The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.

CSP Progress Report: Two Steps Forward, One Step Back

Some of the planet's biggest solar energy plants are about to come online in the U.S., showcasing the promise and potential of both large utility-scale solar energy and in particular concentrating solar power (CSP) technology.

CSP has had a long road to commercialization, largely falling out of favor as costs and pricing have been overwhelmed by plummeting solar PV metrics, though it's carved out what should be a competitive sweetspot in very high-insolation areas in various regions. Three CSP plants in the U.S. long in development are back in the news this week, though not for the same reasons.

Final Countdown for Ivanpah, Solana

Four months after declaring it was in its final days of construction and doing steam blow tests, the 392-MW (370-MW net) Ivanpah plant in California's Mojave Desert now has achieved "first sync" with its first unit station, meaning it's produced output and synched it to the power grid and showing "operational readiness." Tests for the site's Unit 2 and 3 stations will happen "in the coming months," according to NRG Energy. Ivanpah has PPAs in hand with Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) for its Unit 1 and Unit 3 stations, and a PPA with Southern California Edison (SCE) for the site's Unit 2. Project backers include Brightsource with its "power tower" technology and Google with its wallet; Bechtel is the EPC firm.

Meanwhile, Abengoa's Solana plant near Gila Bend, Arizona, a 280-MW parabolic trough plant that features six hours of thermal energy storage (molten salt), also is entering final testing stages after three years of construction. Local reports indicate the project already has been sending power to the grid and should reach full capacity in October. The Solana project has a 30-year, $4 billion PPA with Arizona Public Service (APS) to purchase all of the site's power. For interested parties in the vicinity, Abengoa and APS are said to be offering sneak-peek tours in the coming days.

CEC: Concerns And Uncertainty About Palen

Another CSP project in California doesn't have such good news, though. The California Energy Commission's (CEC's) final environmental analysis of the Palen solar plant delivers some bad news for the project: the CEC says it will "have significant environmental impacts" for visual resources even with recommended mitigation measures, and would not comply with all related laws, ordinances, regulations, and standards. The CEC also expressed doubt that recommended measures will significantly mitigate impacts to avian species.

Earlier this year Brightsource mothballed two other planned large CSP projects, Rio Mesa and Hidden Hills, to direct its attention to Palen, which encompasses twin 250-MW solar plants each with 85,000 heliostats focused on a receiver atop a 750-foot-tall power tower. This project has already been revised and scaled back to address various concerns, from reducing the land and water usage to eliminating the need for an extra transmission line. If and once Palen gets approved, construction would take nearly three years and cost roughly $2 billion.

Specifically the CEC cites concerns about impacts to biological resources including "Sonoran creosote bush scrub, sand dunes, desert washes and other native plant and wildlife communities." Adding fencing won't help spare habitats because it will keep out most terrestrial animals, and noise and activities at the site will further drive them away. The CEC also expresses concern about impacts to birds and bat species -- most notably, bald and golden eagles -- from "solar flux" (essentially cooking them mid-flight) to sky reflections in the mirrors that might appear as a body of water, attracting them down into collisions. Lethal and sub-lethal injuries "would be significant," the CEC says, though acknowledging that no mechanism to quantify this potential exists." The CEC's concerns about visual impacts include "substantial adverse impact to existing scenic resource values" in the area, from the Chuckwalla Mountains and Interstate 10 to the south, Joshua Tree National Park and Route 177 to the west/northwest, and Palen McCoy Wilderness to the northeast.

This CEC filing isn't a proposed decision on the project, but it will represent the CEC's testimony at commission hearings to review the proposed project. As KCET's Chris Clarke points out, CEC's staff concerns have been overridden in past project approvals. Further CEC assessments related to the Palen site about cultural resources and air quality/greenhouse gases are due in coming weeks.

Lead image: Walking on endless stairs, via Shutterstock

RELATED ARTICLES

What Is the Value of Solar Energy + Storage?

Andrew Burger, Contributor What's the true, overall value of combined “behind the meter” energy storage plus solar PV deployment to U.S. power utilities and their customers? That's the big question facing stakeholders in Hawaii and other U.S. states ...

Listen Up: The Solar Maintenance Myth

The Energy Show on Renewable Energy World Why are rooftop solar systems so reliable? First, because the solar panels themselves have zero moving parts, use tempered glass and anodized aluminum (better than most windows and skylights), and are covered by a 25 year m...
Solar panels

New Tool Helps Utilities Manage the Rapidly Growing Community Solar Market

Vince Font, Contributing Editor Community solar projects are among the fastest growing solar segments in the U.S with some estimates forecasting that community solar initiatives will be responsible for the addition of 500 MW (megawatts) of annual capacity...
Pope Francis

A 9-Minute Guide To Pope Francis’ Encyclical on Climate Change

Jim Lane, Biofuels Digest Pope Francis issued Laudato si’ (Praise Be to You) On the care for our common home, his second encyclical, concerning Catholic doctrine with respect to climate change, consumerism, and development.
Jim is Contributing Editor for RenewableEnergyWorld.com, covering the solar and wind beats. He previously was associate editor for Solid State Technology and Photovoltaics World, and has covered semiconductor manufacturing and related industries, ...

CURRENT MAGAZINE ISSUE

Volume 18, Issue 3
1505REW_C11

STAY CONNECTED

To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

Tweet the Editors! @megcichon @jennrunyon

FEATURED PARTNERS



EVENTS

Training: Meeting NEC 2014 Code Compliance - Installer Challenges a...

CLICK HERE to register for a FREE expo entrance pass and ...

NFMT Orlando

NFMT Orlando is a trade show and educational conference for facility pro...

Green Sports Alliance Summit

The annual Green Sports Alliance Summit is the world’s largest and...

COMPANY BLOGS

Five Reasons Why Solar is a Safe Investment

Nothing is certain but death and taxes. But most of us are confident tha...

Be Your Customer's Hero

How do you win business in a competitive marketplace? If your products a...

Reframing Your Time

I think it’s safe to say that most of us are in a constant battle ...

NEWSLETTERS

Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now  

 

FEATURED PARTNERS