low-cost advantages could be neutralized by future solar PV technology improvements. Higher efficiency translates to lower costs everywhere else, from balance-of-system requirements to project development (same output/smaller footprint, more output/same footprint). Thinner silicon and glass will save costs in materials and processing.

Put scaling and technology improvements together and the aforementioned MSP advantage practically evaporates -- narrowing to just $0.64/W in China vs. $0.62/W in the U.S. Ultimately that nexus will push total costs down and make subsidies obsolete, which will further entice private investments.

"The main takeaway is that innovation will continue," chimed NREL's Ted James, another report co-author. "Current manufacturing competitive advantages are not inherent to a region. The final chapter has certainly not been written."

Lead image: Balance, via Shutterstock

Read more solar energy news here.

Untitled Document

RELATED ARTICLES

Hybrid solar minigrid to power Tanzanian island village

Tildy Bayar

A hybrid solar photovoltaic-battery energy storage-diesel minigrid project aims to provide power for around 400 households in the remote island village of Lake Victoria (pictured) in Tanzania. 

World Moves Toward 100 Percent Renewable Energy – First Electricity, Then Heating/Cooling, and Finally Transportation

Junko Movellan, Correspondent The exclusive use of energy from renewable resources in at least one sector has now become a feasible goal for 8 countries. Diane Moss, Founding Director of Renewables 100 Policy Institute, discussed this remarkable develop...

Solar power growth impacting UK electricity sector

Diarmaid Williams

Q2 of 2015 saw a large increase in the generation of electricity from solar PV in the UK, with the growth having a significant impact on electricity market prices and other supply factors.

PACE Finance Opening Doors for C&I Solar In California

Susan Kraemer, Correspondent With its excellent renewable policy, California leads the nation in solar. Over the years both the Renewable Portfolio Standard and the California Solar Initiative drove utility scale and residential solar deployment. But w...
Jim is Contributing Editor for RenewableEnergyWorld.com, covering the solar and wind beats. He previously was associate editor for Solid State Technology and Photovoltaics World, and has covered semiconductor manufacturing and related industries, ...

CURRENT MAGAZINE ISSUE

Volume 18, Issue 4
1507REW_C11

STAY CONNECTED

To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

Tweet the Editors! @megcichon @jennrunyon

FEATURED PARTNERS



EVENTS

Grid-connected and Off-grid Photovoltaics

This training covers all aspects of planning, installation, maintenance,...

2015 Intersolar-South America

Canadian Solar will be exhibiting @ Intersolar-South America. Stop by an...

5th Annual Hydro Plant Maintenance

Join maintenance professionals to discuss the challenges in maintenance ...

COMPANY BLOGS

Prevailing At A Premium

As efficiency sales professionals, we’re often faced with situatio...

Do Your Goals Match Your Values?

Before you set goals for your company or your personal work performance ...

LSX rises with sustainable wine making in Mexico

his custom LSX solar canopy shades the upper deck organic gard...

NEWSLETTERS

Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now  

 

FEATURED PARTNERS