The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

Geothermal Energy: Why It Is Different From Shale Gas

The possibility of producing shale gas in some European countries has triggered a very heated debate about the environmental and social impacts of the technique used to extract gas from shale rocks (today only in the US and Canada); this technique is widely known as hydraulic fracturing or fracking.

Recently, part of the gas industry has claimed that fracking for shale gas is comparable to the hydraulic stimulation process used for geothermal exploration and that the granting of geothermal exploration permits whilst those for shale gas are rejected is creating a double standard.  Whilst there are similarities, it is important to understand the intricacies and differences between the two technologies.

An Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS) is an underground reservoir that has been created or improved artificially.  Traditionally, we only saw geothermal power plants in areas with highly permeable rocks and high underground temperatures, such as Tuscany and Iceland. EGS allow us to increase the permeability of rocks, which means we can use the geothermal resources right across Europe – even in areas with lower temperatures.

Drilling operation at Egoci project - EGS (France)

Both EGS and shale gas extraction technologies have a shared objective: to use stimulation techniques based on the high pressure injection of water in order to extract as much mass flow as possible. However, the target is different, either heat or gas. Shale gas is locked in rocks, typically with low permeability in sedimentary basins, in a dispersed form without fluid. Geothermal power production targets semi-permeable rocks, so the pressure of the required injection is lower.

There are also important differences in terms of the fluid used. With EGS, no specific additives are required; the fluid includes water, which may have minerals added so that the water’s composition matches that already existing in the subsurface. The advantage of EGS is that the permeability is permanently increased, the artificial reservoir is self-sustaining and does not require further stimulation. The stimulation fluid does not need to be pumped back up to the surface as it now forms an integral part of the newly created reservoir.

In the case of shale gas, there is always a need to create new fractures and in order to keep the fractures open, additives and sand are mixed with the water. As these fluids can reduce the production efficiency, they need to be pumped back to the surface. The absence of a natural fluid in the underground requires the supply of water from external sources. A large quantity (10.000–20.000 m3/well) is required and as a result significant level of chemicals.

There has been public concern about micro-seismic activity (less than 3.5 on the Richter scale) in relation to hydraulic stimulation. Monitoring protocols have been established by the industry, using the long experience of the oil and gas sector in this area. Geothermal drillers install seismometers and use special purpose software to map the faults and assess the local geology. This enables them to monitor what will happen during the stimulation, to create a risk management plan, and to control micro-seismicity.

Drilling site for an EGS project

The European Parliament’s resolution (2011/2309(INI) urges public authorities to introduce underground regional planning in order to optimise resource allocation between geothermal energy, shale gas, carbon capture and storage (CCS) and possible other possible underground uses, and thereby maximising the benefits of our underground resources for society.

As our use of the underground changes, we will need to prioritise the way we use it. Shale gas is an extension of classical hydrocarbon technology whereas geothermal energy is a sustainable and renewable energy resource.

Philippe Dumas is Secretary General, and Luca Angelino is Policy and Project Officer, at the European Geothermal Energy Council.

Images courtesy European Geothermal Energy Council

Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now


Top 10 Clean Energy Trends Driving the Global Clean Energy Revolution

Top 10 Clean Energy Trends Driving the Global Clean Energy Revolution

Geothermal Industry Could Come With $73 Billion Price Tag

Anna Hirtenstein, Bloomberg The geothermal industry may need as much as $73 billion in public financing, almost 10 times current spending levels,...

States Already Seek To Delay Clean Power Plan

Andrew Harris, Bloomberg Fifteen states led by coal-rich West Virginia asked a federal court to stall Obama administration rules intended to c...

Global Renewable Energy Roundup: China, Kenya, Turkey, India Seeking More Renewables

Bloomberg News Editors China is being encouraged by three industry groups to double the nation’s solar-power goal for 2020 to make up for sh...


Canadian Solar Signs Agreement with Mashiki Town and Kumamoto Prefecture to Build 47 MW Solar Plant in Japan

Canadian Solar Signs Agreement for 47 MW Solar Plant

NC State University Installs Student-Funded Spotlight Solar Structure to Drive Awareness and Adoption of Clean Energy

North Carolina State University (NC State) will today showcase its commitment to clean ...

$100 Discount on 5-day Advanced PV Project Experience Workshop

Upcoming 5-day Workshops: Nov. 7 - 11 Feb. 6 - 10

NEC Energy Partners with Eos Energy Storage to Bring Revolutionary Energy Storage Product to Market

NEC Energy Solutions (“NEC ES”), a subsidiary of NEC Corporation, announced today that ...


Beyond Utility 2.0: Part 4 “Next Steps”

Principles, Structure, and Policies of Energy Democracy Energy democracy can best be described as an electricity sy...

30 Minutes Off

Smartphones have become one of the most valuable tools in the business world. They give us access to our email, conta...

Weather watching

GCube, the renewable energy sector insurance underwriter, has launched a new Weather Risk Transfer mechanism to provi...

How to Save on Your Next Power Bill

  Your rooftop solar is going to generate less electricity over the winter months. Your hot water and he...


Philippe Dumas, after a master in European Affairs in 1999, first worked in a European engineering company as representative in Brussels for EU affairs (2000-2007). Firstly involved in geothermal energy with EGEC, starting as project manager for ...


Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



GeoPower & Heat Summit

The GeoPower & Heat Summit is the most commercial event in the geoth...

International Energy and Sustainability Conference 2015

The fourth International Energy and Sustainability Conference will be he...

GRC Workshop at Indonesian International Geothermal Convention & Ex...

The Geothermal Conceptual Model & Well Targeting The Geothermal Me...


Final Program Now Available for GRC Annual Meeting & GEA Geothermal...

GRC Annual Meeting & GEA Geothermal Energy Expo - Final Program f...

GRC Annual Geothermal Photo Contest - View all the Entries

36th Annual Geothermal Photo Contest The Geothermal Resources

Why Electric Utilities Love Geothermal

When it comes time to think about replacing the heating and cooling syst...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now