The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.
Untitled Document

Is IP Standing in the Way of a Green Planet?

The potential of intellectual property rights to impede the cleantech revolution has sparked a lively debate full of heated rhetoric. Secretary of Energy Steven Chu jump-started this discussion last year during a discussion of the Obama administration's goals to promote development of green technologies.

Addressing the importance of international collaboration, Secretary Chu said “we should work very hard in a very collaborative way - by very collaborative I mean share all intellectual property as much as possible.”  This suggestion, extreme on its face, reminds us that IP rights play an important role in the climate change debate and must be meaningfully addressed at a global level. 

The fundamental importance of IP is a maxim of U.S. business echoed throughout the cleantech industry.  The ability to acquire and enforce IP rights allows innovative green start-up companies to spur discovery, attract financing, defend growing markets, and increase revenues.  A new World Economic Forum report Accelerating Successful Smart Grid Pilots discussing the central role of policy-makers and regulators in creating the right conditions for innovation acknowledged that “it is critical that they offer upside to the innovators to allow them to benefit from the intellectual property that they are developing, while encouraging the best practices to be shared and adopted elsewhere.”

Embodying this pro-business pro-IP position is the recently-formed Coalition for Innovation, Development & Employment Alliance (or “IDEA”).  This group, which was launched by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and industry leaders shortly after Secretary’s Chu’s remarks, has the stated mission of “champion[ing] the role of innovation and creativity in creating jobs” by protecting strong intellectual property rights globally.  IDEA urges that the continued growth of the cleantech industry, which has the potention to produce millions of new American jobs, depends on strong IP rights.  The group has lobbied hard to prevent erosion of the U.S. patent system.

In the opposite corner from the “IP fundamentalists” are those who believe that IP rights challenge the deployment of innovative green technologies to developing countries.  Because meeting future global targets for reducing carbon emissions will involve these countries, they should be granted access to the most efficient available technologies by reducing the barriers to use patented technologies.

The perceived tension between relying on strong IP rights to promote cleantech innovations and enabling global access to these technologies has been analogized to the fight for access to patented lifesaving medicines in developing and underdeveloped countries. The international Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs) set out minimum standards for IP regimes for a country to join the World Trade Organization (WTO), and anticipated that in some instances compulsory licensing may be appropriate.  And indeed the Doha Declaration, adopted in 2001, affirms the flexibility of WTO member states to relax patent rights to improve access to essential medicines, and has successfully increased access to HIV drugs.

The fight for increasing the transfer of green technology is being waged within the ongoing United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) meetings.  At the 2010 Copenhagen negotiations, efforts to reach a binding agreement for IP and technology transfer issues were unsuccessful. Although there is consensus that clean technology must be disseminated worldwide, negotiations stalled over IP policies. 

Two of the four options considered involved compulsory licensing proposals, in which a government is given permission to practice a patented invention without the patent owner’s consent.  The U.S. vigorously opposes compulsory licensing  - the House of Representatives even passed a bill in June 2009 to provide for the protection of IP rights of U.S. persons in other countries.  Voluntary licensing schemes, which are more politically viable, are more flexible and allow IP holders to choose to participate.  Other approaches include creating incentives for sharing green technologies, creating common pools into which cleantech companies could devote some IP rights, and creating simplified licenses with reduced terms for sustainable uses of some IP. 

Characterizing the debate for broadened access to cleantech IP as a “battle” unnecessarily amplifies the distance between two imperatives: promoting innovation to develop the technology we need to combat climate change, and ensuring its global implementation.  Between a hardcore compulsory licensing regime and a pure IP fundamentalist approach lies ample room to craft policies which further both of these goals.  If each side listens carefully to the other, there is no reason we can’t find pragmatic ways to structure IP rights to both incentivize research and development and serve the public interest.

Eric Raciti, left, is a partner in the Cambridge, Massachusetts office of Finnegan. Mr. Raciti focuses his practice on intellectual property counseling, particularly in the fields of alternative energy and medical devices. You can learn more about Mr. Raciti by accessing his profile, here.

Nicole Parsons (left), Ph.D., is an Associate at Finnegan. Dr. Parsons’ practices includes client counseling, U.S. and international patent prosecution, portfolio management, and provides infringement, validity, patentability and freedom-to-operate opinions, primarily in life sciences. Dr. Parsons also works on various patent litigation matters.


Untitled Document

Get All the Renewable Energy World News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to Renewable Energy World or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now


Uganda Signs US$95 Million Agreement to Develop 44.7-MW Muzizi Hydroelectric Project

Gregory B. Poindexter Germany’s state controlled KFW Development Bank, the French Development Agency (AFD) and the government of Uganda, si...

Understanding the Yieldco Structure for Renewable Energy Project Finance

Gregory F. Jenner, Edward D. Einowski and Adam D. Schurle, Contributors In the 1950s, the federal government sought to boost home ownership by increasing private lending. To this end, the g...

NHA Recognizes Five Companies as Outstanding Stewards of America's Waters

Five companies have been recognized by the National Hydropower Association as recipients of its Outstanding Stewards ...

India's 330-MW Alaknanda Hydropower Plant Enters Commercial Operation

Indian infrastructure group GVK has put the first unit at its 330-MW Alaknanda hydropower plant into commercial opera...


Array Technologies Finalizes Shipments to E.ON’s Maricopa West Solar Project

Array Technologies, Inc. (ATI) has completed DuraTrack® HZ shipments to the 20 MW (ac) ...

B.C. Energy Minister to provide keynote at renewables for mines summit.

BC Minister of Energy and Mines to address the challenges of providing alternative powe...

Mining leaders seek renewables solutions at Toronto Summit

The global mining sector is facing a tough business environment with low commodity pric...

American Renewable Energy Institute Gears Up for 12th Annual Summit

"Racing Climate Change: Green Bridge with China, The Road to Paris” is the theme of th...


New Mexico Attracts Jobs and Revenues with Renewable Energy Tax Credit

New Mexico has abundant fossil fuel resources: in 2013, it ranked sixth in the nation for crude oil production, seven...

The Vice President Stole My Show (Not Really)

When I finished my Solar Power International (SPI) panel discussing what future opportunities the panelists saw in so...

The Value Of The Building

If you’re selling efficiency solutions in the built environment, you may find yourself being asked by your pros...

Sewage provides energy through processing

Many nations are investing in new technology to turn sewage waste into usable energy. Japan has recently revised its ...



Volume 18, Issue 4


To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:


Tweet the Editors! @jennrunyon



Successfully Integrating Solar: A Proactive Approach

•      What does the increasing solar penetrati...

Doing Business in Europe – in partnership with GWEC, the Global Win...

There is now 128.8 GW of installed wind energy capacity in the EU (appro...

Doing Business in South Africa – in partnership with GWEC, the Glob...

Wind Energy in South Africa has been expanding dramatically, growing fro...


Sell Through Hypothesis

You first learned to hypothesize, or make educated guesses, in grade sch...

Final Program Now Available for GRC Annual Meeting & GEA Geothermal...

GRC Annual Meeting & GEA Geothermal Energy Expo - Final Program f...

Vacancy? No Problem!

Have you ever tried to sell an efficiency product or service to a prospe...


Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now