The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

Solar Takes Wind in Test

Blustery gusts keep a wind turbine spinning at Inland Power and Light's corporate headquarters on the West Plains, but solar panels are the real powerhouse at the utility's alternative energy pilot project.

The solar panels have produced about five times as much electricity as the wind turbine over the past 14 months. The sun’s ability to generate more electricity than the wind – even during short winter days – has surprised the utility’s engineers.

“Solar,” said Richard Damiano, the utility’s chief engineer, “is trouncing wind.”

Inland Power set up the experiment to help the utility customers compare alternative-energy options for their homes. Each year, the utility fields from 50 to 60 calls from people interested in producing some of their own electricity. Initially, most think they want a wind turbine, Damiano said.

To help customers with the analysis, Inland Power officials decided to collect their own data.

The utility bought a 35-foot wind turbine and a bank of solar panels. The systems are representative of technology scaled to individual homeowner use, Damiano said. Each cost from $22,000 to $24,000 to install.

Conventional thinking suggested that wind turbines would outperform solar panels, particularly on gray winter days.

“It’s the West Plains, so there’s a perception that the wind is always blowing,” Damiano said.

But wind is more erratic than people realize, he said. The wind dies down, for instance, during hot weather and cold spells. Inland Power’s turbine is similar to the larger ones installed in the Columbia River Gorge. It needs a stiff breeze of around 12 miles per hour to start producing electricity.

Solar panels, on the other hand, generate a certain amount of electricity even on cloudy days.

During the first 13 days of January, Inland Power’s solar panels produced 35 kilowatt-hours of electricity, compared with 10 kilowatt-hours from wind generation.

The results don’t surprise Linda Finney, who sold the wind turbine to Inland Power. She and her husband initially installed it on a grassy hill above their home on the Palouse Highway, about 12 miles south of Spokane. After two years, they took the turbine down because it wasn’t generating the results they hoped for, and they replaced it with 16 solar panels.

At certain times of the year, “our meter runs backwards,” said Finney, executive director of Leadership Spokane. “We’re banking energy during the summer months.”

Damiano said some customers do the research and still end up with wind turbines. In areas heavily shaded by trees, for instance, wind turbines can outperform solar panels.

In the Inland Power pilot project, the solar panels produced about 15 percent of a typical household’s electric needs over the course of a year. The wind turbine produced less than 3 percent.

From a cost-benefit standpoint, erecting a wind turbine or putting in solar panels is still a reach for most homeowners, Damiano said. Those who take the plunge are making a lifestyle choice to reduce their carbon footprint, he said. Recovering the installation costs for turbines or solar panels can take years, even with the 30 percent tax subsidy available to homeowners.

“It will take you a chunk of time,” Finney acknowledged. But she encourages people to think about the long-term benefits.

“Some people spend $25,000 on a new car,” she said. “We decided this is how we wanted to live and how we wanted to spend our money.”

Becky Kramer is a reporter for The Spokesman-Review in the Idaho department. She covers the environment, natural resources and utilities.

Copyright 2011.  Reproduced with permission of The Spokesman-Review. Permission is granted in the interest of public discussion and does not imply endorsement of any product, service or organization otherwise mentioned herein.

Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox - FREE!

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World Magazine and our award-winning e-Newsletter to stay up to date on current news and industry trends.

 Subscribe Now



Solar to Play ‘Lead Role’ in Vermont RE Standard Compliance

Jennifer Delony New distributed generation solar power facilities of 5 MW or less likely will play a “lead role” in Green Mountain Po...

United PV Turns to Crowdfunding After Stocks in China Plunge

Feifei Shen, Bloomberg United Photovoltaics Group Ltd., a Chinese solar farm operator, said it will use crowdfunding to raise money for its ...

Digging Deeper, Why Renewables are Beating Coal and Gas in Some Parts of the World

Jennifer Runyon Earlier this month Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF) announced findings that the LCOE for wind and solar is now che...

Russia Turns to Sun, Wind to Improve Electricity Supply for Country’s Far East

Vladislav Vorotnikov Russian company RAO ES East will construct 178 renewable energy facilities with a total capacity of 146 MW within the...


Solar Power World Ranks Florida Solar One a Top 400 Solar Installer

Florida Solar One, a Miami Fort Lauderdale solar contractor is ranked among the top sol...

Niner Wine Estates Powers 100 Percent of Winery Operations with REC Solar

The 388 KW solar system installed by REC Solar will pay for itself in approximately fiv...

AWS Truepower Makes Wind Project Design More Effective with Less Effort with New Openwind® Version

AWS Truepower, LLC, an international leader in renewable energy consulting and informat...

US Solar Institute Chosen for Military Solar Training at Patrick Air Force Base

In August 2015, the Air Force chose The US Solar Institute (USSI) for a specialized sol...



Geothermal Visual: GEA, Clean Energy Organizations Tell Congress: We Need Tax Extenders 'As Soon As Possible'

In a letter dated Oct. 5, over 580 signatories representing clean energy industries, including Geothermal Energy Asso...

It's All About The Why

Why do people buy your product or service? This is a question that you should keep in your mind at all times and remi...

Tracked Community Solar Gardens Bloom

Victor Delgado and his wife Norma had been watching their utility bills slowly climb since they bought their home in ...



Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



Solar + Storage: Capturing Opportunities and Overcoming Challenges ...

The convergence of solar and energy storage applications is under way. T...

UL Photovoltaic (PV) System Installation Certification Exam

UL University and US Solar Institute have partnered to offer the Photovo...

PV-301: Advanced PV Installation

PV301 by The US Solar Institute is comprehensive and highly advanced 40 ...


Tracked Community Solar Gardens Bloom

Victor Delgado and his wife Norma had been watching their utility bills ...

Five Microgrid Powerhouses (Part 2)

Five Microgrid Powerhouses (Part 2)   Last week, we wrote about the...

SimpleGrip: An All New Low-Slope Solution

The crew here at EcoFasten Solar is very excited about th...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now