The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

Energy Market Uncertainty Boiling Up in Texas

Texas is an energy powerhouse. It dwarfs nearly every other state in total production on both a British thermal unit (BTU) and kilowatt-hour (kWh) basis. Yet the Energy Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) is reportedly facing a looming problem of shrinking capacity reserve margins thanks to peak electricity load growth outpacing new capacity additions. According to energy analysts, low energy prices and unfavorable future market conditions are not encouraging additional peaker generation capacity to be built.

To address the issue, the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) has enacted a number of rules which include raising the maximum amount the market will pay for power during scarcity pricing scenarios — known as the system-wide offer cap (SWOC). On August 1, 2012 the SWOC was raised for the second time this year and now sits at $4,500 per megawatt-hour (MWh). While some are concerned this could lead to market manipulation, the PUC's goals appear to be centered around improving "forward price signals" for new peaker generation investments. In fact, ERCOT published analysis on the effects of the rule changes on peaker net margins (PNMs) in 2011. As shown below PNMs would have improved 42% in 2011 with the new rule changes that just went into effect ($4,500/MWh SWOC).

Given the difficulty in predicting future spot-market pricing scenarios and market behavior, there is broad disagreement over both the rules' proposed levels and implications. Commissioner Anderson cautioned against increasing the SWOC again so soon after it was raised, whereas a recent report by the Brattle Group found ERCOT would still need "several thousand megawatts [of demand response] under a $9,000 price cap."

Although discussions of major market construct changes could discourage investment due to uncertainty, a major challenge facing ERCOT could be the construct of the market itself. The "energy-only" construct only pays resources for the energy and ancillary services they deliver, not installed capacity, making it difficult for investors to calculate the bankability of such infrequently called upon assets, according to Midwest ISO Discussion Paper on Resource Adequacy for the Midwest IS0 Energy Market.

Earlier comments filed with the PUCT by the multi-state energy company Exelon suggested, "there is no perfect adjustment to the energy-only market [because it] is inherently short term and volatile, and generation investment is inherently long term and capital intensive."

Former DOE assistant secretary Susan Tierney believes capacity markets make more sense. In a recent keynote address to the Gulf Coast Power Association, she noted, "A competitive capacity market allows for provision of capacity as efficiently as possible…and allows time for the winners of the capacity auction to bring their resources online." She also went on to say, "a capacity market can induce…distributed generation."

But what about "energy-only" markets such as ERCOT? Can they not also encourage distributed generation (DG)?

Energy-only markets clearly favor dispatchable power when spot prices skyrocket. But the uncertainty of these occurrences favors a more risk averse — and therefore more protracted — investment strategy which can include the development of smaller, more scalable, load-following solar generation. As evidenced by the lack of gas peaker development in ERCOT, market uncertainty is the antithesis of long-term, capital intensive projects.

Most importantly, the unintended market consequences of the PUCT’s new rules should not be ignored. Although the intent may be to improve peaker net margins, the rules could actually end up encouraging more demand-side curtailment instead.  Which means flexibility is key. Those who can most effectively predict or react fastest to the new rules will be the ones ensuring themselves a nice Texas-sized payday.

This article was originally published on NREL Renewable Energy Finance and was republished with permission.

Lead image: Texas flag via Shutterstock

Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox - FREE!

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World Magazine and our award-winning e-Newsletter to stay up to date on current news and industry trends.

 Subscribe Now



Evaluating the Case for Module-Level Shutdown

Hannes Knopf With 2014 NEC adoption in full swing, many are anticipating what the next version of the code will hold for the PV in...

A Case Study in Energy-Transition Momentum

Tim King South Australia is clearly at the forefront of the global energy transition as it establishes a fast-moving model oth...

Listen Up: Can I Get Solar if my Roof is Shaded?

The Energy Show on Renewable Energy World Rooftop solar panels only work when they are in direct sunlight. So if you have a partially shaded roof, the output o...

US Senate Democrats Unveil Energy Bill That Restores PTC and Extends ITC

Brian Eckhouse, Bloomberg Senate Democrats unveiled a bill that would provide more tax credits for renewable energy while killing some tax ince...


Array Technologies Finalizes Shipments to E.ON’s Maricopa West Solar Project

Array Technologies, Inc. (ATI) has completed DuraTrack® HZ shipments to the 20 MW (ac) ...

Power Engineering and Renewable Energy World Magazines Name Projects of the Year Awards Finalists

Tulsa, Okla. and Nashua, N.H., Oct. 5, 2015 -- The editors of Power Engineering and Ren...

Sun Xtender® Launches New Website at

The newly designed website for Sun Xtender solar batteries is now live on the World Wid...

Canadian Solar Closes Purchase of Ontario Assets from KKR

Canadian Solar Purchased 3 Solar Power Plants Totaling 59.8 MW AC from KKR


energy efficiency

Beyond the Trend: Maximizing the Impact of Your Energy Efficiency Solution

A revolution is happening in the energy sector. From the new regulations pushed out earlier this summer by the EPA’s ...

Why the Solar PV Industry Should Love Geothermal Heat Pumps Pt 2

It’s a marriage made in heaven: Solar PV and Geothermal Heat Pumps Part 2 of a 6-Part Series Prevailing Heati...

The Whirlwind Known As Tradeshow Season 2015

Wow. What a tradeshow season 2015 is turning out to be! Hot on the heels of Intersolar and SPI, next week we’re...


Ryan Hubbell is a Research Program Participant with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s project finance team. He has an MBA with concentration in renewable energy development in addition to numerous years of experience in corporate finance ...


Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



Successfully Integrating Solar: A Proactive Approach

•      What does the increasing solar penetrati...

Solar Power Asset Management and Performance

SEIA and SEPA collaborated with industry leaders to present the first ev...

Solar Power Northeast

  From the team that produced Solar Power Southeast and the sol...


Fast facts: 4 things you need to know about the state of solar fina...

Fast facts: 4 things you need to know about the state of solar financing...

10 Questions You Should Be Asking

Tony Robbins is fond of saying that the quality of your life is directly...

Join us at the New Solar Power Northeast

From the team that produced Solar Power Southeast and the sold out P...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now