The World's #1 Renewable Energy Network for News, Information, and Companies.

WFC Grades North American FIT Programs

The World Future Council has issued a report grading North American feed-in tariffs for renewable energy. Only Ontario and Vermont make a passing grade. All other programs in the U.S. and Canada failed to pass.

The report, Grading North American Feed-in Tariffs by renewable energy industry analyst Paul Gipe, compares North American programs to successful policies in Europe. 

Gipe evaluated the programs using ten criteria that have been found critical in creating successful renewable energy policy. He then devised a weighting system to reflect the relative importance of each criterion. Most criteria received 10 points, some less. Tariff differentiation by size or application, a hallmark of successful programs, received 20 points. 

  • Program caps, 10 points 
  • Project size caps, 10 points 
  • Contract terms, 10 points 
  • Technologies included, 10 points 
  • Tariffs based on cost of generation, 10 points 
  • Tariffs differentiated by technology, 10 points 
  • Tariffs differentiated by size or application for each technology, 20 points 
  • Tariffs differentiated by resource intensity for wind energy, 10 points 
  • Inflation indexing, 6 points 
  • Bonus or social adders, 5 points 

Subsequently, Gipe compared the programs found in Germany, France, and Spain. Worldwide, the policies in these countries are considered the gold standard of feed-in tariff design. These programs are top in their class and are known to work well. 

In Gipe's arbitrary grading system, France and Germany each earned 90 points and were both awarded an "A". Spain's program earned slightly less, 80 points, and was awarded an "A-". 

For the report, Gipe then graded the feed-in tariff programs in various U.S. states and Canadian provinces and ranked them. He did not grade municipal programs like that in Gainesville, Florida. 

In the American system of grading "A" is excellent; "B" and "C" are good; "D" is poor, but passing; and "F" is for failing, or unacceptable performance. 

Ontario, which has a sophisticated program modeled after those in Europe, ranked the highest with a total score of 84 points for a grade of "A-". Oregon ranked the lowest with a score of 16 winning it a very solid "F".

Vermont was the only program in the U.S. to pass. Gipe gave Vermont with a score of 54 a "D" for effort and noted that Ontario's first attempt at a feed-in tariff policy, the Standard Offer Contract Program, also qualified for a "D". Most jurisdictions take several attempts to get their programs working right and Vermont is no exception. 

Onetime trendsetter California pulls up the rear with only 28 points. At last count the Golden State's feed-in tariff resulted in the installation of only 14 MW. 

  • Ontario (2009): 84, A- 
  • Vermont: 54, D 
  • Maine: 43, F 
  • Wisconsin IOUs: 36, F 
  • California: 28, F 
  • Oregon: 16, F 

The report also examined proposed legislation in Indiana and California using the same criteria. Indiana's AB 1190 introduced by Representative Matt Pierce qualified for an "A-" with 82 points. California's AB 1106 introduced by Representatives Felipe Fuentes and Ira Ruskin earned only 54 points giving the proposal a "D" grade.  

Click here for more information on the report, World Future Council: Grading North American Feed-in Tariffs.

The World Future Council is an EnNGO based in Hamburg, Germany with offices in Washington, DC and San Francisco, California. 

Gipe is an independent analyst and renewable energy advocate in Bakersfield, California.

RELATED ARTICLES

Renewable energy jobs

Global Renewable Energy Employment Surges 18 Percent to 7.7 Million

Andrew Burger, Correspondent Ongoing growth in renewable energy investment and deployment is creating jobs worldwide — and lots of them. This job growth is helping governments address a fundamental economic problem plaguing developed and developing cou...
GE Digital Wind Farm

GE Introduces Digital Wind Farm that Could Boost Production 20 Percent, Re-ignites Alstom Buyout Talk

Meg Cichon, Associate Editor General Electric (GE) is pushing its wind farms to join the big data revolution with its new Digital Wind Farm, announced this week at Windpower 2015 in Orlando, Fla. amidst talk that its $15 billion offer to buy Alstom’s p...
Wind turbine

Bigger Wind Turbine Towers = Bigger US Development Opportunity

Meg Cichon, Associate Editor Wind energy already accounts for about 5 percent of U.S. electricity generation, which crowned the nation as the global leader in wind production late last year. There is now more than 65 gigawatts (GW) of capacit...
Wind turbines

Wind Energy Is Crucial in the Fight Against Climate Change, Says US Energy Secretary

Meg Cichon, Associate Editor

The opening general session at Windpower 2015 marked the first appearance by an U.S. energy secretary at the show, “which is surprising,” said current energy secretary Ernest Moniz, “but better late than never.”

CURRENT MAGAZINE ISSUE

Volume 18, Issue 3
1505REW_C11

STAY CONNECTED

To register for our free
e-Newsletters, subscribe today:

SOCIAL ACTIVITY

Tweet the Editors! @megcichon @jennrunyon

FEATURED PARTNERS



EVENTS

Doing Business in Brazil – in partnership with GWEC, the Global Win...

Brazil is one of the most promising markets for wind energy.  Ranke...

EU PVSEC 2015 (European PV Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition)

The EU PVSEC is the largest international Conference for Photovoltaic re...

More Power, More Profit Tour - Secaucus

SMA’s More Power, More Profit Tour is aimed to provide highly-valu...

COMPANY BLOGS

The Outlook for Midwest Solar

Our whirlwind solar conference tour continues! Yesterday we touched down...

Substrate Feeder for Biogas Facilities

RUD manufactures complete, ready-to-use conveyor systems for transportin...

Well, Hello There Southeast — We Are Excited To Be Here

We’ve traveled 651 miles into the heart of the Deep South to atten...

NEWSLETTERS

Renewable Energy: Subscribe Now

Solar Energy: Subscribe Now

Wind Energy: Subscribe Now

Geothermal Energy: Subscribe Now

Bioenergy: Subscribe Now  

 

FEATURED PARTNERS