The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

PACE: Not Dead, Just Sleeping

Regular readers must be well aware of the fraught history of Property-assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs. We've been writing about this excellent new way of financing small-scale solar installations since January 2009, not long after the first PACE program was instituted in Berkeley, Calif.

Following Berkeley’s success, 27 states passed PACE-enabling legislation, clearing the way for local governments to create programs in which:

  • The government entity raises funds, ideally from tax-free clean energy bonds;
  • Homeowners and business owners can apply to use those funds for renewable energy or energy efficiency installations;
  • The solar arrays (for example) are installed at no cost to the owner;
  • The owner repays the lending agency through regular property tax assessments over an extended period, e.g., 20 years;
  • Should the owner sell the property before the installation is paid for, the balance of the tax assessment is applied to the new owner.

Of course, for every idea that catches fire there’s someone waiting with a bucket of water, and in this case it was the Federal Housing Finance Authority (FHFA), the overlord of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. FHFA considered the financial arrangement not a tax assessment but a loan, and thus could not stomach the notion that its mortgage operations would lose their senior lien position to a local authority. Last summer, then, FHFA instructed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac not to underwrite mortgages for properties with a PACE assessment. Given the large number of home mortgages that end up being sold to these government mortgage agencies, FHFA’s action effectively killed the entire PACE movement.

Fighting Back

Behind the scenes, a lot of individuals and organizations quickly started working to restore this wildly popular program. Rep. Mike Thompson (D-CA) tried to introduce a bill late last year to address FHFA’s concerns and kick-start PACE programs, but it became lost in the usual Congressional December maelstrom. This year his bill, with key modifications, has gathered strength and bipartisan support, and in a different form was introduced in Congress last week.

Characteristically, however, the Green Mountain State didn’t wait for Congress to get its act in gear. During the legislative session that ended in late May, the Vermont legislature passed a bill that has apparently satisfied the FHFA’s concerns, and will become effective on Jan. 1. 

The new law establishes two funds to support PACE programs in the state, neither of which impacts the public purse. One will be fed by a 2 percent fee that participating property owners must pay, while the other will be supported with money from the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative that originated as system benefit charges paid by ratepayers. Since the law confirms that liens associated with PACE assessments will be secondary to those of FHFA-backed mortgages, the funds provide a large measure of security for investors in PACE programs. It’s thought by Vermont lawmakers, with the agreement of FHFA, that these funds will be sufficient to guard against potential mortgage defaults; this means that communities across the state can establish special tax districts within which PACE programs can be launched with the blessing of the federal government mortgage agencies.

Moving from Montpelier to Washington, D.C., we find a scintilla of hope in the successor to Thompson’s bill, the newly introduced PACE Protection Act of 2011 (HR2599). The bill, introduced by Rep. Nan Hayworth of New York and co-sponsored by Thompson, Dan Lungren and Lois Capps of California, has picked up another dozen truly bipartisan co-sponsors from across the country. The bill would prevent the FHFA from adopting policies that work against local PACE laws, so long as certain provisions applied to applicants, e.g:

  • the proposed energy efficiency or renewable energy installation could not cost more than 10 percent of the value of the property;
  • the property owner had more than 15 percent equity in the property;
  • PACE-financed projects have positive savings-to-investment ratios.

What’s Not to Like?

It’s too early to tell whether the bill has any chance of passage in the penumbral state of Congressional rationale that drives legislative debate today, but there should be enough points of illumination in it to find favor on both sides of the aisle. PACE programs are not a burden to taxpayers or government budgets, they do not represent government mandates, and they don’t disadvantage any one group in favor of another. They do, however, leverage private capital, create a continuing stream of local jobs, save homeowners money and reduce fossil fuel usage. In short, they come dressed in a mantle of “what’s not to like?”

And that’s a question that must have been pointedly asked of FHFA Acting Director Edward DeMarco last year. We expect it was, in effect, asked by the Department of Energy when they offered FHFA a loan guarantee reserve of $150 million to keep PACE programs alive.  Whatever answer DeMarco gave then, it was ephemeral, for only days later he issued his order to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac that killed the programs. Yet the answer, as we can see from the details of the Vermont and Congressional bills, was always simple and always within the power of the parties to propose and to accept – a full year ago.  There appears to have been no interest from FHFA’s side in doing either.

It can be agreed that FHFA had legitimate concerns about lien priorities, especially during the current pandemic of mortgage defaults, and wanted to protect its agencies from excessive risk; as Peter Adamczyk of the Vermont Energy Investment Corporation puts it: “PACE has been described as the best possible program introduced at the worst possible time.” But by steadfastly refusing to countenance any negotiated remedy that would allow a program that was favored in most states to continue, FHFA was exhibiting a somewhat more disconcerting mindset: that of not valuing, or even understanding, the importance of what it was killing.

To those of us with some level of understanding of the benefits of renewables, it’s natural to expect to make accommodations and adjustments if we want to see more of them deployed. But if those benefits don’t resonate with you, if they don’t even rise over your visibility threshold, any concern expressed by others must qualify as Much Ado About Nothing. 

It must have been a lot simpler for FHFA management to take the bankers’ approach and see only the fiscal argument than to use a little imagination and accommodate the future.

By doing so, the agency even misread the fiscal argument. The rate of defaults on homes with PACE assessments is less than .08 percent, about one-30th of the national rate. Efficiency upgrades and solar installations lower the cost of living, making owners less, rather than more, likely to default. Put another way, as conventional energy sources become increasingly expensive, homeowners may be put in the position of choosing between making their mortgage payments or avoiding freezing in winter. With “strategic mortgage defaults” becoming more and more a budget management technique of underwater mortgagors, one would think the body responsible for the solvency of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would itself have been a little more responsible.

And meanwhile, the PACE Assessment Protection Act of 2011 has at least made it into the House of Representatives and been referred to the Committee on Financial Services. 

You can find out more about PACE, how it works, and its benefits to the nation, property owners, lenders and local governments.  You can also send a message to your Congressperson from this site, calling for a positive vote on HR2599.

Untitled Document

RELATED ARTICLES

Solar Shipments in Japan Drop First Time Since 2012 Incentives

Chisaki Watanabe, Bloomberg Shipments of solar panels in Japan fell 13 percent in the three months to June 30, a sign the market may be cooling t...

Fossil Fuels Losing Cost Advantage Over Solar, Wind, IEA Says

Tara Patel, Bloomberg The cost of producing electricity from renewable sources such as solar and wind has dropped significantly over the pa...

How India Goes Solar Could Change the World

Susan Kraemer, Correspondent Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s proposals for a draft National Renewable Energy Act raising renewable deploymen...

Listen Up: Questions You May Ask About Rooftop Solar

The Energy Show on Renewable Energy World I’ve spent a lot of time over the past 15 years talking to homeowners about rooftop solar. More kitchen table chats a...

PRESS RELEASES

Canadian Solar Announces Partnership in 200 MW Tranquility Solar Power Project

Recurrent Energy signed an agreement with Southern Power to partner on the Tranquility ...

AWS Truepower Announces Major Expansion of its Due Diligence Team in Response to Growing Market Demand

AWS Truepower, an international leader in wind and solar energy consulting and engineer...

20 days to GRC Annual Meeting & GEA Geothermal Energy Expo

The Geothermal Resources Council (GRC) has announced that it is only 20 days to go to t...

Array Technologies’ DuraTrack HZ v3 Continues to (R)evolutionize at SPI

Array Technologies, Inc. (ATI) prepares to showcase its recently launched tracking syst...

FEATURED BLOGS

NATiVE Recognized for Excellence at 2015 Greater Austin Business Awards

NATiVE Recognized for Excellence at 2015 Greater Austin Business Awards NEWS RELEASE AUSTIN, Texas – Aug. 27...

Solar Energy Means Jobs, Savings, and a Low-Cost Future [infographic]

There are a lot of utility-sponsored legislative and regulatory attacks on solar energy lately, and we put together t...

How To Get People To Do Stuff

It’s no secret that psychology and sales go hand in hand. If you understand the principles of human psychology ...

Get In The Groove

When we talk about strategies for boosting productivity, we often overlook the fact certain projects lend themselves ...

FINANCIAL NEWS

CURRENT MAGAZINE ISSUE

Volume 18, Issue 4
1507REW_C11

STAY CONNECTED

To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon

FEATURED PARTNERS



EVENTS

Successfully Integrating Solar: A Proactive Approach

In this complimentary webcast, join DNV GL for a comprehensive look at a...

Solar Power International 2015

  Please visit Panasonic Eco Solutions at Booth #4500   SPI G...

1-1/2 Day Photovoltaic System Fundamentals Workshop

Participants will learn how to assess the solar resources available at a...

COMPANY BLOGS

The Perfect Elevator Pitch

The elevator pitch is a concise statement that grabs attention and commu...

3 Reasons To Follow-Up

It’s very important to begin nurturing your relationship with a cu...

LSX crowns the Jewel of Kahana

Located on Maui, Hawaii, the Jewel of Kahana is a beautiful ma...

NEWSLETTERS

Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now  

 

FEATURED PARTNERS