The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

RPS Attacks Go Against the March of History

Last week in Phoenix, I watched the very conservative governor of Arizona, Jan Brewer, deliver a brief keynote speech to open the second day of the CleanTech Future conference put on by CleanTech Connections and the Arizona Commerce Authority. Nineteen floors above the impressive solar PV arrays at Arizona State University's downtown campus across the street, Brewer extolled the virtues of solar and other clean energy as a business boon for her state.

“Let me tell you what clean tech is not about,” said Brewer, who’s probably best known for Arizona’s controversial immigration policies – and wagging her finger in President Obama’s face on an airport tarmac last year. “It’s not about hugging a tree, saving a whale, or joining a drum circle. It’s about innovation and advanced thinking.” She noted that she’s used solar in her home since the 1970s, and that Arizona installed more utility-scale solar capacity in the past year than any other state. “Despite some bumps in the road,” said Brewer, “the future for solar in Arizona is bright.”

Some of those bumps, like Suntech’s March closing of its PV panel factory in Goodyear, Arizona after its recent bankruptcy, are due to economic factors. But unfortunately, others are due to a concentrated effort by many in Brewer’s Republican party to attack the growth of clean energy in states across the country.

The American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a non-profit advocacy group with strong ties to Koch Industries and other fossil-fuel interests, is attempting to roll back renewable portfolio standard (RPS) laws in nearly two dozen of the 29 states that have them. Last fall, it released a template bill called the “Electricity Freedom Act” for supportive legislators to push in their respective states. The key portion of this template reads as follows: “The State of {insert state} repeals the renewable energy mandate and as such, no electric distribution utilities and electric services companies will be forced to procure renewable energy resources as defined by the State of {insert state}’s renewable energy mandate." 

In addition to its stated libertarian, limited-government position, ALEC and its allies have claimed that RPS mandates substantially drive up a state’s electric rates. But a comprehensive study of RPS impacts presented in December by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found that only one state, Arizona, saw rate increases of more than two percent — and even there it was less than four percent. 

But as we know all too well, facts don’t always win the day in politics, whether on Capitol Hill or the nation’s statehouses. The good news here is that ALEC’s efforts to cut back RPS mandates have yet to succeed anywhere. In at least two states, Kansas and Arizona, damaging bills have been either voted down or withdrawn. But in cases like these, can we really declare victory for clean energy when all we’ve done is successfully defend what we already have?

The answer, I believe, is yes. Because efforts like ALEC’s to roll back progress toward a clean-energy economy can actually backfire. They galvanize opposition, perhaps starting with environmental activists but bringing in unlikely allies like farmers, ranchers, and many types of business interests. And the forces in favor of renewable energy growth emerge stronger as a result.

I saw this firsthand in my home state of California in 2010, when out-of-state oil interests asked Californians to vote on a ballot measure, Proposition 23, that would have suspended (and in reality, likely killed off) the state’s landmark AB32 greenhouse gas reduction law. When I attended early strategy meetings for the No on 23 campaign, my initial thought was: what a waste of time and money, fighting just to keep what’s already in place.

But then I watched what the campaign did. It brought in big guns from the political center/right (former GOP Cabinet secretary George Shultz) and business (hedge fund billionaire Tom Steyer). Although California’s clean-tech industry had shown solid legislative muscle in the past, perhaps most notably Environmental Entrepreneurs’ work to get AB32 passed in the first place, the No on 23 campaign galvanized the community as never before. It outraised the oil-funded Yes campaign by a wide margin, and on Election Day the measure was defeated in a landslide, 62 to 38 percent. In fact, No on 23 received more votes — nearly six million — than any other ballot measure or candidate across the nation.

Since then, Steyer has devoted most of the past 2½ years to influential advocacy for the economic, employment, environmental, and climate benefits of clean energy. Just yesterday, the Steyer-Taylor Center for Energy Policy and Finance at Stanford (he’s the benefactor) named former New Mexico Sen. Jeff Bingaman, a great clean-energy champion, to lead its initiative to strengthen RPS policies in the states. And AB32 implementation has moved onward, though not without hiccups, but California last year became the first state to put a price on carbon through the auction of carbon credits.

I’m cautiously optimistic that ALEC’s attacks on state RPS laws will similarly backfire. The march of history has always been toward newer, more innovative technologies (as coal and oil once were) — and poll after poll shows that the American people are on board. In a Gallup poll last month asking which energy sources the U.S. should focus most on developing, solar (cited by 76 percent of respondents) and wind (71 percent) topped the charts, followed by natural gas at 65 percent. Trailing far behind were oil (46 percent), nuclear (37 percent) and coal (33 percent).

“I know we have to expend resources just to defend the status quo,” says Rob Sargent, energy program director at Environment America, a federation of state environmental organizations on the front lines of defending RPS mandates. “But I think it strengthens the resolve. It forces the question: do we go forward toward more clean energy, or backwards away from it? And we’re starting to see that there are very few people that don’t like it except those with an immediate stake in selling more fossil fuels.”

We should never underestimate the forces against progress, and the current initiatives against RPS laws bear close scrutiny and strong action in states across the country. But I think clean energy will emerge stronger in the end. On this issue, history is on our side.

One quick personal postscript: 10 years and one day ago, I drove a brand-new 2003 Toyota Prius off the lot in Novato, California. One decade, a few dings, and about 83,000 miles later, it’s still going strong — sharing the roads with thousands of much newer Priuses, other hybrids, and more than a few Chevy Volts and Nissan LEAFs. That is just the kind of historical progress I’m talking about.

Lead image: Watch on notebook via Shutterstock

Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox - FREE!

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World Magazine and our award-winning e-Newsletter to stay up to date on current news and industry trends.

 Subscribe Now



EIB Links Green Bonds to Projects in Second Push for Climate

Anna Hirtenstein, Bloomberg The European Investment Bank is the first issuer to link its individual green bonds to the projects they finance in a...

SolarCity Lays Claim to ‘World’s Most Efficient Rooftop Solar Panel’

Jennifer Delony SolarCity in an Oct. 2 announcement said that it will begin production this month on what the company claims is the “...

Global Forecast: Solar Installation Capacity To Top 57 GW in 2015

Renewable Energy World Editors Solar installations globally could grow by between 25 percent and 30 percent in 2015 compared to last year, according...
solar power

APS Requesting Proposals for New Large-scale Solar Power Plant

PennEnergy Editors Arizona Public Service (APS) on Oct. 1 announced it is issuing a request for proposals (RFP) to test the market for n...

PRESS RELEASES Welcomes Jennifer Delony as Associate Editor

PennWell Corporation is pleased to announce that Jennifer Delony has joined the company...

Customized Energy Solutions Executes Agreement with the Massachusetts Clean Energy Center (“MassCEC”) and the Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources (“DOER”) for Important Energy Storage Study

Customized Energy Solutions (CES) has entered into agreements with Massachusetts Clean ...

CleanTX Releases New White Paper on the Future of Texas Solar in Texas

We love this new White Paper from our clean energy partners CleanTX

Sun Xtender® Launches New Website at

The newly designed website for Sun Xtender solar batteries is now live on the World Wid...


energy efficiency

Beyond the Trend: Maximizing the Impact of Your Energy Efficiency Solution

A revolution is happening in the energy sector. From the new regulations pushed out earlier this summer by the EPA’s ...

Northeast States Create Cap-and-Trade Program for Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Northeast states have worked together for several decades to address air quality issues and, more recently, climate c...

Why the Solar PV Industry Should Love Geothermal Heat Pumps Pt 2

It’s a marriage made in heaven: Solar PV and Geothermal Heat Pumps Part 2 of a 6-Part Series Prevailing Heati...

Park District Goes Solar, Saves Big While Preserving Open Space

Not only do community parks provide green space for recreation and leisure, they also increase property values, attra...



Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



Certified PV Professional - online training

After completing this online training, participants will be able to unde...

Applying Renewable Energy - Online Training

RENAC Online offers a selection of courses on a wide variety of renewabl...

CRGM - Online Training on Grid Integration of Renewable Energy

The training is useful for persons who would like to learn more about me...


Investor Relations Research

Those of you who have been reading this blog for a while or have taken a...

New State Study Demonstrates Net Metering Benefit for Ratepayers

The body of evidence that demonstrates the benefits of solar net meterin...

Community Solar Allows Utilities to Adapt, Thrive as Energy Landsca...

Adaptability is the key to survival — both in nature as Charles Da...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now